I spent much of my adult life avoiding living with my parents. While some of my fellow Italian family members opted to stay with their folks until getting married, I left home and went to college out of state as soon as I could. Then I moved clear across the country to L.A. Now I've settled about 200 miles away from home in New York City. It's not that I don't love my parents. I love them so much that I moved back to the East Coast so I could be within driving distance of Boston, where they live. The thing is, despite the fact that immigrant families find it culturally acceptable to stay with your parents pretty much forever, I wanted to truly embrace the ways of my American peers and be independent. Which is why living next door to my boyfriend's mom for the past year has been both uncomfortable and comforting.
I moved in last January. After bopping around between three crappy apartments within eight months I decided it made the most sense to shack up with my beau. I mean I was there 99 percent of the time anyway, it only made sense that I live there, right? However, my boyfriend had never lived with a girl, let alone in an apartment next to his Christian minister mom, who didn't exactly approve of shacking up before tying the knot. But her love for her son (and for his amazing girlfriend) outweighed her traditional values, and, with her blessing, I moved in.
I didn't think families could be more tight-knit than mine until I met my boyfriend's Indian family. It seemed the percentage of Indian-American kids living with or right near their immigrant parents was even greater than the number of Italians I knew who still hung on to that ethnic umbilical cord.
I wasn't turned off by the fact that he lived next door to his mama. Actually, I was attracted to the fact that he is so close with his family since this was a cultural value I was familiar with, and especially since part of his reasoning was that he wanted to take care of his mom now that his father is gone (his dad passed away five years ago). A guy with strong family ties + he loves his mom + he doesn't think my loud, ethnic family is weird 'cause he has a loud, ethnic family of his own? Seems like a dream, right?
Well, sorta. Despite the warm, fuzzy nostalgia I felt being around a motherly figure with an accent who would remind me to "bring an umbrella 'cause it looks like rain", being in such close proximity to anyone's mom, especially your significant other's, can sometimes be annoying.
Now, just to clarify: We live next door to his mom, not with his mom. We are in a separate apartment, with our own door. A door that is about two feet from her door. A door that is connected to very thin walls. A door that isn't always locked because we have a dog, and sometimes she comes in to take care of the dog, and sometimes we forget to lock it again when I'm, oh I dunno, coming out of the shower sans towel because I think it's cute to do my "just got outta the shower" dance in front of the TV while my boyfriend is watching football and then ... oopsies, Mom walks in.
Luckily I have pretty quick reflexes. In addition to almost seeing my crotch, his mom has been known to pop in during arguments, sex, and when we aren't home to help herself to MY jar of baby pickles. For the most part though, she's been pretty respectful of our privacy, more so than I thought a mom could be. But she is still a mom, which means her son acts like her little son when certain issues arise.
What I'm trying to say here is I've heard my boyfriend whine "Mmmmmmmmmmmooooooooooommmmmmmmmmmmmmm!" more times than any lover should. It's not his fault; I think most adults can agree that no matter what age you are, when talking to your parents, your life-is-so-unfair teenager voice often comes out. It's high-pitched, it can cause infantile foot stomping, and it's decidedly unsexy. On anyone.
You know what is sexy though? A washer and dryer -- and his mom has both, which means I get to use them! Other sexy stuff? Storage space in her garage, cold medicine brought to my bedside when I'm sick, and more homemade shrimp curry than I ever thought I'd eat in my life. There are perks to being in close proximity to a mom and tender loving care is certainly one of them.
After many years of independent living, I kind of needed a break. It feels nice to be mothered once in a while and to have someone nearby who will listen to me cry and make me dinner when I've had a rough day. Strangely enough, his mom's chicken biryani has the same medicinal affects on my heart and soul as my mom's pasta and meatballs. (There must be some kind of cooking ingredient that only mothers can access.)
It also comforts my own mom to know that there is another mom near me, looking out for me, loving me. Whenever I've fought my mom's smothering and over-protective ways she always said "you'll never know what it's like till you have kids of your own." And she's right: I can't imagine what it's like to send your little baby, no matter if she is thirteen or thirty, out into the big bad world without Mommy to protect them.
Even though I'm an "adult" my mom feels good knowing I have a real "grown-up" around to help me out. And I think in many ways it comforts my boyfriend's mom because she doesn't have daughters. So there I am to loan her nail polish remover, give her opinions on outfits, and listen to her bitch about what some lady said behind her back at the church meeting.
After an incredibly rough financial year (for both me and boyfriend), I have really learned to appreciate my living situation. Our landlord is kind, generous, and doesn't freak out if our rent is late (or even paid for that matter). I resisted ever living so close to family because I wanted to prove how mature and strong I was, but true maturity and strength is asking for help when you need it and accepting support from those willing and happy to give it.
So right now, for a little bit, I'm not living the independent life I dreamed of, so what? While I don't want to live next door to anyone's parents for the rest of my life, for right now I am going to be grateful for this period of comfort and mothering. I spent a long time resisting my close-knit, loud, and often smothering ethnic roots, but those roots are pretty cozy and the food is delicious.
Giulia Rozzi is a New York City–based comedian, actress and writer currently at work on a memoir about ethnicity and relationships. She enjoys making lasagna for her boyfriend's family while munching on samosas.












Comments:
Add a comment
Wednesday 08 December
By Marjorie Taylor
That is not exactly true powerofgoodebay. I am not close to my parents at all. First off, I was never really close to my father and he passed away several years ago. Second, I am not close to my mother and never have been. I am pretty much a loner and since I got married I'm not even close to my husbands mother at all. As a matter of fact he isn't close to his own mother either. There are some of us that don't have the close family bonds that others have. So you can't say that everyone is close to family when they aren't. Sorry to burst your bubble on this but hey that's how things are. I'm not really close to anyone for that matter. I've had too much disappoints and stuff happen in my life that I just can't get close to someone no matter how hard I try. I guess you could say that I have several issues in that subject.
Wednesday 08 December
By Claudia Menendez
This article made my day, it kinda hit home to stuff that I deal/dealt with and it was nice to read someone else going thru it...thanks, I really enjoyed it!
Reply
Wednesday 08 December
By andrea chermark
i loved this article. i always lived with my parents. they were there for me to help me when i was 16 and had my first child. i never left my parents. my dad passed away and it was me my mom and my 2 boys. i dont know what i would of done without them. she passed away almost 3 years ago, theres not a day that goes by that i dont cry for her. i am very close with my 2 sons who live in hoboken i live in hasbrouck heights, my one son works in rutherford every chance i get to see him i go and bring him dinner. there is nothing like having a close relationship to your children. my boyfriend doesnt understand why i help them sometimes, but i dont care what he says. ill always be there for them as my parents were for me. if my boys could live with me believe me i would take them in. thanks for this article im going to show it to my boyfriend.
Thursday 16 December
By Loren
Dido, Great article
Thursday 16 December
By wtf
@Majorie taylor: yes we can all say that you DO have issues, what they are is none of our business, but issues it is. You say you are not close to anyone but you are married. Where does you husband fall in the closeness issue? My take on everything is that you are not close to anyone because you chose not to be. That is so sad.
Wednesday 08 December
By Denizio
And I needed to know this because...........
Reply
Wednesday 08 December
By Jasmine
You exactly did not need to know this. Maybe she thought she could help other people with her story.
Thursday 16 December
By New York
You saw the title of this story . If you weren't interested, why did you read it???
Wednesday 08 December
By tiredofwomensbs
I am right there with you!!! "...after years of independent living, I kind of needed a break"! Wow...if only I was allowed to have that kind of attitude w/o being labeled a deadbeat loser. American women have a defiinite sense of entitlement. Pathetic. We need REAL equality and SOON!!!
Reply
Wednesday 08 December
By tim
I did'nt read the whole story, but she's a real hottie!
Reply
Wednesday 08 December
By bjcsoccer13
i agree
Wednesday 08 December
By optimist
This article sucks on so many levels.
Reply
Wednesday 08 December
By Julie
I purchased a house across the street and down 4 houses from my parents. It wasn't because I wanted to live close, it was becuase it was a hice house which was available for a reasonable price and the seller hadn't even put it on the market yet. THAT was 15 years ago and it has been an iteresting ride. My parents have supported me through a lot of good AND bad times. They were there for me when I left my husband and moved to a city 8 miles away. They were there for me when I took the house away from my ex-husband, because he was going to default on the mortgage, and moved back into a home I thought I never wanted to step foot in again. My parents are both in their 70s and they are now my (PAID) daycare for my 3 year-old son. They LOVE having their daughter and grandsons living so close. Don't get me wrong....sometimes the privacy is next to NONE, but I wouldn't trade my parents for anything. Love you Mom & Dad!!!!!!
Reply
Wednesday 08 December
By Aboona Joe
What was the purpose of this UTTERLY inane article? Just to flaunt shackin' up?
Reply
Thursday 16 December
By Grandma
I agree with you. The whole situation is idiotic. Shacking up is sick, traipsing around in the buff when the boyfriend's mother may just walk in at any moment, is sick. And giving out TMI is also sick. She needs to grow up and get a real life!
Thursday 16 December
By crickett
Today's society has been so desensitized to any form of morality that it means nothing to sleep with several different people, move in with this one, move out...
do it all again....dishonoring themselves to the point of nothing is sacred and don't even realize what they are doing to themselves...to be respected you must respect yourself and put a value on yourself and stick with it...
Wednesday 08 December
By candida bond
She doesn't know how good she has it. Quit complaining.
Reply
Wednesday 08 December
By Irish Rose
I agree. I also think that she needs to rethink her beliefs and figure out that to succeed she needs to have more respect for her parents and her "boyfriends" mom. She needs to remember that corny one...no man is an island.. It takes a community of people to make a successful family. I hope that she sees this and figures it out. I did but it was way too late when I finally did and I am still cleaning up the mess that came about because of my so called independence.
Thursday 09 December
By charlie
This is beautifully expressed. Well written. I have to say I think the author has a bundle of things going on in heart and mind. I feel the relationship with boyfriend hasn't been mentioned much...but perhaps only because that was not so much the focus of the article and she is wisely being focused. Giulia, I think you have a battle going on in your heart and mind. Love/perhaps marriage soon/children/home. Freedom. Maturely living with boyfriend. Mistaking that for freedom in this case since it is "away from nuclear family". Yet still in the midst of the "same ol' same ol'". Perhaps you don't really want that freedom. Perhaps you don't really want that group living situation. Perhaps you're trying to rectify it all and see if maybe it really is okay to live as your parents did. It's a tough time. You're part of what I call the crossover generation, the first generation to put your feet in the water to cross from 'other country' traditional ways to American ways. The thing is we so often want to go whole hog about it. Perhaps there is some middle road. But don't stay in anything just because it's familiar.
Reply
Wednesday 08 December
By KMH
I agree with Denizio. Also, she starts out as if we are going to read how bad it sure is, but oooops, she loves it.
Reply