When I announced on my blog that I didn't believe in marriage, I expected the typical reactions: Don't you want a ring and proposal? (No.) Will you ever trust your partner's commitment to you? (Yes.) What about children? (What about them?) I got those questions, along with some comments in support of my views. But what I didn't quite anticipate was that a random commenter would insinuate my beliefs were "f**ked up" because of the way I was raised.
CNN published a piece last spring suggesting that single mothers are teaching their daughters to embrace independence by staying single, but I wonder just how true that is. My mother, who was in an unhappy marriage for nearly 20 years, has always wanted me to be in the kind of relationship she didn't have. A fiercely independent woman herself, she recognizes that self-sufficiency is important, but it doesn't mean that one has to do without love.
My parents grew up in poverty and married in China with the understanding that my father would first seek his fortune in America before coming back to take my mother with him. I know that their marriage was not without love, but I also know that my mother's understanding of it is different from mine.
Throughout college, I dated with reckless abandon, looking not for stability but for a partner who "got me." My mother never did understand what I expected from my relationships. For my parents, love was a luxury that they could not even begin to comprehend after a childhood without potable water or meat. Marriage meant stability, but it didn't mean passion. After they immigrated to America, they slowly began to make a living and a life together.
They first had me, then my sister, and soon it became clear -- to just about everyone in my family -- that they were incompatible as life partners. Yet both sets of grandparents were insistent that my parents stay together for the sake of tradition and family honor. For a time, my parents did stay together because of financial considerations. Their impoverishment a lifetime ago was still too recent a memory. But eventually, as family finances became more stable and the living situation untenable, my mother initiated divorce proceedings. In doing so, she took control of both her happiness and my father's. Nobody but the children knew until the ink was dry.
Today, my parents are more content without having to live together, their respective families have more or less come to terms with their separation, and they are perhaps the most cordial divorced couple I've heard of. Had my mother not acted sooner, I have no doubt that our family life would have deteriorated to the kind of "f**ked up" dynamics the disgruntled commenter referred to. When they both attended my graduation from college last May, I worried about many things, such as how to conceal my sex toys. What I didn't worry about was whether my parents would get pissed at each other and embarrass me in some grand fashion. Now that they don't have to live together, my parents actually like each other. It's as functional as family dysfunction gets.
My mother, despite being divorced, still believes in life partnerships and entertains many romantic ambitions for her two daughters. She's happy that I've found someone with whom I can co-exist for lengthy periods of time. She has also come to accept, despite her deeply conservative upbringing, that it's OK if I don't want to get married; marriage, as she learned firsthand herself, is not necessarily all that it's cracked up to be. We both recognize from personal experience that many marriages don't work out, that simply getting married doesn't imbue relationships with special meaning, and that loving freely is a privilege I have today only because of the sacrifices that my parents made to their personal happiness years ago.
Lena Chen is a freelance writer who reports on sex, feminism and food. The New York Times once called her "a small Asian woman"; she was not amused. Lena's blogging career started during her sophomore year at Harvard University, when she started the infamous Sex and the Ivy blog. For the full story, check out her blog, The Ch!cktionary.













Comments:
Add a comment
Wednesday 15 December
By Evilbeagle
In an effort to criticize another person's life choices, people often make overly simplistic assumptions so that they can self righteously point the finger and whine about the supposedly deteriorating family values. If being honest with oneself and choosing to be independent and single is right for you, then it's no one's business to judge from atop their high horse.
Reply
Wednesday 01 December
By TheGreen
You misunderstand what the commentor meant when he referred to your upbringing. From what you stated he only said your beliefs were "fucked up" not your upbringing. Maybe your parents are happy now, but how did your parents failing relationship affect you? It does not necessarily mean that was the cause but according to the commentor it probably was. That's what he/she was saying. So your whole article disproved nothing and you didn't even look into the reasons as to why single mothers are turning their daughters single. The title was misleading and invalid. Yeah, there is a link, but your article would have been more persuasive if you pointed out what CNN's reasonings were and then disprove them. Anyhow, experience isn't scientifically logical. Hence, your article was illogical and a bad argument at that.
Reply
Wednesday 01 December
By Lena Chen
Actually, the commenter wrote:
"Please state the martial status of your parents and your relatives. Your fucked up views concerning this issue is directly related to your terrible experiences growing up."
So they did actually claim that I don't believe in marriage precisely because I had a "terrible" upbringing.
As far as the CNN article is concerned, the author was also writing a personal essay based on her experiences. Neither of us are trying to suggest that our experience speaks for all other women. I merely explained how being a single mother doesn't mean that you don't want your daughter to also find love.
Wednesday 01 December
By Not sure what point you were trying to get across...
I thought your article was interesting but was confused as to how it actually explained why you don't believe in marriage. Since all you talked about was how dysfunctional your parents marriage was the only conclusion seems to be that you were deeply affected by this and that is what shaped your values regarding marriage. I'm not saying that this is definitely the case, this is just the only reason I draw from your article.
Reply
Wednesday 01 December
By Mauren Matlack
I am a step mom. I am also divorced. Sometims I wish that my ex's wife didn't try to make such a strong statement about being a single mom. Her mom is also a single mom. I really care about this girl. She is holding in so much hurt because of what has bee propelled toward her by her mother with her limited thinking. Oh, my, I couldn't ever be to blame. I wish I had been so short thinking when my husban of 9 years walked out on me and my 2 younng sons. Hey, life is what you make of it and sometimes you have to stand up and accept some of the blame becaause you should always that your children are listening and learning from your example. My husband's favorite song . . . . . I can see clearly now because LORRANIE is gone.
Reply
Wednesday 01 December
By Kaje
I wonder what kind of f*cked up childhood Brooke had that makes her flip out whenever someone disagrees with the status quo.
Hey! Condescending unfounded assumptions of bitterness works both ways! Neat!
Reply
Wednesday 01 December
By TheGreen
@Lena Chen: You did not put any emphasis on any of the stuff you clarified on. You stated some things and I quoted how you stated them. Readers will get confused if there isn't enough info on the matter. How are we supposed to know that's what the article said? I didn't feel like reading it; it's your job to fill us in. I didn't know the guy said that; you didn't give us all that information in the article above. How was I supposed to know that? The readers only learn what you tell us in this article. I also tried to look for your other article about your marital views. It wasn't on here. Your article was not clarified at all until you commented. And the title is still a reference to society as a whole. I was only getting that you don't believe that you were messed up by your broken up family. Not how well of a person it's made you. But whatever.
Reply
Wednesday 01 December
By Lena Chen
The title of the article comes from the title of the CNN piece and wasn't meant to make a sweeping generalization about all single mothers or all their daughters. I hope it didn't seem like I was making a broad statement about single motherhood. The purpose of this personal essay was never to draw any conclusions about a specific social phenomena as a whole. I can only speak to my own experience, which is why I wrote in the first-person and about my own family circumstances, without making assumptions about how other children of single mothers make sense of their parents' relationship.
I added a link to the entry on my blog where the comment originates from, so hopefully, those readers interested in the backstory can read the full statement on their own.
Wednesday 01 December
By TheGreen
...........
Reply
Wednesday 01 December
By TheGreen
.........smh..........
Reply
Thursday 02 December
By sara
Lena, I thought your piece was lovely.
It is clear that it's intended to be a personal essay and not a treatise on the statistics of single motherhood.
We are lucky to have choices regarding our romantic lives, and it seems that you have
For those with problems - it is unnecessary to know what exactly Lena's reasons are for not wanting to get married in order to understand this piece.
It's frustrating as a reader and as a writer to see such nit-picky responses to a thoughtful and well-written piece.
Reply
Thursday 02 December
By sara
Lena, I thought your piece was lovely.
It is clear that it's intended to be a personal essay and not a treatise on the statistics of single motherhood.
We are lucky to have choices regarding our romantic lives, and it seems that you have made yours based on many considerations.
For those with problems - it is unnecessary to know what exactly Lena's reasons are for not wanting to get married in order to understand this piece.
It's frustrating as a reader and as a writer to see such nit-picky responses to a thoughtful and well-written piece.
Reply
Thursday 02 December
By smh2
@TheGreen Exactly my reaction. Chen writes this whole blog because of what ONE RANDOM TROLL said on her blog. Rather half-baked premise for this 'article'.
In fact, the fact that Chen is so defensive about a stray blog-comment suggests that the comment might have been TOO TRUTHFUL for Chen's comfort. (Most of us tend to just delete troll comments, not confabulate 1000-word replies to them.)
@sara What you're calling "nit picky" is the kind of stuff Ms. Chen should have learned in Composition 101. "But it's a PERSONAL essay!" does not excuse ill-conceived, rambling babble.
Reply
Thursday 02 December
By TheGreen
@smh2: Thank you! I kept thinking English 101 the whole time! Where are her premises? And the arguments she's trying to disprove? Very disappointing. And very good point. Why write an article based on what some commentor said? It's ridiculous, and was invalidly disproven.
@sara: Go back to college, that was not a well written article. I've never criticized someone's article on lemondrop before. And lots of the articles are bad but hilarious. This article lacked all of the content it needed desperately. Please do tell me how it was good because it was not. First of all, I don't have problems except for the problems I have with bad writers. Especially if it's her preferred career. Nor have I disagreed with her relationship preferences. I have issues with how she wrote the article. Sorry if you can't understand that. Nit-picky? No duh. That's what it takes to be a writer. Obviously you have know knowledge of the profession. So you should not talk if you are uncredited. Thanks. Peace.
Reply
Friday 03 December
By ignoranceisbliss
LOL @ TheGreen, who are you to critize on english/comp? " Obviously you have know **no** knowledge of the profession".
Though, I do agree the "essay" was pretty pointless, lacking content, a waste of my goof off time at work and brain cell rotting.
IMO, the commentors comment who initiated this brain spew of rot from Lena was correct in their views:
"Please state the martial status of your parents and your relatives. Your fucked up views concerning this issue is directly related to your terrible experiences growing up."
The commentor does not speak of upbringing, when I think upbringing, I think morals, values, everything we are taught. The commentor says "terrible experiences growing up" NOT upbringing. From what I can grab out of Lena's "essay", her experiences of witnessing the failing marriage of her parents has influenced her decision on her relationship status - which makes the commentor correct. Im my eyes, the commentor was very correct and Lena should really stop writing for public display.
I, myself have issues with getting married ever, and I will be the first to admit that it is because of my childhood experiences.
Good Day :)
Saturday 04 December
By sara
I'm not engaging beyond this, but I do think it's bizarre that your response to my liking the article and disagreeing with you is to criticize my education. Yes, I did find the points people were making to be "nit-picky," but I never insulted anyone personally. And for your information, I do have "credentials," and a damn fine education. But perhaps more importantly, I'm not the kind of person who seeks to put other people down. If that makes me the target of your derision, that's fine.
Thursday 02 December
By Renewed Thinker
As a man, its sad that many women have justified shacking up as okay. I used to love the idea of women like you, just giving up the sex for free and when I was tried of you, I would throw you out. But because of my new view on marriage (now 5 years into mine) I have a wonderful commitment with my WIFE not just with a co-existence "got me" person. Its a shame women are allowing men to use them. I'm so thankful life has changed for me and I'm truly ashamed that I used women in such a way. I'll I know is if woman showed more respect for marriage (commitment) the ball would be in their court! Now the ball bounces anywhere.
Reply
Friday 03 December
By JP
Renewed Thinker: Yeah, right. Typical male. You sewed your wild oats, and then bash the women you did it with. Guess what? If they were being "used for sex" then so were you. They weren't having that dirty, pre-marital sex by themselves. You didn't show respect for marriage or commitment, but you expect women to? Why? Why do you get a pass? And if you were throwing women away after sex, why are you trashing THEM? You should be ashamed of *yourself* for doing that. You appear to have a serious case of "Madonna/Whore Complex."
Your Victorian sexism isn't relevant anymore.
Friday 03 December
By CrmnsnSrfr
My parents also got along loads better once they didn't live together. Neither remarried. I do hope to get married someday but I think there is something to be said for people who don't...
Reply
Friday 03 December
By JP
Even if that CNN commentator was right, so what? Since the dawn of time, we have raised our daughters TO get married. Everyone seemed to think that was fine. But now, if single women raise their daughters to NOT get married, why is that bad? Isn't that commentator's disapproval just one more example of the sexism which tells women we aren't good enough if we don't have a ring on our finger?
Reply