Often I think to myself, You know what, [Redacted]? You're a really simple guy with very basic needs. Congratulate yourself with some beer. So I do, because I am. There are so few things I really want or need from a woman. And some people think that's why I haven't found one.
I've had countless friends ask me (for the purposes of setting me up, or out of frustration that the "plus one" I bring to their parties is a bottle of Old English 800 smuggled into my sport coat) what exactly I'm looking for in a girl. Some have even gone so far as to suggest that I list my ideal qualities in a girl so as to have less horrible luck finding one.
But you know what? I don't have ideal qualities.
Look, all I'm looking for in a girl is one I'm attracted to who likes me. I'm not asking for much here. I'd love a gal who I can talk to about books and movies and how there should be a Geneva Convention exemption to torture people who ride their bicycles on the sidewalks ... But I'd take one who couldn't if there was Something Between Us.
Theoretically, this seems like I should be dating more women. But I'm not.
I don't require that a woman be some kind of perfect combination of smarts and looks and poise. Could she even be a bit of a party animal, and happen to have a slightly sketchy alcohol intake and occasionally lose entire Sundays afternoons to Netflix and bong rips? A bit of a dork? A bit of a ne'er-do-well? Yes, she could. This is how unbelievably laid back I am about this.
Guys? Maybe I'm too easy.
What I'm Supposed to Care About and Don't
I know that there are a bunch of things I should look for in a woman and don't. For instance, I really don't care about a girl's background. Do I care if she went to college? If she gets along with her family? Barely. Would it be great to meet a sharp girl who gets along really well with her mom and her dying billionaire father? Sure. Call me shallow, but these things just don't seem to matter to me.
Do I care about her job? Nope. If we had the right spark, I wouldn't care if a girl worked the graveyard shift mopping floors at Arby's because she loved the coveralls. You know all I require from a woman, ambition-wise? Enough will to be nice to kids and animals and strangers, and to have hair that has that girl-hair smell.
I know that people like to keep these checklists of what they want in a person -- financial savvy, green eyes, the ability to maneuver a futon up and down the stairs during a move without scratching the faux birch. Maybe I should have one of these lists, but for me, anything else on top of chemistry is gravy. If that's there, it doesn't matter if you have the most basic math and dressing and job skills. As long as you have breasts and the ability to have multiple orgasms and we have chemistry, I'm registering us at Crate & Barrel.
So why can't I find it?
Perhaps I Should Be More Specific
I know what you're thinking: Come on, [Redacted]. You know what you want in a woman. But I'm telling you right now, all I actually want, if you're forcing me into specifics, is maybe one who likes to laugh and who, I don't know, likes music. I'm that easy. I'm just a regular guy out there looking for a woman to dote on. I know it doesn't seem like it, but I've got the capacity to dote in me.
I guess maybe the problem is that I've just become so stridently OK with being single, and I like the same thing in a girl. When did it become too much to ask for a woman who is independent? A woman who enjoys her alone time and is not looking for someone to "complete" her and maybe has similarly relaxed standards in what she wants in a guy?
I'm asking you all because you're women and you tend to make these lists of what you're searching for like the children did in "Mary Poppins." But even though men and Internet commenters may act like they're looking for some perfect amalgam of a La Perla model and Blizzard Entertainment employee, ask any man and he will tell you that his number one requirement in a woman is that she is "nice."
Any man who says anything else is lying or a sociopath. This is what I ask for: a nice, funny girl whom I wouldn't mind seeing without clothes.
Tell Me What I'm Doing Wrong Here
It's become such a problem that I'm wondering if my lack of standards isn't actually my problem. It's almost funny how little I require to be content with a gal. So could this be what's screwing me over in the end? Like when you're so hungry that you can't decide what you want, so you just go to Subway and then you're like, Why did I do this? This bread tastes like it's made out of a Korean newspaper.
Because really, even if you ask me to dig deep and come up with a list of essential qualities, I'll go with smart, funny and likes to have sex with me. Just a gal who digs ABC's new lineup and asking if I've read the new Franzen and dressing up in a lady cop costume with a removable crotch flap.
And maybe one who will promise to never, ever read this column.
[Redacted] Guy is the resident single guy writer at Lemondrop. He owns a first-edition copy of Judy Blume's "Then Again Maybe I Won't," around which he has based his life.
Send him hate mail and love letters here, and follow him on Twitter.












Comments:
Add a comment
Thursday 21 October
By Julie
This doesn't make much sense. Are you the same one who wrote the article about dumping women. If so, why did you dump these women who so perfectly met your standards.
I also don't know exactly what I want, but I know when I'm happy and I know when I'm unhappy, and I don't limit myself to one "type" of guy, because you never know when you find the right one.
Reply
Thursday 21 October
By A Girl
Dear Redacted Guy,
What happened with previous girls that you liked?
You sound like a really nice guy with all the right priorities. Not trying to narrow down the dating pool by eye color seems like a pretty rational thing to do.
The only thing I can think of that might be "wrong" is that everyone likes to be thought of as special. And if most people are a potential mate in your eyes, then none of those women can think to herself, "A ha! He's found me! After all these years of dating the wrong people - I am the one he wants." She might be afraid that if a lot of other women can work, there's nothing keeping you glued to her, in particular.
Reply
Thursday 21 October
By Shona
I totally agree! Not that this is much consolation, but just finding someone you're really into, who's also truly into you is hard enough, without all that other stuff.
Reply
Thursday 21 October
By the other side of the pillow
i ride my bicycle on the sidewalk.
Reply
Thursday 21 October
By Michelle
I am the female version of you....open to many but truly excited about no one. Yet, anyway.
Reply
Thursday 21 October
By Laura
I gotta agree with A Girl on this one. I dated a guy who after about 2 dates was like, "This is good. We work. Let's be a couple." I felt like he just wanted to be with a nice, funny girl, who he wanted to see naked and I happened to fit the bill. And if it hadn't been me it would have been somone esle. This was never stated out loud, but I got that vibe. Not terribly romantic. We're no longer together and I'm with a guy who makes me feel like he couldn't imagine being with anyone else.
Reply
Thursday 21 October
By Virginia
When you find the right girl, you'll know because she'll tell you.
Reply
Thursday 21 October
By Rachel
You are me in male form. Scary.
Reply
Thursday 21 October
By Liz
You can start by asking them out.
Reply
Thursday 21 October
By Red Head
Seriously? You just described your perfect women in your article.
"...like to see without clothes." She has to be pretty.
"...discuss books..." She has to be intelligent enough to do just that.
"...funny girl..." She has to have a sense of humor.
What if she mops floors all day at Arby's and comes home and complains and whines all night long, every time because she hates her job but can't get another one because she is uneducated. Or has "daddy" issues and can't have sex more than 3 times a year. Or causes herself horrible disease because she can't stop drinking long enough to get sober...is that gonna do it for you, just because she is "in to you"? You can live with that, day in and day out night after night????? Doubt it!
And yes, men are simple creatures who require very little...sex, sustenance and sports. But women are complex, they want more than a guy to sit and watch football all day and go out for beers with the guys 7 days a week. Maybe that's your problem...you care so little about the women and HER needs because your need are met if she sleeps with you and gets you a beer afterward.
Reply
Friday 22 October
By MnM
I have to agree w/ a girl & laura. You make it sound so unromantic about finding a chick. You have some reevaluating to do! Sounds to me that your a bit contradicting, and your putting a lot of emphasis on sex... Ugh! Get back to the basics my man...
Reply
Sunday 24 October
By Charles
After a few longer relationships come to an end, and then others never seem to start, it's difficult to get excited about the new ones. It's tough to be romantic when at the same time you don't want to get ahead of yourself and declare this girl "the one" after 2 dates
Friday 22 October
By An
Liz beat me to it! I would have liked to have known what attempts you've made in finding a mate (since just about any woman will do). This whole post is exactly what every other Nice Guy (tm) I know says. They complain a lot about being single, or about not being able to find the right one, and insist they aren't picky, but they don't put themselves out there and ask women out.
Reply
Friday 22 October
By Rob
[ Redacted ], I've been a big fan of your column since I stumbled upon it a few months back. Went through, read through everything you posted, and I thought, here is a fellow I can get on-board with – a kindred spirit, someone out there fighting the good fight, and doing it the right way. I haven't always agreed with everything you've said, but I at least got why you said it.
This one just didn't ring true for me, though.
To me, this column read like too much of an attempt to make yourself seem like some odd, isolated exception. Like, "look how quirky my worldview is." You don't have to convince us of that one, man – we're all pretty sold.
The fact of the matter is, you *do* have certain preferences in women; you actually listed them throughout the piece, in the form of alleged hypotheticals (e.g., "A bit of a ne'er-do-well?") But, more than that, go back through just about any column you've written, and there are examples of specific characteristics or behaviors you prefer or do not prefer, no doubt based upon women you've been with, or seen, or dreamed about.
The only thing is, these coveted traits aren't dealbreakers for you – which is healthy, and how it should be. Once you've got this stringent set of requirements, and that's *all* you go for, you start getting into fetish country, and that's when things get creepy. I guess my point is, flexibility and open-mindedness should be a given, not the oddity you're making it out to be.
You killed me at the end with the "Then Again, Maybe I Won't" shout-out at the end, though. Bless you, Judy Blume, for making my random teenage boners acceptable.
Reply
Saturday 23 October
By des
you'll know and understand better when you meet someone who will make your world a totally different one..far beyond what you could imagine. It's easy to say things such as what you have mentioned especially for someone who is good with words and adjectives..but when you simply can't describe it anymore sounds more real..
Reply
Monday 25 October
By blazy
YES!
Reply
Wednesday 27 October
By LondonCityGirl.co.uk
No offence redacted, but you sound a bit of a looney in this post. Finding a nice, funny girl and one you have enough chemistry with to warrant a relationship IS the hard bit. I don't want to be harsh but those girls don't grow on trees. In the same way nice, funny guys who I have chemsitry with (and lets not kid ourselves, chemistry means cute) are hard to find. It's not that you lack standards. If you just opted to settle with someone reasonably interesting who you were semi attracted to you'd have a girlfriend in no time. You have to be less picky, slip those standards waaaay down my man.
Reply
Friday 29 October
By Megan
As long as you have breasts and the ability to have multiple orgasms and we have chemistry, I'm registering us at Crate & Barrel.
Reply
Saturday 30 October
By Kevin
People, give the dude a break. I'm pretty much the same way.
Reply
Wednesday 03 November
By Samantha
This post is so jumbled and has to be the worst writing I have seen from Redacted Guy (and I read every week). I am not sure if it's poor editing, or just a pure lack of motivation with you, RG. Running out of things to write about? Glamour just got a new "Jake," maybe you should hang up your hat and let a younger lad replace you as well.
Reply