Yesterday I received the same message via email, text, tweet and wall post no fewer than a dozen times: "I'm sure you've already seen this, but ..."
The "this" was Robin Marantz Henig's hefty New York Times article about the state of today's 20-somethings -- an extensive assessment of the way my generation is choosing to spend our transition into adulthood, what our choices mean, and whether they're good or bad.
The barrage of messages came to me because I write a blog called 20-Nothings, started at age 24 after the hundredth time I heard the term "quarter-life crisis."
It also came because today -- at 27 -- I'm literally packing up my childhood bedroom where I returned in May after five years in Manhattan in prep for a cross-country pursuit of my passions.
According to the article, mine is the path of today's 20-something: a meandering line directed by soul-searching -- as opposed to 401(k) saving -- and a fierce belief that 35 is the new 25.
"Seen it?" became my copy-paste response, "I am it."
For those who haven't read the article (though I recommend you do), the central question is this: Why are so many people in their 20s taking so long to grow up? (Click here to read Lemondrop's summary.)
New York Times, I have your answer.
It's a question based on the very-well-documented sociological differences between my peers and all those who came before us. Unlike our parents who hit the job-marriage-kids goals at a traditional pace, "[Today] the 20s are a black box -- and there is a lot of churning going on in there," reports the Times.
That churning equals "identity exploration, instability, self-focus, feeling in-between," the opposite of what was/is traditional adulthood (choosing a path, settling down, and creating a stable life for you-plus-family).
As a person who took from graduation to her five-year college reunion to even choose a path, I can attest to the churning. I have churned, damn near professionally.
I have also talked to dozens and dozens of 20-somethings over my years writing the blog about what it feels like inside that "black box." While it is a stretch to say the experience is universal (some people do not have the means to not know what they're doing at 25, but that's a whole other article), many of us do feel less focused and less certain. We are more driven by our personal interests than family-oriented ones. And our goal is to get to the right place, not to get there at the "right time." It's not that we don't know what it means to be an adult and how we're supposed to do it -- it's that we do.
We are painfully aware that decisions in our 20s lay the foundation for all of adult life. We know exactly how old our parents were when they had us, and exactly what they sacrificed as a result. We know that time is precious, age isn't really just a number, and having kids changes everything.
So, we can absolutely see the forest through the trees. We just figure it's best to deliberately navigate through those trees so we arrive at the forest in one (better) piece. And -- this may just be the crux of it -- we don't see why we should rush. We were raised not to.
Case in point: When I said to my parents, "I'd like to move home to save money to pursue my creative passions in Los Angeles," they said, "Good for you." (To be clear about my personal sitch: they did not also say, "And here's $10K to get you there!") Every single person I've told since then has reacted with some version of "Now's the time" or "I wish I'd done that when I was your age."
We want to hear your story of being a 20-something.
Share it here.
I think there is a difference between wandering and floundering, between taking a longer time to grow up and choosing to stay a "child." The former was me living in a closet-size Manhattan apartment, working at a job I was sure wasn't quite right, and eating Ramen noodles 'till I figured out what was. I took the traditional steps toward traditional adult life (financial independence, career stability), I just took (am still taking) them slower and more deliberately. And I made that path -- figuring out what was best for me both life- and career-wise -- my primary task.
The latter would have been me living in my parents' basement crying to "My So-called Life" on Hulu and meeting the "What are you doing with your life?" question with a "Get off my back!" That's stalling. I was, I don't know, crawling?
But does that make me less mature and less adult? Or does it make me more?
Where I get confused around this plight-of-the-20-something issue is when it's suggested by the generations above us that our crawling or churning is immature or foolish, that one day -- sometime after we cross over the 3-0 threshold, apparently -- we're all going to wake up and realize we should have buckled down, gotten married and quit the charade because the
real joy/purpose in life is to "be an adult." That slow and steady actually loses the race. So, my question as I literally spend my grown-up savings account to pursue my childhood dream is, What is so much better about becoming an adult faster?
What am I gaining by taking my time versus what I'm losing by just getting to it already? With every year I wait to be ready to get married, am I letting all the people there are to marry pass me by? Will I be a better, more mature mother at 35 or would I have been just as adept and instinctual at 25? If I live at home with my parents for one more year while I save up to be a full-time writer, will that leave an eternal mark of lame on my life résumé? Does being an adult mean having the maturity to know you're not ready for adult things, or having the maturity to dive in and just figure it out? Won't I be a better, happier, healthier adult if I take my time getting there?
If someone could please write the article that answers those questions, we'll kindly decide at what speed we'd like to "grow up."
But for better or worse, we were raised to ask all those questions. And in the absence of answers, we've grown comfortable and confident handling them ourselves.
So, as one 20-nothing who has embodied the "It's about the journey" approach, I'd like to say that I am grown up. I am an adult. I just don't look or act or live quite like the generations prior, and frankly I find that thrilling.
Jessie Rosen is a frequent Lemondrop contributor and financial genius / television superstar. She writes the blog 20-Nothings, an account of getting by from 2-0 to 3-0 with minimal wind resistance.













Comments:
Add a comment
Thursday 19 August
By Mandi
I am also a 20 something year old wanderer, but I am wandering to get to a place that is much harder to get to than my peers. Unlike those who settled into a cushy pre-planned career, my career in broadcasting/production takes more perseverance and dedication and longer-hours than can be allowed with raising a family at my age. You can't just graduate and get a great paying job in this industry, if you can even get a job at all. I have at least thirty years to dedicate to family, god-willing, why can't I take thirty for my career. I wouldn't want my kids to give up their dream in order to have a family, not when in today's world when you can have both and divorce is so prevalent. My advice is never settle for anything less than everything. It's your life.
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By Wade
Jessie, you're an idiot, as is most of your generation. The reason you should have children- if you want to have children- while in your 20s has nothing to do with anything except you have more energy to keep up with 2-year-olds in your 20s, and you'll likely live long enough to see them graduate high school and evn have kids of their own. The older you are having kids, the less chance ANy of those things will happen.
This country already has a serious gap in not reproducing enough to keep things going; everything from race and culture to religion and even paying into systems to help out others are quickly being depleted because of your idiot thinking! The problem falls back on your being coddled too much growing up, and not taking responsibilty soon enough. Your generation would never be able to stand through a Great Depression or survive a World War. You haven't invented anything, but have lived off of the fat of other technologies before you, to where you think these are "necessities", instead of luxuries.
You have too much time on your hands to think about finding perfection in life, instead of dealing with life and being happy as it's handed to you.
You show yourself to be selfish and spoiled and cry like a baby if things don't go picture- perfect in your life. You'll end up in your 40s, looking back, and realize (if you have any intelligence for self-awareness instead of self-serving), that you pissed away so much of your life looking for a "dream job", a "dream spouse", etc. when those things don't exist. And, remember, you may think you have plenty of time to decide what you want, but time is promised to NO ONE at any age. Stop whining about not wanting to "grow up", and just do what you must. "Growing up" is not just an age, it's taking responsibilties in life and dealing with the cards that are dealt to you; and it's also experience, which builds slowly the older you get.
Reply
Friday 20 August
By Todd
couldn’t have said it better myself. I’m 24 and in themilitary. I have so many friends that live at home with their parents and aren’t going anywhere or even moving forward in their lives. I’m so sick of the college students that take money from mommy and daddy and just blow it all on drugs and booze. Then end up dropping out and going to rehab. What is wrong with my generation?
Friday 20 August
By gedeus
Well said!!!
Thursday 19 August
By Dan
And the eggs and sperm rot and break- the biology is not going along with the "I need to find me" routine timeline - you will get in touch with yourself if you stop watching "Idol" - this from the older generation.
Reply
Tuesday 24 August
By tothecloseminded
I love how everyone is so quick to jump in and say that we are not "grown up" by choice. Aside from the mass of people who are graduating with degrees, there are thousands more with degrees and experience lined up for the same job. So maybe it isn't always a choice to linger and go from job to job barely able to afford simple bills. Come to New York, find a place and a job with just a degree and a 20-something year old smile. Good luck to you because that is not enough. You need experience. You need to know someone. You need to look older. Experience comes with time so relax, let us do what's best for us and focus on your own life before you start worrying about others that do not even remotely affect you.
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By Charlie Angel 43
I have no problem with this concept. Maybe this generation senses the world is going to end soon, so why bother. However, you still have to support yourself somehow if you want to live this life. To "find yourself" is easy if someone else is "flipping the bill". Like Frank Sinatra sang "nice work if you can get and if you can get it, won't you tell me how?" Anyway, maybe the the 20 nothings know something. But for me, you have to live deliberatly. In any case, I have no choice but to take care of my responsibilities (I'm a 50 something after all). -
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By James
Great article. I love how the NY Times writer does not remember the decades before us. Didn't the baby boomers shake the conventional norms of society? The article talks about cohabitation and premartial sex. Wasn't the 60's and 70's the start of that into the mainstream and then it become more acceptable. It is not like this is an overnight scene.
A lot of my peers went along with the traditional path of graduate high school,. attend college, then enter into a career. With the recession over the last few years, there have been massive layoffs that impact the young employees like the older ones. The problem is that the old plan of college into a career doesn't guarantee success. The old game plan is busted for the majority. A lot has to do with the increasing costs of college.
Personally, I went out of state to another university that is ranked highly for my field and I made sacrifices of working 2 to 3 summer job as well as being a dreaded RA for my junior and senior years. I knew that I had to sacrifice in order to attend the chosen school and not be killed with the amount of student loans. I have friends that have over 50k in student loans but make a fraction of that in their career path. How are they ever going to get ahead or back to even after to pay back loans at that amount. Our generation is going to be WORSE off then the prior ones. We are going to have to fill in the gap for Social Security and other programs because the boomers and other before us didn't save or lost most of their money when the market sold off in 2008 and/or their homes aren't worth as much. I am curious to see what the NY Times writer has to say when in 20 to 30 years, she and her husband are going to live with one of their daughters. Mark my words, she is going to write a "I'm moving back with my kids" article in the future. Great so we will have to take care of our parents are even higher healthcare costs as well as put our kids through college at even higher rates too. Follow 20-Nothing's, start saving now!
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By Jennifer
I am 29 years old, and I moved out when I was 20. I lived alone until I got engaged when I was 26. I have always supported myself, never moved back home, and never had to take a dime from my parents. I am so proud to have been completely on my own! Whenever I hear of 25 yr olds "still living at home", I feel sick to my stomach. Stop sucking on mommy and daddys wallets and grow up!
Reply
Friday 20 August
By howardroark
i can't believe how much nonsensical gibberish this broad wrote... she makes it seem that "churning" -- i'll assume that means trying to figure out what you want to do with your life -- is something new and unique to these so-called 20-nothings. listen, sugarbritches, you just gotta get out there and do some-effing-thing while you're trying to figure yourself / life out. life will eventually present something to your whiny, self-absorbed liking.
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By Vonnie
It does not matter to me what 20 somethings do....as long as I don't have to pay for it. If you want to wader aimlessly through life, please don't apply for any government assistance. Then you are no longer trying to find yourself, you are a burden on society and highly selfish. And that includes when you are 20 something and when you are 60 something. Your lack of planning now should not affect the future of your children or any one elses.
And dear sweet parents, when your darling 20 something calls and says they want to move back in so they can persue their dreams (and live off your dime for a while longer) just say NO. On second thought say HELL NO. If we keep on encouraging the thought that they are entitled to get everything handed to them we have failed miserably as parents.
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By 18-nothing
As a confused young adult trying to figure out what I'm going to do in college/work/life I found this article reassuring-I'm not alone in my thoughts about the "job-marriage-kids" deal. Thank you for writing this article. Life is about discovery afterall; why not begin with ourselves?
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By Bemda
There is a great book you will need to buy at around 60. The title is" 27 interesting ways to prepare Alpo"
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By HU
Thanks God there are still persons with reason in this country, specially for " no surprise", well said it, this 20s something they forgot that the time to find them self is when you are a teenager, they only want a excuse to still living in that phase and let the parents or family take their responsibilities, they think that their energy and health is forever ( like a teenager thinking) and then they can have children at 38 or 40 year old, because they do not care what happen to the children after, bottom line they are selfish and the parents that allow this behavior are also responsible.
Reply
Friday 20 August
By gedeus
Good answer!!!
Thursday 19 August
By Fed up
What a load of crap! How about you churn your way to putting food in your mouth and a roof over your head before you take the luxury of "finding yourself"? While your parents are busting their buns at jobs and delaying their retirement, no one would want you to put aside that selfish self expression and GROW UP!
Kids of the world listen up! Your parents raised you to 18 while you repeatedly reminded them that you wanted to be treated like an adult. So act like an adult and quit sponging off your parents now that you are over 18. If your parents had the ability to help you out with college, thank them and MOVE OUT! Get a job and show them that their sacrifice went to a better purpose than a whiny, self absorbed, immature child who won't accept the responsibilities of living in the real world.
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By John
Dear Jessie:
I am 76 and agree with you.
I was married once when I was in my mid 20's and it was a distaster. I went back in the Navy for several more years met another woman 9+ years my junior and now after 44+ years with 3 children and 4 grandchildren I realize the love of my life came at the right time for me.
it can't be rushed. When it is right it is right and you will know it.
John
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By jvm
An interesting read. I personally am 46- and i still feel more like i did at 20 than what a traditional 46 year old person is supposed to feel.
I watch stuff like South Park, not Fox News, Star Trek re runs, not the Kardashians, and dang if it aint football season again.thank god
My biggest problem is that i have outlasted my peer group, and that most everyone who graduated in 1981 has become exactly what we were dedicated not to become, as in money grubbing moronic quitters.
i pay my bills, i know what i like to do for a living, but becoming one of the suit wearing, no fun GROWN UPS i have encountered just does not seem to be on the plate for me. i am probably going to croak with my playstation controller in one hand and a spleef in the other, and thats ok.
I am lucky, my favorite band is still kicking ass 30 years later, and i saw all 6 Star Wars, which was a quest unto itself, many people i knew DIED before Sith came out.
Its the little things that matter...
my advice to all you 20 somethings is be yourself, do what ya like and never let anyone bully you into a job or a marriage because thats what THEY think you should do. that includes parents, friends and co workers- life is a journey, not a destination,
so enjoy the ride. I have...
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By Andy
This article's title should really be, " The Pornography of Self-Realization" or , "Naval-Gazing and other Excuses; an explaination of why I still mooch of my Parents" My parents practically kicked me out at 17, and I can understand why, now that I'm 48. My generation wanted to get out on our own and join the world. And come to think of it, were never enabled as the younger generation of today is enabled. Sorry to all you little self-absorbed 20 somethings, but this article is nothing more than an excuse as to why you're stil babies.
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By Sharron
This is the biggesst load of crap I ever heard.
Reply