Yesterday I received the same message via email, text, tweet and wall post no fewer than a dozen times: "I'm sure you've already seen this, but ..."
The "this" was Robin Marantz Henig's hefty New York Times article about the state of today's 20-somethings -- an extensive assessment of the way my generation is choosing to spend our transition into adulthood, what our choices mean, and whether they're good or bad.
The barrage of messages came to me because I write a blog called 20-Nothings, started at age 24 after the hundredth time I heard the term "quarter-life crisis."
It also came because today -- at 27 -- I'm literally packing up my childhood bedroom where I returned in May after five years in Manhattan in prep for a cross-country pursuit of my passions.
According to the article, mine is the path of today's 20-something: a meandering line directed by soul-searching -- as opposed to 401(k) saving -- and a fierce belief that 35 is the new 25.
"Seen it?" became my copy-paste response, "I am it."
For those who haven't read the article (though I recommend you do), the central question is this: Why are so many people in their 20s taking so long to grow up? (Click here to read Lemondrop's summary.)
New York Times, I have your answer.
It's a question based on the very-well-documented sociological differences between my peers and all those who came before us. Unlike our parents who hit the job-marriage-kids goals at a traditional pace, "[Today] the 20s are a black box -- and there is a lot of churning going on in there," reports the Times.
That churning equals "identity exploration, instability, self-focus, feeling in-between," the opposite of what was/is traditional adulthood (choosing a path, settling down, and creating a stable life for you-plus-family).
As a person who took from graduation to her five-year college reunion to even choose a path, I can attest to the churning. I have churned, damn near professionally.
I have also talked to dozens and dozens of 20-somethings over my years writing the blog about what it feels like inside that "black box." While it is a stretch to say the experience is universal (some people do not have the means to not know what they're doing at 25, but that's a whole other article), many of us do feel less focused and less certain. We are more driven by our personal interests than family-oriented ones. And our goal is to get to the right place, not to get there at the "right time." It's not that we don't know what it means to be an adult and how we're supposed to do it -- it's that we do.
We are painfully aware that decisions in our 20s lay the foundation for all of adult life. We know exactly how old our parents were when they had us, and exactly what they sacrificed as a result. We know that time is precious, age isn't really just a number, and having kids changes everything.
So, we can absolutely see the forest through the trees. We just figure it's best to deliberately navigate through those trees so we arrive at the forest in one (better) piece. And -- this may just be the crux of it -- we don't see why we should rush. We were raised not to.
Case in point: When I said to my parents, "I'd like to move home to save money to pursue my creative passions in Los Angeles," they said, "Good for you." (To be clear about my personal sitch: they did not also say, "And here's $10K to get you there!") Every single person I've told since then has reacted with some version of "Now's the time" or "I wish I'd done that when I was your age."
We want to hear your story of being a 20-something.
Share it here.
I think there is a difference between wandering and floundering, between taking a longer time to grow up and choosing to stay a "child." The former was me living in a closet-size Manhattan apartment, working at a job I was sure wasn't quite right, and eating Ramen noodles 'till I figured out what was. I took the traditional steps toward traditional adult life (financial independence, career stability), I just took (am still taking) them slower and more deliberately. And I made that path -- figuring out what was best for me both life- and career-wise -- my primary task.
The latter would have been me living in my parents' basement crying to "My So-called Life" on Hulu and meeting the "What are you doing with your life?" question with a "Get off my back!" That's stalling. I was, I don't know, crawling?
But does that make me less mature and less adult? Or does it make me more?
Where I get confused around this plight-of-the-20-something issue is when it's suggested by the generations above us that our crawling or churning is immature or foolish, that one day -- sometime after we cross over the 3-0 threshold, apparently -- we're all going to wake up and realize we should have buckled down, gotten married and quit the charade because the
real joy/purpose in life is to "be an adult." That slow and steady actually loses the race. So, my question as I literally spend my grown-up savings account to pursue my childhood dream is, What is so much better about becoming an adult faster?
What am I gaining by taking my time versus what I'm losing by just getting to it already? With every year I wait to be ready to get married, am I letting all the people there are to marry pass me by? Will I be a better, more mature mother at 35 or would I have been just as adept and instinctual at 25? If I live at home with my parents for one more year while I save up to be a full-time writer, will that leave an eternal mark of lame on my life résumé? Does being an adult mean having the maturity to know you're not ready for adult things, or having the maturity to dive in and just figure it out? Won't I be a better, happier, healthier adult if I take my time getting there?
If someone could please write the article that answers those questions, we'll kindly decide at what speed we'd like to "grow up."
But for better or worse, we were raised to ask all those questions. And in the absence of answers, we've grown comfortable and confident handling them ourselves.
So, as one 20-nothing who has embodied the "It's about the journey" approach, I'd like to say that I am grown up. I am an adult. I just don't look or act or live quite like the generations prior, and frankly I find that thrilling.
Jessie Rosen is a frequent Lemondrop contributor and financial genius / television superstar. She writes the blog 20-Nothings, an account of getting by from 2-0 to 3-0 with minimal wind resistance.













Comments:
Add a comment
Thursday 19 August
By Fifthpocket
What a baby...
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By Elinore Delaney
Two incidents - Columbine and 9/11 - that occurred during the early lives of the twenty-somethings defined us - their parents - as we raised our children. We realized their world was a lot more dangerous and fragile than our own had been, and we consciously chose to insulate them from this world a little longer than we had been insulated from the realities of our own. And you know what? The kids are all right!
Thursday 19 August
By Wade
@ Fifthpocket- LOL!
Thursday 19 August
By grable surber
support yourselves and ono one give a rats ass how long it takes you to "find yourself" you can be 20 something as long as you want or more likely as to how long your parents will support you.
Thursday 19 August
By Seen It
One one hand, the chance to 'take your time and do it right' is a wonderful opportunity to explore your options. You are free to devote time to your own pursuits, without traditional responsibilities to weigh you down or affect your choices. However, expect that it's going to be more complicated to settle down later, when you find that most of the desirable partners have already been spoken for, and those remaining either have issues, or lots of baggage from a previous marriage, in the form of kids and an ex-spouse. Like everything else in life, it's a trade-off.
Thursday 19 August
By TJK
All your good intentions to be a "free spirit" will leave you broke & eating cat food when you are 60. WAKE UP..............................
Friday 20 August
By BHA81
Why so serious everyone? Life is short, you may die tomorrow......at best what 30.....40......50 years from now? To quote the Greatful Dead. "Such a short time to be here and such a long, long time to be gone.......Just Live and let live.....Love......Laugh and Enjoy....then say the same to everyone that comes after you and.....be on your way. Is everyone really that worried about what everyone else is doing with their lives? Come on now, think about it.......I hope you do.....
Friday 20 August
By Loren
Elinore, what a load of crap. You mambe panbes are raise a bunch of emotional welfare babies. My wife is in the child care industry and calls people like you NOW NOW Mommas. Making a bunch of spoiled brat adults the have no back bone. What kids need is straingth, duty, honor, love, and corporal punishment. Everyone I know that has 20 something kids still in the house have nothing but drama constantly. Throw the birds out of the nest its natural.
Thursday 19 August
By Elizabeth
This was a perfect response. Perfectly put and perfectly balanced and open... well don Jessie!
Now, what I am about to say, I mean objectively, as I too am taking my time to reach what some people consider "adulthood." I am pursuing my career and tryng to navigate which direction I want to continue with it first and foremost. If I meet a man I want to spend the rest of my life with and we have the same direction, woo hoo, maybe I'll get married.
With that said, I think one of the reasons we do "crawl" so to speak, is due to fear. We are raised ina society where we are expected to be perfect. We are prepped at a young age to take part in as many extracurriculars as we can all while being popular and maintaining top grades in school. Before you stereotype, I by no means fit these characteristics. I grew up somewhat of an outcast in school and am still looked at funny when I argue why hiking is more fun than shopping.
But being part of a generation that was expected to outperform not only our parents but ourselves by the time we could walk, well, what do people expect?
How can we graduate college, find our dream job and settle down with Mr or Mrs Perfect without a few blunders? And when a blunder awards you a scarlet letter, why would we rush? We need to make sure we do it all right, without disappointing our parents, friends and, most of all, ourselves.
Reply
Thursday 19 August
By suzycreamcheese
Actually it's "graduate FROM college".
Thursday 19 August
By Jules
Elizabeth, I am guessing that you live on your own and have a job! You don't sound like the type of person who just lets mommy and daddy foot the bill and all of the responsibilities.
I personally couldn't wait to get out of the house and I moved out with roommates just after my 18th birthday (1980). It wasn't the lap of luxury but I had a sense of self-satisfaction knowing that I was paying my own bills and buying my own food. I didn't have a career goal in mind at the time, and not many people really know what they want to do at that age, anyway. I worked a fulltime job and went to school, which left me very little play time and left me rather broke. It was hunger that gave me the initiative to make my way. I just knew that I had to be on my own and wasn't willing to mooch off of mom and dad. I made my way and found my niche.
There is nothing wrong with delaying the onset of children and marriage. That is an individual decision and no one else's business. I did that myself. Unfortunately, it worked out for me that I never had children of my own because I waited too long while developing and building my ideal career. I also waited too long to find "Mr. Right" and was rather old for childbearing when I finally settled down, although many these days find it acceptable to have children after the age of 35. I was lucky enough to find an amazing man who already had fulltime custody of his children.
Unfortunately, these 20 somethings are rather reluctant to grow up and move out of our home, which WE worked hard to enjoy in our older years (would have been nice to have some privacy at this late state of our lives). I have a hard time understanding why anyone would want to stay dependent on other people for food and shelter, anyway. I encourage young people to find themselves, just don't be a mooch while doing so!
Thursday 19 August
By RNB
Very well said!
Thursday 19 August
By Aerin
Dearest Elizabeth: I applaud your goal, but I would like to provide a healthy dose of reality: There is no such thing as perfection!!!!! I was lucky to find a job and a career I thoroughly enjoyed for more than thirty years BUT, it was not perfect. Even the most interesting and enjoyable work - and very few of us are lucky enough to have the talent and ability to get that work - will have days when it is boring and unproductive. Nor is Mr. Right always perfectly charming: a good marriage requires two people who are willing to work on it, not expect perfection to descent upon them.
It is exactly this expectation of perfection - perhaps even the attitude that we deserve perfection - that makes us oldsters look at your generation and cringe at the immaturity.
Thursday 19 August
By Joe
Elizabeth - yes. You ARE expected to come as close to perfection as your own abilities, intelligence, and integrity will bring you. Pressure ? Stress ?? Gee...I'm sorry. Just come on over here and I'll give you an iPod full of your favorite music, cook you your favorite meal especially for YOU all the time so that you can watch it in front of the TV and then make sure that you sleep as late as you like the next day...God knows you'd be exhausted from all of those text conversations with your fellow twentynothings (For the Love of God...you could get carpal tunnel syndrome with all of that texting !!!) then enjoy a nice long lunch and shopping trip with your fellow shortcomers while you muse to each other about writing a great piece of fiction.
SNAP OUT OF IT !!!!! This is THE REAL WORLD...and yes - it's an often cruel, hard, violent place ( ask any other twentysomething who's spent a couple of years dodging IEDs in Iraq and Taliban bullets in Afghanistan) and you are expected to STEP UP !!!! YOU are called upon to make a contribution - we all are. This was drummed home to me when I was 19 through a rather impassioned litany from a United States Coast Guard Company Commander in Cape May, New Jersey (the REAL Jersey Shore). I don't really - nor do I think alot of other adults of my ilk and genre - CARE how scared you are of pressure, competition, and expected perfection. You may or may not have noticed, given the cushion of your insulated and narcissistic jelly cells, but this country is slipping into the realm or irrelevence on the world stage because we don't step up !!!! Guess what ??? It's Rome and The Goths are at the gate...only now they're not riding horses...they're flying hijacked airliners. Damn !!
To Elinore I say this...I believe that YOUR perception and ideology regarding shielding our children from this cruel world is equally as dangerous. Yes - we lived through 9/11, Columbine, the Virginia Tech massacre, Katrina, and reality televison. At best, this world is different from ours - at worst it's dangerous. BUT - let me put this to you...what happened to our parents when Kennedy was assasinated ? Did they fold and put maturity and responsibility on hold ? No - they were irrevocably changed and scarred, but they went on...fought in Vietnam, suffered through the indignity of Watergate, Inflation, the Arab Oil Embargo, the arms race, and disco. Did our grandparents put maturity and responsibility on hold when the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor ? No...they stepped up, manned up, and defeated totalitarianism and tyrany. Scared ? Pressure ? Perfection ? I can guarantee that a paratrooper jumping into Festung Europa on the 5th of June 1944 felt all of those things Scared to die, pressure of not letting his buddies down, and the absolute need for perfection, lest there be the blood of a good friend shed unnecessarily. The only difference between them and the 20whatevers of today is courage. Courage isn't the absence of fear but the realization that there is something more important than fear. When they came home, they built a world of prosperity and affluence that has since softened every generation incrementally yet exponentially. Step up !!!!!!!
So...as you all live in your nice, cushy, relative comfort to ponder the "future", remember that you are doing it in the shadows of much greater, more responsible, braver people than you...and if you DON'T do something collectively, then that's all you will ever be (not that it matters to any of you).
Thursday 19 August
By wornwinger
you will not be perfect.................if you are waiting for all these things to fall in your lap? you will be thirty something saying where did my friends go....they are raising thier kids,working thier careers,paying morgages,nd sitting home saving money to go to aruba for two weeks this summer..................I like hiking....the people that look like they have a perfect life.....just put on a better act,than the rest of us.do you have any life goals?
Friday 20 August
By Matt
true and well put. i feel this is becoming the case for many college students and recent grads. college and the perfect job are almost assumed, but working it all out is harder in real life than on paper.
Friday 20 August
By Bill
After all of the many angles we try to take about this issue, there is one basic truth. Since the individual is emancipated at 18 and essentially unfettered, and since the parents cease all legal and moral responsibility to support the individual at 18, YES...Do what you want when you want, but not on my dime, kiddo...This falls into the "you can't have it both ways" category. I have been through this with my two sons, and each took a different path. I am not telling them to grow up according to any set plan. I simply expect them to REALLY do it their way, and on their own.
Friday 20 August
By Kim
The problem is you will never be able to "do it all right" --and the fact that you made that statement speaks for itself. NOTHING is EVER DONE ALL RIGHT. Ever. No one expects your generation to be perfect, what they do expect you to DO is GET A JOB. PAY your OWN RENT instead of sponging off your parents by living with them into your 20's or older... FEED Yourselves. TAKE RESPONSIBILITY FOR YOUR OWN LIFE . Until you do that, no one is going to respect you. Let go of the selfishness. Shed the idea that the world revolves around you, because I can assure you IT DOES NOT. IF you don't realize that NOW, later in life you are going to be SOOOOOOOOOOO depressed when you DO find out, Just GROW UP, for crying out loud. Stop being so RUDE to others. Like , uh, you don't really matter any more than anyone else does. Stop with the drama. Stop bringint it into the lives of others. NO ONE CARES.
Handle IT YOURSELVES.
Friday 20 August
By ken
Elizabeth, First of all when making an argument you must get accurate facts as the basis of your argument. Most of us "older" adults DO NOT expect more from the younger generation......we expect less, and we are getting it.
Monday 23 August
By cheeflo
"How can we graduate college, find our dream job and settle down with Mr or Mrs Perfect without a few blunders? And when a blunder awards you a scarlet letter, why would we rush? We need to make sure we do it all right, without disappointing our parents, friends and, most of all, ourselves."
I can guarantee you that no matter how long you take or how careful and deliberate you are, you will make your share of blunders and disappoint your parents, friends, and yourself. Until you understand that, you won't know what your dream job is and who Mr. or Ms. Right might be. How you recover from your blunders is what will matter in the long run. Will you castigate yourself, make the same mistakes again and again, and become risk averse? Or will you pick yourself up, recognize and learn from your mistakes, and try again?
Two things: (1) Perfection is the enemy of the good (Voltaire). (2) You learn more from one failure than you do from years of success.