Remember cash? That green, waxy paper stuff that features one of several dead presidents or Ben Franklin? Well, for upwards of four years, I didn't. Never carried it. Never used it. Couldn't tell you which guy went with which dollar amount. My preferred currency was plastic and like most of us slaves to the magnetic strip, I swiped with reckless abandon. Sure, I applied my version of mental checkbook balancing to each purchase, but come the end of the month my numbers never quite subtracted up.
I was in need of serious spending self-help -- a solution that would remind me of the value of the almighty dollar and stop me from swiping without thinking.
And so, I went to the halls of self-improvement (the third floor of the local Barnes and Noble) and sought out the advice of the fiercest financial contributor to any morning news program. A woman who would have made Mr. Potter feel like a spendthrift. A woman who lives and breathes efficiency from the tips of her toes to the top of her haircut. The one and only Suze Orman.
Suze is a goddess of savings. She knows how to squeeze a nickel out of a penny and then turn that nickel into a million dollars. I figured she'd have an intricate system to reform my recklessness, but after a bit of research I found that for a case like mine she recommends the simplest of her waste-curbing practices: the Cash-Only Diet, aka the Suze Orman.
See, that's me, discussing my cash-only existence with none other than the Suze above! So, here's how it all went down ...
Doing the Suze means you develop a spending budget for each week, take that amount of cash out at its start, and spend only that until its finish. No debit cards, no credit cards, just cold, harsh cash.

What if there's a sale at Crate and Barrel on just the houseware you need? Suze says buy it next week if it's beyond your budget. What if it's two people's birthdays in one week and you have to go out on the town? Suze says pack a lunch and brew your coffee at home. What if you have a major date with a really great guy and simply must get a new dress? Suze rolls her eyes at you and walks away. No pain, no gain, her books say.
The Suze was just what I needed. She basically says your budget should include expenses outside of your monthly bills and essentials (rent, phone bill, electric), and acceptable offroading includes only things like emergency doctor's visits. In other words, this was a budget for your lifestyle money, not your life money.
I'm 26, and with my $1,100 rent, $200 college loans, additional life debt at $200 per month -- plus cable, electric, and 401(k) savings, my 40-something-K salary doesn't go very far. So, I gave myself a budget of $220 a week, withdrew my allowance and Krazy-glued all of my credit cards together. (Only kidding.)
My self-imposed requirements for what my cash would cover were as follows:
-- ALL food: groceries for cooking in, and all meals eaten out
-- Toiletries and accessories: Yes, that means toilet paper and cotton balls, as well as new lipstick or hair gel.
-- Entertainment: new books, movie tickets, concerts, etc. (Note: Concert tickets purchased one week for an upcoming event were tough because you have to buy those online. I couldn't count those against my weekly budget, but I kept a separate list.)
-- Clothes: also tricky. A new pair of sandals were a want, not a need, so did those count against the budget? Sadly, yes.
I cannot take you through my first week of cash-only life (I cheated twice and overspent by 50 bones) nor can I describe my second (I cheated once and overspent by $100), but a nightly glance at Suze's obviously-tooth-whitened-smile on the book kept on my nightstand stood as a constant reminder that I really wanted my teeth whitened, and that cost money I'd need to save.
I am now a proud two months into a fully-Suze spending style and, as such, have nestled into a weekly mental pattern that only gets less manic with time. These days, my weeks go something very much like this:
Monday, 9 a.m.: Withdraw weekly budget out of ATM. Breathe sigh of relief and skip joyfully out of Bank of America vestibule with pocket full of sunshine.
Monday, noon: Test early week willpower with bout of Bluefly browsing. Note: If ever there is a mechanism by which you feed cash into the laptop to make online purchases, it's all over for me.
Monday, 5 p.m.: Treat self to late-afternoon coffee after long day, because what's a $3.50 latte when I have a wallet full of cash?
Monday, 8 p.m.: Post-gym grocery shopping for week's worth of breakfast, lunch and some dinner. Feel accomplished, sensible, adult.
Tuesday: Challenge Day! I've grown accustomed to spending zero on Tuesdays as a way to reserve a surplus for later-in-the week social events. It's a small sacrifice that pays off incredibly well in mental and actual progress. That said, one recent Tuesday marked the start of the Barney's Warehouse Sale, and that was a disaster.
Wednesday: Incorporate one frivolous purchase to celebrate success of the week thus far. Options include: Tasti D-Lite, new magazine, sushi lunch, after-work cocktail. At this point cash remains plentiful, but the weekend looms. A Wednesday movie or casual dinner can fit into the plan, but not if there's a big weekend ahead. In other words, Wednesday is pivotal.
Thursday: The beginning of the end. Come Thursday I tend to want desperately to buy stuff I don't need -- new clothes for the weekend, a random houseware I stumble across on my walk home, a GROUPON for Bikram yoga. I cannot explain it, but Thursday is my spending siren ...
Luckily my office hosts a Thursday happy hour complete with appetizers, so that helps with post-work food and beverage. We'll tend to move from happy hour to some bar-related social activity, meaning the day's budget includes a cocktail or two, but still within budget. I like to think of Thursday as the judge of my progress from week to week. If I have more that Thursday than the week prior, I'm a financial success. This happens 30 percent of the time ...
Friday: Oh, Friday ... It feels like the end, but it's absolutely not. By Friday I realize what life supplies (all things purchased at either CVS or Old Navy) I'll need to get me through the weekend, and if it's saline solution, hair gel or any other of the more expensive toiletries, it's trouble.
Friday lunch out of the office is hard to resist, but if a big Friday night is in the works, it must be avoided. By now the bills can usually be counted on one hand, and let's just say they're not Benjamins.
A rough Friday night out -- expensive dinner or too many drinks -- can make the weekend a wash, so I have to be incredibly careful. Saturday and Sunday are two full days away from the office, meaning much more time to spend.
Saturday: It's either brunch, lunch or dinner, but definitely not more than one out of the house at this point in the week. A costly Saturday day or night outing can mean all meals must be eaten at home to make room for whatever concert, day-trip, or out-of-control karaoke session pops up. Come Saturday I am absolutely dying to swipe the debit card and be done with it. The wallet is full of small bills and change I have to keep because I'll probably need to use it. I am not above paying for a bacon-egg-and-cheese in quarters.
Sunday: Sweet victory, technically -- but Sunday represents a full 24 hours to go. Spend foolishly throughout the week and Sunday is the most miserable day of all. Save smartly and you can celebrate with a leisurely brunch, mini shopping spree, evening matinee or, if you have far more willpower than me, all three.
And there you have it. Seven days. One chunk of cash. Endless lessons in need versus want. I am not ashamed to say that I once went without paper towels in the house because it came down to the wire, and new razors were more important. I've also come to order vodka sodas versus beers because of the alcohol-to-purchase ratio. In the end, it's about making choices and weighing needs.
Of course, according to Suze, it's also supposed to be about having money left over at the end of the week to contribute to the savings pot. And, dammit, Suze was right: Two months into my meager diet has netted me $800 in savings. And just think how long I could live off of that.
Jessie Rosen writes the blog 20-Nothings.com, an account of getting by from 2-0 to 3-0. Today is Thursday, so you will find weighing her financial progress -- then drinking off her angst at her office's free happy hour.
More Good Stuff on the Web:
Which One of These Women is Plus-Sized?
Is There a Connection between Food and Sex?
I'm the Daughter of a Serial Killer
10 Things You Should Never Say To A Guy












Comments:
Add a comment
Wednesday 12 May
By Al Schrader
I don't recommend the cash only way. Your credit card will provide you with a list of expenditures so you can track them. Here's an example: Signs at Wal Mart say absolutely the lowest price, so I bought eveything there: paper towels, chips, meats, beverages, etc. When I got my statement, I had spent $100.00 more than I expected. When I combed through the charges, I discovered that the extra $100.00 had gone to Wal Mart. How ? Yes, some of the prices are lowest but interlaced on the shelves are some wallet killers - the laundry detergent, potato chips, paper products, pasta sauces, etc. Last year Wal Mart did $400 billion in sales. That money came from somewhere. In the end the way to have money is don't spend it. Mow your lawn instead of paying others (35 cents worth of gas verses $50), etc.....Al-
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By lindee
Has anyone ever written an intelligent, live changing blog ? The trend continues...
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By John
I do not buy new clothes, I do not go out ot eat, i do not go out for drinks,
because i cannot aford to. So do not complain .
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By robyn
my heart bleads for you. you make ONLY 40K+ ONLY?????
try doing that on 15K because you've been downsized. try doing it when you haven't had company medical or 401K EVER!
what do you spend on transportation? on charity? what do you spend on anyone other than yourself? how would you get by without all those freebies?
and as for cash? i hope you don't ever lose your wallet or get it pickpocketed.
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By Jenn
I realize this is a younger person, but it certainly goes to show why our country is in the condition it's in. Someone made a comment, "would you feel better if she shopped at a thrift store" Umm, yes actually I would. I do quite a bit of shopping at thrift stores and yard sales. I buy alot of things that still have tags on them. In order to save money you have to learn to be thrifty and really change your habits. For someone that has a great job and a good income then I guess you could consider her plan as a good "savings plan" Oh, but wait, isn't that what's happened with a lot of people? Lots of people thought that since they were educated and had great jobs, they didn't need to worry about what they spent. The last few years with the downfall our economy has taken should be a warning to all....doesn't matter the job or education, we all need to learn how to save...that means not worrying about the latest designer fashions or the latest trends, it means gee, how much can I get into my savings account this month
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By flyguy_3
I have been using the cash only spending for years and recording every cash transaction in to a quicken cash only spending account . I withdraw a fixed amount of cash for my wallet and then use it for Gas , groceries , entertainment , misc expenses . Saving my credit card for mostly major purchases . I then periodically compare what cash is left in my wallet with what my cash spent account last entry was in the computor. They should theoretically come out equal . They never do !!!! Why ? because you would be amased how often you can forget to ask for a reciept and then try to remember 3 days later purchases you made without that reciept so you can accurately record it. Does this mean this method isnt effective ? No ! because it still allows you to keep constant track and make adjustments on your spending and keep it withen a reasonable level despite the fact you dont always balance out . I periodically balance the account out by recording the difference on the computor as : " unaccounted for spending" and start over again.
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By nick
Suze has been suckering in folks for years and she is making a 7 figure salary and laughing all the way to the bank at all you folks, another one of thse liberal JEWS who gives big time to liberal causes, here we get fooled again.
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By Kathy
I think this is a great article. It's kind of a coming of age with finances! It's the first step in a process. I was a great bugeter in my 20's out of neccesity. Then I got some plastic. Now I'm back peddling to get out of debt so I can someday enjoy my retirement. I think my parents were right. They couldn't wait to pay off the mortgage and live debt free. I used my equity to pay for college tuition for my kids, so I am starting all over again. I won't pay off my loans for at least 20 years. On the bright side, I have given my kids opportunities I never had. And if I had kept the other spending in check, I probably would have saved more for thier education.
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By steff
$200 a week left over after bill paying..wow!
That's alot to spend on food and paper and entertainment.
I'd think I was in Beverly Hills.
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By IF Group LLC
While it is a smart move to budget oneself, paying for EVERYTHING with the green-eyed presidents is not always in your best interest (no pun intended)!
What Ms. Orman fails to divulge is the fact that you cannot build a "credit score" using just cash! As a young adult just starting out in life, you do need to begin to establish a credit history, for future reference...a house, auto loan, etc. Most of the College loans are in both student & parents names, does not really help with establishing your own credit score!
It is OK to use plastic, IF & this is the key here, IF you can budget the dollars spent on the credit card, and pay it off each month, you will establish credit worthyness AND stay within your means!
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By ARC
Love the article. Thanks for the honesty.
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By pete
1. Get a cheaper apartment.
2. Make a lower contribution to your 401k or stop contributing altogether for a while
3. Cut back on utilities you uws.
4. If you are having money problems what the hell are you doing with CABLE???
You aren't the only one who's been there. Orman isn't the only one who's come back from there. She just wrote books about it and got her face on TV, and made a fortune.
I lost my job in 1976 under carter. I was out of work for less than a week, but the cut in pay and working hours cost me my house. From 1976 until I retired in 2002, I spent more time living in my car than in any kind of building, but I paid my debts. All of them.
It all boils down to one thing: At the end of the day you have only your integrity. Did you stand by your word? Or did you choose to screw somebody who trusted you out of what you owed them?
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By Jennifer Butcher
Does she give anything to church, charity, others?
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By Allen
I love Credit Cards, you have no protection with CASH (except to protect yourself from you ownself-no self control ?) I also get 2% cash back on
every thing except my income tax payments. Who save the most Cash or Credit?
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By jon
u gotta be kidding,who does this person think she is...this program of suzy whats her name is rediculous..I'm sure your all aware that she works for the finaciail services industry...shes a fraud
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By pwayne
Boy, this girl is not by any means saving for anything. I have been on a cash budget since the '80's and don't let cash drain through my hands like this woman. The first thing is stop spending! period. I go by the 10/10 rule: 10% to tithe, 10% to save and that is other than my 401K. Bills are nest--mortgage, utilitites, car note, car insurance and my medical account; here is where I put in each payday a little to cover the next visit since my deductible went sky high. After that is food, clothing (you would be surprised what you can find at a thrift store), I do buy new underwear and shoes though WARNING do not become a slave to designers. I also have parties in where everyone brings something; I do not drink beer so you bring your brand--the food is fun and usually my friends are too strapped to drink anything other than soda or water, like me. I do not eat out at all, I make it at home for less than the cost of one egg muffin, I can make four--see where I'm going? Eating out and drinks are too expensive for my crowd and no one is thrown out for getting rowdy; they are taken home to sleep it off.
Anyone can make the change. just add up what you spend out--save the receipts at the end of the week and you had better be sitting down, it is horrific what we give to someone else for our bucks. You wouldn't give away services as an accountant or attorney for free but this is what you do when you buy a pack of cigarettes at $6 a pop or a drink at $10 to $15 a pop. Our way of life is convenient for us not inexpensive--you are paying for it and through the nose or wallet.
You're right Spencer, she spends way too much.
Reply
Wednesday 12 May
By Jerome
This babe is a real piece of work. Obviously her parents never thought her any fiscal responsibility when she was young. First of all you need to eat out only twice a month and learn how to cook. She also has to be a little off to be drinking $3.50 Latte's all the time. And I think this dingbat needs to look for a less expensive place to live or take on a room mate to share expenses. $1,100.00 a month rent is way more then she be spending for rent. This woman is a poor example of how to handle her expenses. A dime to a dollar says she will be back in the same finiancial saddle she was in six months from now. If you don't live beyond your means and save your money, you can be like me and retire at age 55 with no bills and never have to work again. I did not need an over rated Suze Orman to show me how to do it. By the way, my 4 year retirement anniversary is coming up. I own my home outright. I have no car payments. And, I carry no credit card balances on 5 credit cards. I never have.
Reply
Friday 14 May
By albqjag
While I'm considerably older than the writer, I can attest to the soundness of her strategy. Living a "cash only" life has allowed me at 54 (I started this at 45) to be totally debt free and own my cars and very comfortable home out right. Like the writer, I've allowed myself some luxuries which also enabled me to stick to my budget. Doing the "cash only" thing makes you realize just how much credit actually costs. Interest is money you're giving other people that could better be spent on you.
Reply
Thursday 13 May
By retired with a small pension
Here's how I am doing it and it works quite well. I do not have any monthly bills other than my utilities and general stuff. I only use the debit card...no cash because if you've got the cash in pocket you are tempted to spend it. Every part of my budget is on Excel and I can watch it every day on the banks site if need be? So much goes for food, entertainment etc, my house is paid for, i keep my car in good shape and have weatherized the home which has really cut my electricity bills about 40%. Sometimes I wish i had more disposable income however, its kind of neat to be in control of your finances.
Reply
Thursday 13 May
By Scola
Suze Orman is a two bit fraud. She peddles recycled common sense punctuated by a few stupid tidbits for $19.99. Worse yet she embraces things like the cult of the FICO score. The cult of the FICO score is basically saying liquidity is not what you can sell but what you can borrow. This is hugely destructive.
I pay for everything on a credit card. However, I have never carried a balance in my life. Every couple of days I look at when my credit cards are vs. a target number and if they are too high I dial down the spending. Every month I look at my bank account after paying the credit cards and if the balance gets below $X I dial it down again. There's nothing magic about paper.
The reason my system is better is I get 2% cash back on every credit purchase, which I then put into my money market which I also have targets for rising over time.
Reply