There's nothing like a good Hollywood meltdown, especially when the subject is as detestable as Mel Gibson. His "Gallipoli" days far behind him, Mel's become a bit of a frootbat in recent years, in case you haven't noticed. And I know you have. I really can't think of a more humiliating, scathing example of naked, caught-on-tape aggression than his recent Oksana-bashing rants.
As a pop-culture voyeur, I do get a certain schadenfreude from listening. But as a woman, I also get a chill. Because brutal as those rants are, it took me a couple rounds before I finally said, "OK, I haven't heard that before." Because I have an abusive ex exactly like Mel, and I had tapes like Oksana's. And hearing it all again makes me just a teeny bit sick to my stomach.
I should interject here to say: my ex went to AA, got sober and made amends, and not just to me. These days we're arm's-length friendly: He might ask me for relationship advice, I might send a link about Mario Brothers for him to share with his kids (whom I still adore). In fact, when the Mel Gibson brouhaha hit, he called and asked, "Didja hear the tapes?"
"Are you kidding? I got déjà vu," I told him.
"Ah, you're a b***h," he laughed. Then, after a pause, "I'm sorry."
There's a lot to be said for amends. But the years I spent being called hideous names, shrinking under the sonic boom of his screaming temper tantrums, and walking on eggshells hoping to avoid a new rant didn't just disappear. I no longer hear him in my sleep (correction: after writing the rough draft of this post, I did have some night-sweats), but it's sometimes hard to hear him when I'm awake.
As I read the Tweets and various comments on articles about Mel, I'm depressed (though unsurprised) by the number of people who express empathy for him; apparently, there are a lot of angry mates out there who might not like what he said, but feel we all lose our cool sometimes. That assumes that screaming, "If you get raped by a pack of n*ggers, it'll be your fault" qualifies as losing your cool, but all right.
However, I'm downright annoyed by the "gold-digger" accusations flying around. The idea is that Oksana only released the tapes so she could shake Mel down for more money. But I mean, here's the thing: the tapes still exist. He still said that stuff. She couldn't shake him down for a single cent if he hadn't given her enough rope to hang him with.
So, why stay with him? That's the next question on everyone's lips. Why, if he was the kind of guy to say this brutal stuff, did she have a kid with him, stay with him, continue to see him even after he broke her teeth?
I get it.
It doesn't start out like that. It starts out great, like any relationship with a narcissist. They turn their limelight on you, and you bask in the warm glow of their attention till you're hooked. You experience love and connection as never before. But you're not in a relationship with a normal person; you're in a relationship with a cipher. And as the facade slowly vanishes, you start frantically chasing after him emotionally, figuring it must be something you did.

As the abuse ramps up, from verbal to emotional to physical, you begin to doubt your own perceptions, even your own sanity. This can't be happening, because it's so illogical. There's nothing else in your life you can point to where this cause (say, rolling up some Ethernet cable in a particular way) had this particular effect (being screamed at for a half-hour).
But the other person completely denies any wrongdoing, so your brain -- your normal brain -- decides the only logical conclusion is that you're simply mistaken. Anything that upsets that status quo gets sent somewhere else; the memories are stored in a different way, so you can't access them easily. It's a way to survive in crazy situations, and it serves you well if you're living under an oppressive regime you can't escape. If you're living under an oppressive regime that you could escape, if you weren't in such slippery denial, well, then it's less helpful.
If this is starting to ring a bell for you, I recommend the book "Dragonslippers: This Is What an Abusive Relationship Looks Like," by Rosalind Penfold. The illustrations border on cheesy, but the information is solid.
I used to make tapes like Oksana's, store them in a secret corner of my laptop, and listen to them when he wasn't around in an effort to shock myself out of the relationship. I also took snapshots of things he destroyed, wrote myself peppy and encouraging notes, and sought out therapy whenever I could get away. So, I get why Oksana was making these recordings.
And even though she says she's not the one who released them, I'd be totally on board if she were. Because when you're in the shadows, emotionally alone with crap like this, it's hard to convince yourself it's as bad as you think. It's only when it comes into the light that you can see what's really up and do something about it.
I think even my ex agrees with that.
Amy L. Keyishian lives in San Francisco, but left her heart in Brooklyn. She's written for every magazine you can think of, having spent four years as a Cosmopolitan staff writer and then freelancing for Self, Glamour, Maxim, Men's Health, Seventeen, Inc., Mac Life, and who the hell knows what else. She has a couple kids, a couple step-kids, a husband, and a severe Twitter hashtag addiction. 












Comments:
Add a comment
Thursday 29 July
By Kitty
Do you really think she purposely put up with that abuse for the money? Listen to what that sounds like. That line of reasoning is nuts.
Thursday 29 July
By Ann
Van - Reading your comment makes me think you are Mel or an abusive person yourself. You don't understand and lack insight. Your comment about Mel using abusive language, but so what proves that. The tongue can be worse than an actual punch to the face. When you are screamed at mercilessly over and over and called things you could never have imagined could come out of a person's mouth, your soul is bloodied. Especially since you look at that person and think . . . I loved you, I had children with you . . . what happened, where is this coming from, Dear God help. Why won't you just talk to me? It's not that the woman doesn't ever do anything wrong, it's that if she does, she must endure the wrath, no matter the size of the offense. There is no mercy. For you women on this board who have never experienced such a thing, you have NO RIGHT to comment . . . NONE, just as I could not judge you on how you handled a particular problem in your life without knowing all the details. I use to say the same thing . . . why would a woman stay in that crap? Then I was in it myself and you are trying to survive, take care of kids, pay bills, clean, etc. It's not easy to try to take your children to a shelter and I thought about it. I could say oh so much more, but I'm sure you'd only judge instead of have an ounce of compassion for the pain of another. Back to Mel . . . he left a beautiful wife of 30 years and 7 children. Sad choice. Hopefully he turns back from his horrible choices.
Thursday 29 July
By Jan Weber
Yes, he reminds me of my ex-husband. Mel thinks he is a super human person, and really is just bipolar and needs medication.
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By Terri J
Amy, your article is truly an eye-opener. I don't understand the sympathy for Mel either. Not only did he practically admit hitting Oksana and then tell her that she deserved it, but he made some disparaging comments about her young son that I find completely despicable. I mean, this man built his own church where HE could make the rules, one of which is that women MUST wear head coverings inside. If that is not the action of a narcissist, I don't know what is. I think he would fit in nicely with the fanatics in Afghanistan and Iraq. They treat women like crap too.
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By Nitty
Thanks for the story. I felt the same way when I heard the tapes. A blast from a past that I thought was mentally and emotionally discarded. We have to thank the gossip mill for surfacing what anger and abuse really looks like. You really hit it in the article. Instead of worrying about the celebs involved, though, our society should be focusing on the increasing number of people - including celebs - that are experiencing mental health and personal identity issues, and the people (especially the children) that are affected.
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By Not Born Yesterday
Mel went crazy when he realized he had been played by Oksana. His ego couldn't take it. He divorced his long time wife for her and now realizes what a bimbo Oksana really is. Oksana has another child by another actor as well. She is not innocent. This is her pattern. She knew exactly what she was doing. Mel turned into an abusive man and now, six months later, Oksana is trying to extort money from him. They are both nuts! Adultry never has a good outcome. Mel should have known better up front. Hey Mel, when you lay down with swine you are going wake up in slop! The children are the real victims here! Neither one of these "adults" is gets any sympathy from me!
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By peter
it would be nice if the shalom boys left mel gibson alone.
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By friends of mel gibson
sometimes a man has to be a man and keep a golddigger in line, poor mel look what happens when a man doesnt control his woman like the great hulk hogan!
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By Bev
My ex was also like this, but I thought she was Borderline, perhaps with some Narcissism. Very skilled, drawing me in, being perfect, and then the attempt to destroy me. She seemed out of control, but I finally learned how very much in control she was, so mental illness is no excuse for abuse -- which is exactly what she herself would say. Almost 10 years together, but I had no idea that most of what she told me about her life was a lie until her daughters (who she had abused told me.)
By the way, I'm amazed at how abusive most of the men responding seem to be -- how incredibly female-hating and how much they identify with and defend Gibson. As bad as some women can be, most are far better than men.
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By Van
Well spoken and completely neutral and rationale in your thought process. Not!
Wednesday 04 August
By Dr. Hasenfratz
These guys are pathetic: misogynist (not that they can spell the word, much less define it), lacking in self-respect, and projecting their insecurities onto women. Mel Gibson is also pathetic, simplistic and delusional on several levels. Won't go into it in depth here because - for our woman-bashing readers - this level of discussion precludes having a vocabulary consisting primarily of four letter words.
Thursday 29 July
By bird
WHEN I HEAR THE REAL TRUTH I MIGHT FORM AN OPINION UNTIL THEN I REFUSE TO BE A GUPPY......... LOVE YA MEL!
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By Give me a break
You can tell that the person that wrote this article does not like Mel Gibson. Most likely has never been a fan of his movies. Just because men like to beat her does not mean that Mel did what this gold digger said. I also was in an abusive relationship before but I'm sorry..the tapes sound like they were rehearsed on Osksana's part. She knows how to push his buttons and that is what she was doing. Maybe you should wait until all the facts are in before you hang the guy. As it is right now we do not know if he abused her or not or if she is just trying to get all his money. Funny he never abused his ex wife or first 7 kids. Abusers abuse EVERY woman they are with not just one woman.
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By sandladyvb
I think anyone who has lived with a parent, spouse, sibling, or even a friend who abuses or abused alcohol could hear the familiar pattern of an individual totally overtaken by addiction. Dry drunk or wet drunk, Mel's verbal rants are all too familiar. I give Oksana a lot of credit for going public with Mel's garbage. He's had plenty of chances to get emotionally as well as physically sober.
This isn't the first time...just another is a series of events. The man has deep seated hatreds for Jews, women and anyone else who doesn't practice his weird brand of "Mel on top" Catholicism.
I hope his career continues to take a nose dive and his wallet gets a lot thinner because these are the only things that are going to register in his mind that maybe, just maybe, Mel Gibson has serious mental problems in addition to alcoholism.
I hope his wife continues to stand up for herself and the safety of her child. I hope she will choose her next partner more wisely--a) a man who is not currently married to someone else, b) a man who if he is alcoholic, is practicing a program of recovery, c) she learns to take care of herself on her own without having to lean a man to provide her with a luxurious life, and d) the first sign of verbal or physical abuse, she bails out of the relationship immediately.
Mel Gibson is getting the bad publicity he deserves. He's got no where to hide because the fact that he is a rager and an abuser is out in the public. Mel Gibson is his own worst lethal weapon and society needs to put him out of commission where he can't harm any other woman or child. Sick people do sick things and Mel definitely has "sick" covered. I hope his you-know what gets blown off so that maybe, just maybe he will stop thinking with it.
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By themop123
Hey listen I understand where you are coming from and you're completely right that being a woman makes your ex's behavior totally unacceptable. Acting like a raving lunatic and screaming at someone is wrong. Yes Mel Gibson did say the things he said. He was obviously drunk. She calls him and intentionally records him over and over again. She stays with him and even has a baby with the man. Sure shes a victim but her motivations for staying with him were not completely pure. This is especially true in the financial sense. If you look at her motivation for wanting to date Mel Gibson in the first place and thinking that would be a viable realistic long term match you would find definite opportunstic tendencies. Just because woman don't scream and yell doesn't mean they aren't trying to cause just as much damage as someone who is yelling. In your article you don't say one thing that contributed to the relationship being bad. Just like this woman Mel Gibson didn't admit one thing either. None of us are really able to admit we are immature and just like Mel Gibson because we don't know ourselves. That is the reason divorce rates are so high. Both the man and the woman are right. It's how they say it that is different. Mel is a verbally bombastic nutcase and she's a passive aggresive golddigger.
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By lokismommie
Has it been proven that Mel Gibson did in fact make these recordings?
I, too, was abused and I also know that some women lie about abuse in nasty divorces. That makes it bad and harder on those of us who were/are real domestic violence victims. DV is not a laughing matter or a joke. I do not recall any press claims about police being called to the Gibson home for domestic disterbance. Are these allagations true? I hope she is telling the truth and not faking things/charges.
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By Ok
There is more to this then what has been told.You ladys look to vent because of a husband and wife thing.I know alot of woman have been done wrong.at the same token men has been used as a excape goat as well.I herd the phone conversation and the woman was to nice acting on the other end.Like it will be said a millon times over...why did she record this phone call as to all the ones he called her?Sure Mel is Mel,grant you that but why do you record a call and have your sister spill it to the press unless you have something going on.Mel was cranked up about something and sex happen to be one of the things.Hard to make a call here because no one knows for sure.This bimbo who is tring to get in the high lights might need to eat a sandwhich or two.
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By foolish
Amy, I hear you- really. I dont have tapes, only terrible memories that haunt me. Apart, but still living in fear. Uhh... What I do know is every day is a blessing and God is real. I hope we all find the peace we never really knew.
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By I'mhealingnow
When I heard those Mel Gibson tapes it made me sick I lived with somone like that for 20 years til 2 months ago when he left, You do try to tell yourself it will get better and he has problems but ti is much more than that. It almost detroyed me emotionally and physically. I got one major disease after another from constant stress and lonliness from cancer, Fibromyalgia, High bloo pressure, hypothyroidism (gained weight) to reight before he left diagnosed with heart disease just had 2 surgeries(I am not that old) also grown son was being abusive physcially and mentally I stay last few years because health so bad could not leave. Since he (both gone) have left my health has improved 100% . I am finacially in bad shape but I am so happy no stress no insults. You do start agreeing that maybe you are the one crazy, mean, ugly and all other horrible names. But by Grace of GOD I am doing great now
Reply
Thursday 29 July
By themop123
Yeah Jane you're perfect right? I'm sure all you're passive aggresive "I'm a victim" thinking really helped that relationship. It's easy to point at a guy yelling and blame the guy. You don't realize how obnoxious you probably are. It's doubtful that it's ever one sided. Blame yourself too. Stop putting the responsibility on other people. You made the mistake of getting married or you stayed too long in the relationship. Or you actually were driving the guy nuts. Somewhere you made mistakes and plenty of them.
Reply