"You don't drink?" You'd think alcohol consumption was a personal choice -- so why is that question always asked with such disdain?
Last week, one of our bloggers wrote about "the pregnant pause": Though normally a social drinker, she waved away a glass of champagne at her best friend's engagement dinner due to her developing embryo -- only to be met with silent stares. Not wanting to disclose her pregnancy or steal her best friend's thunder, she flailed to find an excuse for turning down alcohol.
While readers weighed in with suggestions on avoiding the non-drinking issue, from disguising a soda water as a vodka tonic, to lying about being the designated driver, a bigger question emerged: Pregnant or not, why is it so wrong for someone not to want to drink?
As Rachel Kramer Bussel pointed out, perhaps the issue in this situation is less about pregnancy, more about our misguided attitudes concerning alcohol. She says, "I despise the 'You don't drink?' question when meeting new people. It seems to come with a tinge of 'What the f**k is wrong with you?' Maybe I'm projecting, but still, it definitely comes with a tinge of, 'You are not like the rest of us.' I mean, really -- pregnant or not, can we just drink or not drink on any given night and not have it be a BFD?"
For most of us, four years in college doesn't exactly lend itself to an alcohol-abstaining culture. Lena Chen says, "There is definitely a 'drinking culture' among college students and young adults, in that bars are a default meeting place and drinking is a default weekend and post-work social activity." She adds, "I think people come across as a bit judge-y toward non-drinkers, because my refusal of alcohol could be construed as a condemnation of their decision to drink."
That misconstruction is entirely understandable. Maria Diaz says, "I'm a drinker ... I will admit to feeling weird around people who don't drink or who don't drink as much as I do. So, you know, SORRY! But it's much more about my insecurities about how the non-drinker is judging me because sometimes, they are. Or, in times when I haven't been drinking, I know that I'm annoyed by drunk people."
And if people give you crap for your choice not to drink, says Amber L. Rhea, "I always reference a comedian whose name I can't even remember now but who once did a routine on how people don't act all weird about anything else the way they do about alcohol. People don't go, 'You don't use mayonnaise? Why? Are you addicted to mayonnaise? Is it OK if I use mayonnaise?'"
Tell us! If you don't drink, do you find that people judge you for it -- like you have to explain yourself? And, if you do drink, do you silently judge other people who don't?
More on Lemondrop...
+ Why One Guy Has Chosen to Stay Single
+ The 11 Saddest Animal Movie Deaths of All Time
+ Funny Video -- Pole-Dancing Cat
+ Why This Vampire Fiction Is Better For Women












Comments:
Add a comment
Friday 16 April
By leaf
I'm a 47 year old man and have never drank, trust me it's nothing to do with medical condions or moral beliefs just never liked it . when I was younger folks would give me some grief but for the most part it was a non-issue. Now that I'm married for 21 years to a woman who does drink it comes in handy, my wife like to go out to the clubs drinking with her girl friends and I am the driver. I always get free sodas and coffee at the clubs and look like a playboy with 10 women in tow every where I go.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By R
I GUESS IT SMART AND CLEVER TO GET SHIT FACED, RIGHT??
Reply
Friday 16 April
By Jeff Mauser
I stopped drinking years ago. Here is what I tell people when they ask me or say "You don't drink?" And yes I feel I am being judged. I tell them at first, "Not any more." If they continue to ask me I tell them I am alergic. If they keep asking I tell them I tell them I am alergic I break out in handcuffs. If they keep asking I tell them they don't have enough, once I start drinking it is hard to stop and you don't have enough for me to contiue and have any for anyone else so no I won't. If they keep asking I tell them nicely to F off and leave me alone.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By jim burgan
i don't drink and i don't drink because i have been a substance abuser. when asked why i don't drink i explain that the world is safer without i never make any remarks about other peoples choices i made mine and as of today it is still the right choice for me.
Reply
Saturday 17 April
By Vicki
I get this all the time. I choose not to drink because I don't like the way it makes me feel and I am ALWAYS judged by people. I don't say to the people drinking "you drink!" or "are you an alcoholic"! Get over it, some people just don't for no other reason then they don't want to!
Reply
Friday 16 April
By sbbntexas05
What in the heck is the matter with simply saying "No thank you"...??..., and let it go at that. I have a glass of wine once in a great while, but most times I would just not bother....
Reply
Friday 16 April
By John
Drinkers LOVE to be with Drinkers. Druggies Love to be with other dopers. I do not have a reason for not wantinmg a drink when asked other than I do NOT want one. That is enough. Get used to it you ass-holes.
Christ why do people need to pull others into their screwed up habits?
Reply
Friday 16 April
By diane
I will drink as long as I am not doing the driving not even one if I drive.
I have always been the designated driver when I am out with my friends from the time I was a teen. Just felt my friends drank and sometimes were not responsible enough as they would try to get behind the wheel.
I am a daughter of a recovering achoolic and I do recall times when he should have not been behind the wheel but I was not driving at the time I drink moderately but if I am at a party and I don't have to drive I can get drunk if I choose or I can drink moderately depends on me and what I want to do. I don't do it often as I don' t like hangovers the next day.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By karen
I have never been a big drinker, and now i am a non drinker due to diabetes and a failed liver...but i never really got a lot of flack for not drinking, i just always asked for tea or soda when asked what i would like to drink and smiled and never had anyone ask why i wasn't drinking alcohol instead. think the big smile with a request for a drink made them think i just didn't understand the question, lol. but for the few who asked why i don't, i just asked why did it matter to them, or would ask, why do you drink? why do we think we have to answer anyone's nosy questions anyway? and i went out with friends who drank, they never cared if i did or didn't.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By SteelRaptor
I don't drink, and I have been of drinking age for the past 18 years. I have tried drinking before and I didn't like the feeling of getting drunk, it was the exact same feeling I used to get when I would stand in one place and just spin in circles. That and the fact that I don't like the taste of alcohol, raw or in drinks.
I don't judge the casual drinkers, and no one really has ever judged me, at least not to my face.
Reply
Wednesday 21 April
By Wendy
I hate booze. After having a handful of bad experiences with alcohol in my youth, in which I had the "spins", was nauseated, and had an incredible headache the next morning, I decided booze was not such a great idea. What really sealed the deal for me was being an apartment manager for 6 1/2 years in a 17 unit building in downtown San Francisco, in my 40's. After having the joy of having to deal with big, rowdy parties of drunken twenty-somethings, I realized how dangerous and stupid drunken-ness really is. This does not even mention all the incredible carnage from drunk driving.
So, if someone refuses a drink, just let them be! I do not hassle someone if they want to drink, I just do not want to. The incredible chaos that comes with drunken behavior, the huge messes in untold millions of families with alcoholics at the helm, kids traumatized by drunken parents... the list goes on and on. Too many people cannot stop at one drink, they just get hammered, and the consequences are anything but pretty. If it stayed in a quiet corner, that would be one thing, but it does not. It KILLS, self and others!
Sober is what I am : no drink, no drugs. Much better!
Reply
Friday 16 April
By MomHadIt
I don't drink. I had served six years in a military unit, and did quite enough drinking then. My first husband was an alcoholic. Choosing not to drink is no one's business. We always order water (It's usually free, or a bottle of water costs about $1) A "drink" can run you $5 - $10.
Yeah. I'm not drinking. What ever reason you give is not someone's else's choice.
I don't feel like driving drunk and killing someone tonight, nor getting myself killed either. I am on medications that interact with alcohol? I'm trying to loose weight? I have to drive somewhere far I leave here? Why does anyone have the right to make you feel wrong for not drinking?
My pet peeve is when everyone is splitting the bill, I make a point to be sure they pay for their drinks separately. In one of my old military circles, the Captain would always say, why don't we split it evenly? She would have had 4 or 5 drinks, ordered shrimp or something else expensive for an appetizer. It finally got where several of us brought it up that we were not drinking and would not pay for hers anymore.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By L.Borja
I'm not a big drinker. I rarely have alcohol in my home. If I'm out to dinner I may or may not have a drink. If someone should question my chose not to drinkl I just say I don't feel like a drink today. End of discussion.
Reply
Saturday 17 April
By Robert
Evidently I travel with different crowds than most participants in this discussion. Some drink, some don't, and there is no fuss made either way.
It is the same thing with vegetarians. You eat meat or you don't - no big deal. Get over it folks.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By Lesli
I consider myself a non drinker. Seriously it takes me two hours to finish a wine cooler. To be honest if you are uncomfortable around your "friends" for not drinking or any other sort of behavior, then you need better friends. At ages over 21 you should be well over Peer Pressure. Grow up.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By Chris
I believe that everyone should do what makes them feel comfortable. I'm a musian in a rock band that used to play in bars and nightclubs. By choice, I have not had a drink since High School (1980). I don't care for it. I've been around so many people who have consumed too much alcohol and it's beyond annoying. Have the self respect and dignity to do what you choose to do. If you don't want to drink, don't drink. If you choose to use alcohol...do so with caution and respect for your fellow human beings.
Peace!
Reply
Friday 16 April
By Lucy
I don't drink because I don't like the taste of alcohol and I would prefer to use the calories for dessert! If someone offers me a drink, I just say, "No thank you." If the person persists in asking why, I say just what I wrote.
Few people have ever made me feel uncomfortable about it.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By sue
The same thing happens often with food/dessert. The only acceptable answer for refusing dessert is, "I'm just stuffed." If you say you're being health conscious, watching saturated fats, have a cholesterol problem, etc, you're met with the rolling eyes. But "I'm stuffed" works great. No one bothers me nearly as much about alcohol and my policy is not even 1 drink if I have to drive anywhere at all in the next 2-3 hours. No one gives me any grief over that reason either.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By wllharrington
I read your comments and wonder why any of you feel that you owe the person an answer. It is none of their business as to why you don't want a drink. I am 70, I don't drink because I don't care for it. Ignore the question as if you didn't hear it. The questioner will then have to either stop or ask you again. At that point you can politely say "why do you want to know, because it is none of your business".
Reply
Friday 16 April
By Stephanie
I drink.... just not alcoholic beverages. What's the big deal anyway? You drink, I don't. Big whoop! Why does everyone think that it's an issue? It only becomes an issue when you believe you have to justify it, either way. When someone asks you what you would like to drink, it doesn't have to become a political debate or a need to offer ridiculous excuses about why it's non-alcoholic. It's your own demeanor and attitude that invites the questions. Act like it's no big deal... and it's not! I am not, nor have I ever been, a drinker... and it has never been an issue.
Reply