"You don't drink?" You'd think alcohol consumption was a personal choice -- so why is that question always asked with such disdain?
Last week, one of our bloggers wrote about "the pregnant pause": Though normally a social drinker, she waved away a glass of champagne at her best friend's engagement dinner due to her developing embryo -- only to be met with silent stares. Not wanting to disclose her pregnancy or steal her best friend's thunder, she flailed to find an excuse for turning down alcohol.
While readers weighed in with suggestions on avoiding the non-drinking issue, from disguising a soda water as a vodka tonic, to lying about being the designated driver, a bigger question emerged: Pregnant or not, why is it so wrong for someone not to want to drink?
As Rachel Kramer Bussel pointed out, perhaps the issue in this situation is less about pregnancy, more about our misguided attitudes concerning alcohol. She says, "I despise the 'You don't drink?' question when meeting new people. It seems to come with a tinge of 'What the f**k is wrong with you?' Maybe I'm projecting, but still, it definitely comes with a tinge of, 'You are not like the rest of us.' I mean, really -- pregnant or not, can we just drink or not drink on any given night and not have it be a BFD?"
For most of us, four years in college doesn't exactly lend itself to an alcohol-abstaining culture. Lena Chen says, "There is definitely a 'drinking culture' among college students and young adults, in that bars are a default meeting place and drinking is a default weekend and post-work social activity." She adds, "I think people come across as a bit judge-y toward non-drinkers, because my refusal of alcohol could be construed as a condemnation of their decision to drink."
That misconstruction is entirely understandable. Maria Diaz says, "I'm a drinker ... I will admit to feeling weird around people who don't drink or who don't drink as much as I do. So, you know, SORRY! But it's much more about my insecurities about how the non-drinker is judging me because sometimes, they are. Or, in times when I haven't been drinking, I know that I'm annoyed by drunk people."
And if people give you crap for your choice not to drink, says Amber L. Rhea, "I always reference a comedian whose name I can't even remember now but who once did a routine on how people don't act all weird about anything else the way they do about alcohol. People don't go, 'You don't use mayonnaise? Why? Are you addicted to mayonnaise? Is it OK if I use mayonnaise?'"
Tell us! If you don't drink, do you find that people judge you for it -- like you have to explain yourself? And, if you do drink, do you silently judge other people who don't?
More on Lemondrop...
+ Why One Guy Has Chosen to Stay Single
+ The 11 Saddest Animal Movie Deaths of All Time
+ Funny Video -- Pole-Dancing Cat
+ Why This Vampire Fiction Is Better For Women












Comments:
Add a comment
Friday 16 April
By Merle
I rarely drink So when I am out and wave drink away and somebody questions it, I just say "cause I don't want to act like you are" works every time people know better then to ask. :)
Reply
Friday 16 April
By Simzee
Hey Merle, It's not like we need the "liquid courage" to speak up like you do. Besides, who wants to act like you when you're drunk? Not I that's for sure. Sorry, but anyone who drinks even one drink is a drunk. Have a nice day.
Friday 16 April
By TucsonMatt
Umm... Phil... try reading Merle's comment again, and this time do so more slowly for enhanced comprehension. He did NOT say he makes that comment out of the blue to someone who is drinking when he is not. He did NOT say he makes that comment just because someone offers him a drink. He DID say he makes that comment when someone offers him a drink, he refuses it, and then that person questions it. Since the article spent a lot of time talking about how people question someone's refusal to drink as if there is something wrong with the person refusing, Merle is obviously talking about someone who questions his not drinking in a way that is judgmental.
You, little Phillip, are the one who most likely needs to "get a friggin' life" and are most likely an "idiot" who is one of the obnoxious people who make a big deal out of someone who doesn't want to drink when you are.
My father's side of the family was almost 100% alcoholics. My paternal Grandfather died when my father was 6 from alcoholism. Myriad aunts, uncles and other relations died young of alcohol related diseases or accidents. As a result, I have never had anything alcoholic to drink in my life as there seems to be a genetic predisposition to alcoholism in my family. Thus, when I am at a party or with friends in a bar, I turn down any offers of alcohol. I don't judge anyone who chooses to drink as long as they do it in a manner that is responsible, and like most people, I don't like the way many people behave when they are drunk. But, that doesn't mean you or anyone else has a right to treat me like a second class citizen because I don't. People may have many reasons why they don't want to drink at all or occasionally, but they shouldn't have to subjected to intrusive quizzing about their decision as it may be something that is painful to them or they don't wish to discuss.,
Friday 16 April
By G.Blank
Way to kill eveybody's good time, Merle.
Friday 16 April
By EC
I usually get away with "no thanks". I rarely have anyone question me further. I admit its anoying when they do but since these situations come up in a social setting, and since I prefer not to kill the mood, I usually respond to further questioning with something like "I just don't feel like it tonight" or "I'd rather not". There's usually plenty of other people around who are drinking so people usually let it go at that.
Saturday 17 April
By reticulum9
If someone questions you for not drinking, they deserve to be insulted. They should be questioned for their unhealthy dependence on alcohol.
Friday 16 April
By Marilyn
I don't drink because I am taking medication. Medicine and drink don't mix.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By Kieran
I am NOT on medication that prevents me from drinking, but I have found that telling people that I am gets them off my damn back. I rarely drink, mostly because there are many alcoholics in my family and I am honestly in fear of the disease's genetic component. In addition, liquor is expensive, it's high in calories, it tastes bad, and it makes people act like complete morons, so frankly, I don't see the upside to drinking.
Friday 16 April
By mark
thats what i was thinking. i take xanax and the first time i drank just two beers i got sick. im used to them now tho. to the dumbazz that said if you drink just one drink, youre a drunk. well you are WRONG!!!
Sunday 18 April
By Ami
Same, Marilyn. I can have a little something with low alcohol content, but other than that, baaaad idea. That and I'm very very short, so it takes a lot less to pump up my blood-alcohol level. One normal sized glass of wine, taken at a nice, slow pace with a full dinner, will make me pretty tipsy. Add that to the medicine that already knocks me out on its own and the fact that even a few gulps too fast will give me major heartburn, and surprise, surprise, sometimes I just don't feel like having anything.
It's not because I'm judging anyone or I think alcohol is "bad". Sometimes I just don't want anything. I love ice cream, but I'm not going to have a huge sundae every time there's some around. Maybe it's too cold, or I've had enough sugar for the day, or I'm just not in the mood for ice cream at that exact moment. No one gives people weird looks for passing up a cone of ice cream, so why the weird looks for passing up a shot of booze?
Sunday 18 April
By Messa
I just tell the truth and say "I never acquired a taste for it." I don't tell them this part, but it all tastes like rubbing alcohol to me. I can't stand the stuff.
Friday 16 April
By jerry l
My wife or I neither one drink nor have we ever. We do go out socially, and are asked, "How do you have a good time without drinking?" My standard answer is, "We get our fun from watching those who do drink." I have never been challenged on this non-sensical response.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By Vanessa
I do not drink ever. When out with friends drinks always get offered and when I refuse (even from that know that I do not drink) I get weird stares and you hear the whispering start. I don't drink due to kidney issues. For some reason people are just shocked when I do turn a drink down.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By Kathy
hello i have the same problem. I have a kidney disease and am down to one kidney and people at work continue to hassle me about how I don't drink. Like I need to get drunk or something . Very frustrating. My disease is heriditary and my brother was on dialysis and now has a kidney transplant and they still don't get it . nice to see I am not alone Kathy
Friday 16 April
By Katie
During college, I played on the varsity soccer team, and we had a team rule where we couldn't drink 48 hours before a game. Rather than just sit around and watch movies on Friday nights, I would still go out to parties, and sometimes people would bother me about it. But it seems like most people got it, no, I'm not drinking tonight, why does that matter to you? I think people probably feel like they are being judged because they are insecure. No one really cares what you are doing, and for the people drinking, I highly doubt the nondrinkers are really judging you if you are hanging out in a bar, or there are copious amounts of alcohol being served at a party.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By JoeG
I go on a lot of business trips. All of my business buddies like to drink at the "business meetings" in the restaurants in the evenings. And we're not talking about a drink or two; we're talking about a lot of wine and a lot of mixed drinks. These "business meetings" usually turn into pretty wild affairs. I have diabetes so I can't drink. Don't get me wrong; I love the taste of good beer and wine. I used to order a beer and slowly drink just the top third of the glass throughout the whole "meal" just so I wouldn't get a rash of crap from the rest of the group. At the last trip I went on just a few weeks ago, I stayed away from the evening drinking sessions and was later given a load of crap about not being a "team player." Why should I have to reveal the fact that I have diabetes? Drinking is such an ingrained and expected part of American business. It makes me sick. And the attitude I get from my business buddies is disappointing too.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By dreamer2
JoeG, I wonder if you work for the same company that I left 8 years ago (hint: it was in the Southwest). Almost every month there was a mandatory 2 – 3 day business meeting followed by dinner each night in a restaurant of the president’s or VP’s choosing.
Each and every meeting ended up being extremely offensive as the more the honchos drank, the more they encouraged their subordinates to follow suit. A large majority of my colleagues were at least 10 years younger than me (in their late 20’s / early 30’s) & they thought this was “cool” & were quick to oblige.
99% of the recently hired young girls (& a few guys) either ended up puking their guts out or passing out after being pressured to “come on, just have one more”. I can’t count the number of times where a (50 something year old) boss ended up carrying an unconscious pretty young girl out to the car & into her hotel room. The next day’s business meeting was always typical, lots of raging testosterone & plenty of high-fives from these old men.
Since I was always taught never to mix excessive drinking with work & after seeing what asses they made of themselves I would only occasionally nurse a glass of wine. Would you believe my f’ing boss (he was 28 at the time & I was 39) actually gave me a bad yearly review because of it? I was floored. Even though my review stated that I had the “highest sales quota” of all my peers & was an “exemplary employee” he wrote me up for not being a team player. I quickly found another job & told him to pound sand.
Friday 16 April
By M
it was jim gaffigan who said that... hiliarous
Reply
Friday 16 April
By ladyzirp
I don't drink because of religious reasons. I used to drink on occasion, but now I simply choose not to, When I go out, I simply order a diet soda, and don't make a big fuss about it. But I do find that others that do drink seem to get offended that I do not. Fortunately, I don't get that reaction very often anymore. Everyone knows my beliefs and accepts them. And truly, you can really have a good time without the alcohol.
Reply
Friday 16 April
By amy
I dont drink ever. I have never been drunk. Both my parents were alcholics.
Reply