If you were an ice cream flavor, what ice cream flavor would you be? Well, if you're "Dating Game" contestant Rodney Alcala, probably the kind that kills people. The swingin' bachelor and convicted serial murderer appeared on "The Dating Game" in 1978 -- after he'd already been convicted of sexual assault. Even creepier? He won. Bachelorette Cheryl Bradshaw selected Rodney as her dream date, but we're guessing it didn't go well -- within the next year, Alcala brutally murdered five people. This past February he was found guilty of the crimes and currently awaits sentencing. (CNN)