Finally, a modeling competition in which contestants will be required to have a little meat on their bones. Re/Dress, a boutique for plus-size women in Brooklyn, N.Y., just kicked off a modeling competition, reports the New York Daily News. The catch? The call for models starts at size 18.
In theory we're all for it; we're just a bit confused by all the body-image absurdity these days. Shall we review?
-The fashion industry refuses to look twice at a woman who's one potato skin past a perfect size 4. In fact, they prefer perfect 0s. Or any women who resemble a "hanger," the famous fashion dictate which says that clothes look best on a woman whose body most resembles the wire accessory.
-- When a size 10-ish model with tummy pooch appeared in the September issue of Glamour magazine, the response was so rabid, she was quickly rechristened "the girl on page 194," and the magazine vowed to be the first to include more models who reflected "real women" in its pages. We sighed: Finally, a model who looks like us.
-- Despite that pledge, two months later, Glamour featured famous plus-size model Crystal Renn in a dress she didn't quite seem able to zip up. And we argued that most of the models the magazine deemed "plus-size" were actually smaller than the average American woman, who is a size 14.
-- Now, one of the first modeling searches celebrating real women and their curves skips over the sizes 12, 14 and 16 -- and jumps straight to 18 and up.
We ask: Is promoting women who are size 0 -- or size 18 -- beautiful or irresponsible? And why can't magazines -- and anyone who's going to send women down the catwalk -- select more models who aren't at either extreme?
More Good Stuff on the Web:
Is it okay for women to hit men?
Talk Nerdy to Me: The Top 5 Sci-Fi Date Movies (TechLand)
Parents say the darndest things! And now, the Internet is there to collect them all (CrazyThingsParentsSay)












Comments:
Add a comment
Thursday 11 February
By frug
TO ALL OF THE IDIOTS THEY PUT DOWN FAT PEOPLE: FAT PEOPLE ARE WARM, LOVING, GIVING PERSONS, JUST OVERWEIGHT, BUT STILL HUMAN. NOW IF YOU TALK ABOUT OBESE PEOPLE THEY TOO ARE HUMAN THEY JUST NEED MEDICAL ATTENTION, BEFORE THEIR WEIGHT ISSUES HINDER THEIR LIFE. THIS IS NOT MEANT TO SAY SLENDER PERSONS ARE NOT LOVING,ETC, BUT THE OVERWEIGHT TRY HARDER TO GAIN RESPECT.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By Amanda
I'm glad that plus size women are being accepted more in this thin-crazed socieity. Let's face it, not everyone is a size 0. Plus, if that was the equivalent to beautifil most real women would be considered ugly which is definiatly not the case. I am a size 12-16 in which different sizes fit different on me. I've always had the worst time and most times felt "fat" in regular size stores and I'm glad that some peole are doing the right thing and not buying into the thin bandwagon.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By exerice & work out
I'm 5'5 133 lbs.
I eat healthy and exercise. It's good to have a "healthy" weight. If you are over weight for your height work out and exercise. It is good to "embrace" yourself at any weight but it will cause you health problems down the road.
A LOT of the medical conditions we Americans face have would decrease substantially if we recognized our flaws and just worked out.
Yes beauty comes in all shapes and sizes, but in unfortunately your health does not.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By Autumn
Wow jealous that your skinny ass is no longer in the spotlight? That's pretty pathetic and really shows your character.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By Verna Grasso
I think that we as people have to learn to more tolerant of other people's short comings. Nobody is perfect. When someone is painfully thin or overweight, other people notice and the people who care about them worry. Either can cause severe health risks. Some people don't like to feel "fat" and are constantly dieting while others feel comfortable with a few extra pounds and there are some people who don't think about it at all and are just what they are. As long as you are not at one extreme or the other, who cares? If someone is happy with themselves, then leave them alone, not everybody wants to look like you to or you think they should look. If you want to be accepted as you are, then learn to accept others.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By sfcabe
if you consider yourself skinny, then you do not know what fat is. size does not make one fat.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By lgwfamily
As a large woman who 22 years ago was a plus-size model (while wearing a HUGE size EIGHT!!!!), this subject still pisses me off big time (no pun intended).
We could discuss the evils of being a size 4 or size 20, or the insecurities brought on by the fashion industry all day, but that wouldn't address what is really at play here, so let me clue you in on something...
Everyone, regardless of their size, deserves a chance to look decent when dressing. Some days a nice pair of jeans and t-shirt is fine and some days a muumuu us also fine, but then there are days when my job has a Black tie affair and I want to seriously rock the wardrobe and not look like a friggin garden tent! As a human being, particularly in America, I have the same right to get quality clothing as someone smaller. Being bigger should not disqualify me from looking good in my clothes. We have that right. What we do not have, is the opportunity since designers focus on the 14% of society that can actually wear their clothes and ignores the vast majority who can not.
Staying on topic, for the companies now interested in reaching out to larger women, I applaud you!!! When I was a young model wearing a size 8, it hurt me terribly to be called "FAT." And it's almost funny now when my sons (ages 20 and 15) see pictures of me from then and talk about how skinny I was. Reality check: when I view a magazine/catalog that purports to sell plus-size clothing, I want to - at least occasionally - see a woman on the pictures who LOOKS LIKE ME so I can see what I'd actually look like in the clothes. To see a size 8 model wearing clothing designed for a size 20 is insulting. WHY is it so horrible to consider having models in all sizes? Why not offer quality designs in ALL sizes?! Why do designers think we want to look like circus tents? This could be fixed by incorporating REAL plus-size (18-32) models during the design and fitting phase.
It isn't a war between fat and skinny. It's a war between quality for all and disrespect. I vote for quality.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By Amanda
Women are beautiful no matter what shape and size, but modeling the extremes of both sides sends the wrong message to children in reguards to health. Yes I am all for loving yourself, but I feel like people on both sides are making unhealthy choices. Considering that we spend upwards of 150 billion dollars on healthcare related problems due to obesity, and an estimated 63 % of Americans are overweight or obese, and 1 in 3 children are on the same path, we need to focus on people that are in the healthiest range. Eating disorders have also become a problem, with anorexia, bulimia, and binge-eating. We need to do something to break this vicious cycle. We should not glamourize being out of the healthy range of weight for either side.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By nessa
beauty comes in all shapes, sizes, races, religons, and genders. thin people don't like fat people, because they're "ugly." fat people don't like thin people because they're thin. beauty is in the of the beholder. everyine forgets that models on magazine covers have flaws too, they have luxury of airbrushing. i'm sure if i had a photo that was airbrushed i would look good in a dental floss bikini too.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By keith
I love it and I think it will show that there is beauty in all women
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By Jill
I get really sick of thin vrs plus size, I think there are beautiful attributes to both. I think thin women look lean, and willowy, and that is beautiful. I think plus size women look curvy, and feminine, and that is beautiful as well. What about the people in the middle? I would love it if the fashion industry showed a wide variety of people, women with a pretty faces, hair, and carry themselves well whatever size, that sells.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By Kaitlin
I am a currently a model and a thin one at that. I eat regularly and am very healthy. Just because a woman is thin and in a magazine does not mean she has an eating disorder, unhealthy, or disgusting. I am tired of people saying they want to see "real women" in magazines. Well guess what, I am a REAL woman too, who just happens to be thinner and healthier than some. I agree that women are beautiful at all sizes, but stop being so judgemental and stereotypical about things you know nothing about.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By Mike
I love a plus women who wants to make love to a bag of bones
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By sally65
I think some are missing the point. Advertising is designed to sell "the dream". If you are 5'4" and wear a size 14, advertisers are trying to enhance the fantasy that you too can look gorgeous in this outfit. Couture designers are biased toward lower sizes because their clothes do not look good on heavier models and most of their clients are below a size 10. But the thing about couture clothing is it is tailored to a woman's body. The sad fact is for women who are size 18 or above, it is challenging to envision how something will look on you when it is worn by a size 12 model. There are catalogs who cater to plus size women, who use realistically sized models but they are few and far between. Instead of trading barbs between skinny, "average" and overweight people, it would be pleasant if (1) we can all accept ourselves as we are; (2) accept others the way they are; and (3) if there is something we want to change about ourselves, go for it without demeaning someone else. As women we are way too hard on ourselves. If we have straight hair, we want curly hair, if we have curly hair we want straight hair, we are overly critical of every aspect of ourselves, thanks to the glorification of what the fashion world decides is "perfect". The "perfect" model in the 1950's is not the same "perfect" as today's model. In medieval times, those women who were "rubenesque" were glorified because that size was associated with getting enough to eat, hence healthy. I suggest that we not judge ourselves against an artificial "model of perfection", which changes over time culturally. Let's just learn to love ourselves and focus on what we can do to make this a better world, which doesn't include criticizing one another.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By Rose
We all need to stop judging each other!!! I am glad we are not all the same in height and body size.
For Jennifer: You think being overweight is disgusting and that fat women should put down the fork and exercise. Not everyone is overweight due to eating and lack of exercise. I have PCOS and thyroid cancer. I have struggled for 23 yrs to return to the size 4-6 I was in high school. Due to the medication I take I gain instead of loose. I exercise and still I am fat. God made us all different so that we learn tolerance, love and selflessness. I thank God that I have experienced being thin and being heavy , so that I have the ability to accept all shapes and sizes as human worth is the most important aspect in this life.
Be happy with who you are and love yourself no matter what. You are a soul from God and he loves you thin or thick.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By Jace Beleren
I am a guy. And as for me, I like a woman with some meat on her bones. I can't stand looking at models that are size "0", and yes, I agree that this company is doing the right thing. There should be more places that do this sort of thing. Why cover up what everyone looks like, or make the assumption that everyone *NEEDS* to be skinny to be happy. That's not how it was in the natural world hundreds of years ago. At those times in Human's history and evolution, bigger women were adored and worshipped. Why? Because, if a woman was bigger, it was natural that they were healthier, and more healthy to have children. Look at the Native American's history, and you will see the same thing. Carvings of wood or clay necklaces that depict bigger women.
I even have someone in mind who could and would do great at modeling. However, because of all these egotistical, self-hating-therefore-I-am-going-make-you-miserable-about-yourself people, she probably won't do it. Because of all the hate and people putting her down about her size and weight she now has self esteem issues.
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By Mary
ATTENTION LADIES: In reading these comments, especially from the majority of men, the following now does pertain.......
SIZE DOES MATTER!!!!!
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By Mary
The thin ones, or do you really mean to say the UGLY ones?????
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By Plus Sized Barbie
This goes out to all the plus sized ladies out there...
did ya'll know that Marilyn Monroe wore a size 16 back in the sixties? I do believe that would translate into size 18 or 20 nowadays!
I personally think that women are beautiful no matter what they look like.
I also wanted to say that everyone is not a skinny miss. Not that there is not anything wrong with being that way, I just feel that just because I do not look like the gal's in the fashion magazines, doesn't mean that I am not a real person too.
I think that all the designers out there need to make clothes for plus sized barbies that does not look like something I would re-upholster my couch with!
Come on now!
Ladies of the world, stand up and say that I am a beautiful woman!
Plus Sized Barbie
Reply
Thursday 11 February
By ljsurf322
No, sorry, Marilyn was more of a 12 back then which translates to today's 6 or 8. You don't need to believe me...just look at a picture of her! She was thin!
Either way, I applaud your attitude, but don't forget that health comes first - whether fat or skinny.