It's hard for us average-bodied folk to sympathize with the body-image struggle of someone who is 5-foot-10 with a 24-inch waist, but that's just what Vogue is asking us to do in a January article glorifying Lara Stone, size-4 model.Could Vogue simply be riding the coattails of the magazine industry's plus-size fever, or is this a legitimate issue of acceptance?
In the face of plummeting ad and single-copy sales, every mag is doing what it can to refresh its image. At least with Glamour's celebratory buzz about plus-size Lizzie Miller, the model in question was actually a size 10. (Whereas we're not sure we could make a fat roll form on Lara if we tried.)
The Vogue article cites the embarrassing situations Lara has encountered because of her size: "Worse than being called fat is a gaggle of stylists whispering in a corner after you've been trying on clothes for 10 minutes."
Compared to other models, Lara does have some curves -- and while we guess having actual protrusions from your chest in a sea of of women with the figures of prepubescent boys must be challenging, it looks like her career is chugging on. She's landing work with Givenchy, Calvin Klein and Marc Jacobs. Let's put it this way: If somebody's still throwing money at you to pose in silky underthings, I think it's safe to say your "extra" curvature does not appear to be a major roadblock in your career.
Lara's struggle with her size might have made a semi-interesting story if there weren't plenty of successful size-4 ladies already walking the runways. With measurements of 35-26.5-36, supermodel Gisele Bündchen of Victoria's Secret fame actually has a couple of inches on Lara in all departments. That hasn't stopped her from landing contracts with Louis Vuitton or Dolce and Gabbana. And did we mention Gisele's the highest-paid model in the world?
Moreover, can we truly rally behind a model with curves if she would actually still rather ... well, be skinny? Lara says, "People still tell me I'm fat, but when I look in the mirror, that's not what I see." Yet her history of dieting, exercise and pills doesn't have us convinced of that; at one point, she turned to alcohol to get through the day. Not exactly a paragon of shapely body confidence.
Stories like this one only serve to cement our frustrations about the fashion industry's self-congratulatory nature when it comes to hiring models who barely crack the stick-skinny standard. We'll start clinking our glasses together when someone who actually resembles the average woman finds herself in a glossy Versace spread. Bottom line is this: If the industry is taking progressive steps toward showcasing models who aren't waif-thin, we're all for it. But we're not throwing any parties just yet.
Our essay on Glamour's Lizzie Miller sparked a lot of dialogue, many of you saying that you want your models to be pencil-thin. What do you think about Lara Stone? Also, check out the slightly different opinion of our friends at StyleList.com.
More on Lemondrop:
Why a Guy Won't Text or Call (And He Likes You) (Lemondrop)
Hilarious Christmas Decor Disasters
Master Cleanse -- Do or Don't? 











Comments:
Add a comment
Wednesday 23 December
By erma
I completely agree with you. Although I am slightly overwieght myself, I have never understood why people try to convince themselves that they are better than anyone else simply because they are bigger. I wouldn't like a thin person trying to convince me that they were better because they were smaller so why do big people expect thin people to take it? I'm in the prcess of losing weight right now and even though I dont want to be overly boney or sick looking, I do not want to continue to be overweight because its unhealthy and not that attractive.
Wednesday 23 December
By Dale
From a Man's point of view, I sure wouldn't kick Lara to the curb with a Nice body like that ! , On the other hand I don't want a Couch Potato soap opra addicted eating machine that's as big around as she is tall ,
Being Fat is Not healty & being a size Zero sure couldn't be either,
You ladies need to quit worrying about what size the lady sitting next to you is wearing & worry about your-self, If you are fat take up walking & if Skinny eat all of your veggies & then some !
Lara,, CALL ME !!! ;p
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By Sequin22
Those who obsess and whine about their weight need to be shipped to Iraq or Africa. There they will learn that a body can be destroyed in a matter of minutes (IED explosives) or a matter of months (starvation).
If you have a body that does everything a body is supposed to do (walk, stand, work, take care of babies etc)- you have an excellent body.
A body is more than something to decorate with clothing designed by gay men.
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By Danielle
Julie get a freaking life I mean seriously. Just because I have a little meat on my bones does NOT mean I am a "Fat Hog" grow the fuck up an get some brains.
A size four shouldn't even be considered fat I mean really it is a size 4 for Gods sake. I think people need to get a grip on things, face the fact that you are a nasty woman. People like you are the reasons why 8 year old kids have eating disorders for no damn reason.
Grow Up.
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By Mike P
The modeling world is an odd place. Thin women are just as beautiful as any one when it is natural. Its the women who are pushed to be thin. Pushed to the point where they look unhealthy. That is very unattractive and it creates a stereotype that all models are anorexic. I cant completly disaggree with the description that many models look like prepubescent boys. Ive seen many desighners who push for that skinny short look in their models. Ive seen quite a few sport butch hair cuts. Keep in mind that many of the male designers are homosexual and while most men want to see women in the clothes, they want to see boys, so they do their best to meet in the middle. Ive seen so many models who looked sick, unhealthy and very unhappy. Perhaps people are noticing that and this is why they are satarting to think that thin is bad. Ive always found a peron attractive if they smile and have a good nature regardless of size or looks.
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By Chuck
Lara is just a wonderful looking lady
Being Obese/Fat/Stuffed is never nice
If the overweight people do not want to accept
that they are not attractive except to a minority of men
that is theor problem
Lara Is a 10+ but even without fabulous breasts she would ne a 10
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By Mok Mok
Listen everyone has a different body type. And yes some of us should eat more and some of us should eat less. The bottom line is if you are overwieght because of your eating habits and lack of exercise then try to fix it. If your thin because of your diet and exercise then fix it as well. Be happy with who you are and you will be fine, I refuse to let the press dictate what I should where and how big or small I should be. They are trying to sell you on different products thats it. Do what you are comfortable with. I am 5'5 and weigh 137 lbs, I am 41 and a grandmother and have never felt better, screw the critics.
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By alicekrm
The only time I see the front of any magazine is when I am in the grocery checkout line. It is really disgusting to see these fat women on the cover such as Oprah, Michele Obama and other ugly women. It is a known fact that fat people are unhealthy and are burdens to our health care system. Obama wants his health care fiasco passed, yet allows his old lady to eat too much. I wish so much that we would have had a nice looking family in the Whitehouse instead of those people.
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By Tara
Michelle Obama is not fat...she works out like mad...I find it very interesting again in this post that we can talk about anything not even political...and you un-american people still bash our leaderss. Maybe you have a problem with Oprah and Michelle because you are a racist idiot....how come you didn't mention Paula Deen (she is definitely a big woman and I see her on the shelves)....your post diplays your true ignorance.
Wednesday 23 December
By Jen
Oh wow. You are really ignorant and hateful. Sorry you don't want "those people" in the Whitehouse, but they are a beautiful family to many people. Michelle is regarded as gorgeous to many people (even Oprah). Get over it. Your thinking reveals ugliness, which is so sad in this day and age.
Wednesday 23 December
By Joy
I think we should all be grateful for what we are and consider it a blessing. There are all types of people in this world who just needs to know that somebody cares. It does not matter if you are Skinny, Slim, Plump, Fat or Full Figured. We also need to teach our children that we are all different for one reason or another. I am not Fat, Plump but just right! We hav got to stop labeling people we are all humans and put on these earth to get along with one another. For years it was always the perfect body that was shown on Magazines why not put every shape and size in them and we can all be happy. Just be happy with who you are and others will relate.
God Bless you all!
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By Mary Ellen Sawyer
I am not now and never have been a model never could have been one even in my young and beautiful days. I feel that the pressure put on young women these days is way too much to be thin. Yes, being plus sized isn't the end of the world ladies, i actually have had a fairly good life not being thin like vogue models. Personally I don't even look at magazines like vogue, the clothes designed in them aren't for a "NORMAL" sized woman and never have been. When they start publishing pictures and stories about women who actually are woman in our real world I may start however, are we doing anyone any good by portraying woman as "prepubescent boys" in the "high fashion glossies"? NO WE AREN'T BECAUSE REAL AMERICAN WOMEN AREN'T SHAPED THAT WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By Kris
And ignorant people like YOU make ME sick...
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By Benwa
She looks like Peter Boyle in "Young Frankenstein."
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By john
wow all I can say is wow what makes a woman that has gained weight from having children a fatt hogg you are not a nice person and I bet if the truth be known you are over weight yourself. I am a 41 year old man and I don't like skinny women my wife was a little bigger in high school where we met and fell in love now after 2 children she is a little bigger still and I've seen her starve her self try diet after diet pill after pill with no results. I love HER for who she is not how she looks you can be beautiful on the outside but ugly as hell on the inside. My wife is both now that she has accepted who she is a wonderful mother loving wife and a beautiful woman. Just my oppinion.
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By babs
Can we please start evolving beyond this juvenile weight obsessed curves vs no curves, tall vs short, blue eyed blonde vs sultry brunette yada yada blah blah blah. Insipid stupidity galore. Does no one ever think about reality? Frankly I have quit purchasing Vogue because of the constant over the top attempts at being artsy fartsy and not delivering anything but this type of useless fodder. If I had this article I would use it to wipe my size 36 arse. Call me a fat slob because I have some curves? Pardon me and my grey poupon...but life is more than starving yourself into some glorified version of the new THIN. I have been thin all my life. THIN with curves. Flat chested, flat tummy, long neck, Ideal ballerina build, except I have a fabulous lush ass..Design clothes that flatter the female figures..of all shapes. Quit this so LAST LIGHT YEAR thinking. It's borderline retarded. BLech. Vogue is so not VOGUE anymore..It's just simpleton sheeples following design memes spouted by egomaniacs who don't have taste at all. Real women want real clothes. Wake up ya dummies! stop putting women down in your vomitous articles. New Years Resolution ...Never look at another VOGUE magazine again.
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By Lea
I totally agree! And I do NOT buy that magazine anymore either.
Wednesday 23 December
By Laura Beattie-Proctor
How sad that this seems to be a mud-flinging issue. Pre-pubescent boys vs. a "fat" size 4. Enough already! As someone who has been bald due to chemotherapy, and dropped over 100 pounds after a heart attack due to the damage the treatments did my heart at 35, I am sick of hearing the whining. The average woman would love to be a size 4! It is hard to walk into a store and see 10 shirts in size 4, & 6 but 2 in a 12 or 14. It hurts to ask where the misses section is only to have the store clerk direct your size 12 self to the Plus size section.
Some things in life are predetermined, your eye color, your natural hair color, allergies. Other things we fight with genetics over: the body shape we get from our Mom, or the wide shoulders we get from Dad, the strong jawline everyone in the family has. We can choose to live healthy, not to smoke or drink, to make educated choices in food so that we can live a good life. You can't control everything but it is our responsibility to try to make the most out of our health. We do it with our budget, right? It's our responsibility to make our money go as far as we can. In the long run we pay the ultimate consequences or that impulse buy, or poor budgeting. The same goes with our health!
As someone who in 5 years has gone from a size 18 (only because I refused to buy a 20) to a size 4, I am sick of the whining and bitching! As a society we should be more concerned about being healthy, and having enough energy to do the things we want to do in life, rather than trying to look like a child: tiny and fragile! We need to put down the soda and cheeseburgers and let ourselves enjoy a walk with our spouse or the dog. Get out & play catch with the kids, or go bowling together. Make healthy choices that will allow us to spend more time with our family and friends.
Your life is what you make of it. Quit complaining and do something about it. Feel sorry for yourself and you get nowhere! Become the change you want to see in the world!
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By Doug Sebert
She is a very beautiful woman. I think she looks a lot better than some of the walking skeletons. She needs to be happy with herself.
Reply
Wednesday 23 December
By Betty
I don't think we are just talking about "big" women being in ads, I think we are talking about "average" size 9, 5'4" women. There oly seems to be the very thin in most ads, very few average or even women of all sizes,you see only one thing.
Reply