It's hard for us average-bodied folk to sympathize with the body-image struggle of someone who is 5-foot-10 with a 24-inch waist, but that's just what Vogue is asking us to do in a January article glorifying Lara Stone, size-4 model.Could Vogue simply be riding the coattails of the magazine industry's plus-size fever, or is this a legitimate issue of acceptance?
In the face of plummeting ad and single-copy sales, every mag is doing what it can to refresh its image. At least with Glamour's celebratory buzz about plus-size Lizzie Miller, the model in question was actually a size 10. (Whereas we're not sure we could make a fat roll form on Lara if we tried.)
The Vogue article cites the embarrassing situations Lara has encountered because of her size: "Worse than being called fat is a gaggle of stylists whispering in a corner after you've been trying on clothes for 10 minutes."
Compared to other models, Lara does have some curves -- and while we guess having actual protrusions from your chest in a sea of of women with the figures of prepubescent boys must be challenging, it looks like her career is chugging on. She's landing work with Givenchy, Calvin Klein and Marc Jacobs. Let's put it this way: If somebody's still throwing money at you to pose in silky underthings, I think it's safe to say your "extra" curvature does not appear to be a major roadblock in your career.
Lara's struggle with her size might have made a semi-interesting story if there weren't plenty of successful size-4 ladies already walking the runways. With measurements of 35-26.5-36, supermodel Gisele Bündchen of Victoria's Secret fame actually has a couple of inches on Lara in all departments. That hasn't stopped her from landing contracts with Louis Vuitton or Dolce and Gabbana. And did we mention Gisele's the highest-paid model in the world?
Moreover, can we truly rally behind a model with curves if she would actually still rather ... well, be skinny? Lara says, "People still tell me I'm fat, but when I look in the mirror, that's not what I see." Yet her history of dieting, exercise and pills doesn't have us convinced of that; at one point, she turned to alcohol to get through the day. Not exactly a paragon of shapely body confidence.
Stories like this one only serve to cement our frustrations about the fashion industry's self-congratulatory nature when it comes to hiring models who barely crack the stick-skinny standard. We'll start clinking our glasses together when someone who actually resembles the average woman finds herself in a glossy Versace spread. Bottom line is this: If the industry is taking progressive steps toward showcasing models who aren't waif-thin, we're all for it. But we're not throwing any parties just yet.
Our essay on Glamour's Lizzie Miller sparked a lot of dialogue, many of you saying that you want your models to be pencil-thin. What do you think about Lara Stone? Also, check out the slightly different opinion of our friends at StyleList.com.
More on Lemondrop:
Why a Guy Won't Text or Call (And He Likes You) (Lemondrop)
Hilarious Christmas Decor Disasters
Master Cleanse -- Do or Don't? 











Comments:
Add a comment
Tuesday 22 December
By Kate
Sooo... It is okay to say that thin women look like prepubescent boys, but it's not okay to say heavier women look like :insert rude analogy:? I'm tired of rude comments about thin women being acceptable- as if a thin woman can't develop a complex. When I get tired of hearing rude comments about my figure, I stuff myself until I'm sick in an effort to gain weight. Is this any healthier than a heavy woman crash dieting when she others bring her down? No, it's not. Bottom line is that everyone needs to be kind to one another and stop with such hateful comments.
Reply
Tuesday 22 December
By Jasmine
I wanted to post the same thing when I first read this article.
While I think it is absolutely amazing that there is a push to have magazines and fashion represent "big" women, it is often done in a way that puts down smaller women. Some small women would love curves... it would be great to be able to fill out a dress!
But what we really need to do is stop saying one is better than the other. And just because a women is small doesn't mean she is starving herself and just because a women is bigger doesn't mean she is not happy with her body.
Wednesday 23 December
By quantumdriven
I'd do her!
Wednesday 23 December
By Jef
Honestly go eat something....I'll comment on both of your situations. Go eat something without throwing up you twig and the other fatty can go eat a horse your both lame stop feeling sorry for yourself if your too skinny stop throwing up and if your too fat STOP EATING.
Wednesday 23 December
By The Pisces
Now YOU are insulting prepubescent boys by making rude comments about their bodies. I doubt if they are driven to eat everything around them to please you, however. If you quit trying to control other people's comments and just look how you want to, you won't have to eat everything.
Wednesday 23 December
By Chloe
I agree. People need to stop putting down skinny girls as if thats how they choose to be.
Everyone is a certain way naturally and nobody should assume that just because they want to be super skinny, a super skinny girl is happy with herself
Wednesday 23 December
By dash8833
I'm a fatty, I don't like that fact but its true. I'm a fatty because I eat more than I exercise off. I am tired of people scared to say someone is fat because it might hurt there feeling. accepting people for what they are rather telling them to lose weight. You wonder why we have health care problems? Why is diabetes and heart disease so pronounced in our society? Because we worry more about hurting feelings than the rest of the body
Wednesday 23 December
By gandelf
haha ur prolly fat
Wednesday 23 December
By Bill
I'm wondering why I wasted time reading this. A woman who is a size 4 has issues. Welcome to life!! Another strike on our society. I was married to a model for many years. A more shallow and empty person you won't find. People, ACCEPT who you are, and that God has a reason for you being the way you are.
Wednesday 23 December
By Lisa
Which all comes back to "If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all."
Thursday 24 December
By Ellie
Thanks, I agree! Stop w/ the rudeness and let's be nice to each other. I can't keep weight on and get many comments about my slight build. I used to stuff myself too. .. It took a long time to just accept my body the way it is and learn what looks the best for my size and shape. So doesn't matter whether you're plus size or skinny.. just be the best you can!
Wednesday 23 December
By JANE
Grow up and stop paying attention to models and all the stupid comments on being too thin..too heavy. Who really cares what Vogue or any other magazine is selling?
Wednesday 23 December
By SOB
Get a grip.
Wednesday 23 December
By Heidi
I have to agree with Kate in a way. I'm a size 7, with a nearly there size A bust and 36inch butt, and it makes me very angry that you say that I look like a boy! I don't diet or eat really healthy, I was born like this and I'm not complaining. I'm all for inspiring positive body image, but I hate that magazines now are accusing the stereotypical model of looking boyish. It is actually hurting my body self confidence. The average bust size for women used to be a "B" now it's a "C" because of more fatty diets and plastic surgery being done in the World. I wish magazines would send out the message to just love the woman's body for what it is, large, small, thin, thick, curvy or flat. It's our attitudes and our comfort in the clothes we wear that makes us sexy, not necessarily our curves or lack of.
Wednesday 23 December
By Jason
you people make me want to destroy something. learn to treat people as people and treat yourself with some fcking respect. all this discussion sounds like immature little idiots. please don't have children.
thank you.
Wednesday 23 December
By Eddie
i don't care either way. i just don't like the skeleton people, or the people that weigh like 500 pounds.
Wednesday 23 December
By Olivia
Look, the world WANTS skinny people! Have you seen the ads in magazines lately? And have you seen that ad that ralph lauren totally messed up?Skinny is what anybody wants to be. So don't complain when you're skinny, be happy that you're what everyone wants. This article is just saying that a woman is a size FOUR is NOT fat, and therefore should have NO problems in the modeling world. Theyre just trying to show that when women who are the size of the average american women, which is a size 12,14, or 16, then they will believe the fashion industry is pushing the limit. And i'm not saying you're not an average american woman, its just that when you add the weight of every woman in america together and then divide it by the amount of women you added together, you'll get women with a size 14 not a woman with a size 4.
Wednesday 23 December
By Di
Kate:
I am so with you on this one.....why do so so so so many people feel you have to be PERFECT....not to fat or not too thin? Plus I am sure not may of them have figures that can undergo much scrutney.
I am not 46...1
16 - 20, I was always complimented on my figure.
20 - 21, I did drugs and dropped weight....everyone had something negative to say about my weight but not my bad habit.
21-29 I had two children...no more 36-24-35 curvy Selma Hyak bod and sz 3 but still looking good at sz 5-7....even at that ...the first thing many asked if they did not see me in a long time was, "what happened to your smokin hot bod?"
29 - 35 I sported a sz 7 on a good day and 9 on a typical day....still it was as if people were not happy unless I sported my old body that turned heads.
35-45 I yo-yoed. I'd pack it on for a few years, take it off for a few years and just keep rotaing between sz 7-16.
46 now and I became ill...on meds and I am packing on the weight. Still the same loving careing me who is a good mother to my children, still have way above average character and I still am very honorable and respectful of others.
BUT the negative attention or lack of positive attention I get is at an all time high now.
My sister recently died of cancer...she had friends (I use that term lightly) who mostly are not overweight but they were drug addicts that hardly ever ate or slept. All low life cartons who were cockroaches that used my sissy for whatever they could. Not one of those cockroaches sat by her bedside despite her terminal diagnosis. In the end I sent my friends to sit at her bedside that knew my sissy through me. My sissy did not care if they were fat, thin, def, blind, white, black, male female, gay or straight. She was deeply touched that they truly cared once I told them she was passing and none of her so called friends were the least bit concerned to spend long periods of time at her side while she was so close to crossing over.
PEOPLE NEED TO WAKE UP AND GET OFF THIER HIGH HORSE NAD STOP JUDGING OTHERS. 1.) Most DO NOT have perfect bods themselves, 2.) Most likely their own friends and family have just as many f not more so mislabeled 3) They have horrible character if they are judging others. I'd rather know quality people than opinionated people who think they are better than others.
Wednesday 23 December
By Di
Bill:
Kudos! It sounds like you have lived and learned. As you mature and realize that we make bad choices of who we commit to based mostly on appearence and how good we feel when dating a hottie in the beginning. Yes, we soon learn that once we really get to know who that person really is.....we no longer can stand them.
Now spread the word....let other's learn from your mistake.
Wednesday 23 December
By brittany
I too had a problem with being too skinny. I force fed myself until I felt sick. Still I had problem getting boys to notice me because my chest looked like a "pre-pubescent boy's". I worked so hard at getting a huge plate of food down before my body could register it was full. Nothing helped me gain weight. I had a very good friend of mine who was the same way as I was. She always felt she looked like she was 12 when she was 17. I always told her she was the most naturally beautiful person I ever met and that she's the kind of person they look for for modeling. Now she's a model who travels the world and she's more confident then I've ever seen her. If big girls get curves and sexiness can't we skinny girls have modeling to help us feel attractive?! Apparently according to this article we can't. It's not about your body it's about your personality, which, apparently the personality of this writer is bitter and ugly. Maybe you should think before you rant?