Thanks to fashion magazines, fast food and size-0 actresses, American women live in a crazy funhouse mirror -- the more the obesity rate rises, it seems, the tinier and more unrealistic our idealized standards of beauty become. But is it that way all over the world? That's the question journalist Julia Savacool wanted to answer when she embarked upon a world tour of body-image issues that became her new book, "The World Has Curves: The Global Quest for the Perfect Body," and discovered that, globally, for most women, what determines beauty comes from more meaningful influences than Cosmo. We asked her to tell us about five countries who don't idealize the Keira Knightley physique -- though they each have their own set of body issues.
South Africa
For the women of South Africa, there was a brief moment in the post-Apartheid 1990s where the emulation of Western culture meant a distinct rise in eating disorders. But since then, a radically different, pro-body-image movement has arisen, due in no small part to the fact that the spread of AIDS has caused thinness to be associated with illness.
"When you lose a lot of weight there, people immediately start asking if you're sick," Savacool said. An interesting consequence of this is that Levi's have begun selling a special cut of jeans to flatter curvier South Africans; the style is not yet available in the United States, but does well overseas.
Fiji
The Fijian nation's leaders have striven to connect the once-isolated island with the rest of the world, but the influx of American and Australian television and films has begun spreading an unhealthy body image in a culture that has always embraced eating -- to the point where every visitor to a home is immediately greeted with a gift of food. There are pro-curves movements afoot, but the culture has been compromised by Western society.
Jamaica
For young women of this Caribbean nation, it's socially essential to have a little junk in the trunk, as the dance styles most popular in the country rely heavily on being able to shake what you got. As a result, curves are most definitely embraced, but naturally thin women are occasionally driven to consuming high-fat "chicken pills" in an effort to gain weight.
Afghanistan
Savacool is quick to point out that the body-concealing burqa used to be a personal choice for women, but is now a matter of national law. Beyond that, curves are definitely embraced. Additionally, a woman's face and hair are given equal emphasis when judging her beauty. The longer a woman's hair, the better, it's believed, but it is often true that Afghani beauty is more defined by a pretty face that a toned body.
China
A woman's relationship with her body has taken an extreme cast in modern-day China. While in the early years of the People's Republic, even owning a hairbrush was forbidden, today the country's ultra-rich indulge in plastic surgery with no shortage of regularity. In fact, there's even a contest to reward such efforts -- the Miss Plastic Surgery beauty pageant requires that contestants prove they've undergone procedures like nose jobs, breast augmentation or limb lengthening.
Where might the healthiest bodies be found? Of the countries she profiled, Savacool was quick to point out Jamaica as an example, as the culture's clear embrace of heavier women is definitely a positive step forward. Of course, thinner women there are still occasionally driven to pack on the pounds -- proving that the one thing all these different countries have in common is that, in Savacool's words, "You always want what you can't have."



















Comments:
Add a comment
Tuesday 08 December
By ~S
Also, I want to add how come there are so much conversation about curves and all that. You don't see any skinny people writing books saying how skinny is sexy. Maybe skinny people should write books on how fat people are.
Reply
Friday 11 December
By Skinny too, but not so proud as ~S
Skinny people don't HAVE to write books about fat people to make themselves feel better about themselves. All they have to do is look at photographs of pretty skinny people in magazines. Or turn on the television to see thin people wearing beautiful clothing while doing fn things, or see thin people wearing fat suits in comedy skits doing stupid and embarassing things. I don't see anything wrong about a book, magazine, television show, movie, or website that presents an alternative and supplemental view of beauty. "And" is inclusive, not exclusive, and a good one to use in a discussion like this.
Saturday 12 December
By i
weman all crazy just some look better then other
Monday 14 December
By loving life
Wow! You are really are a bigger person hating bitch. Stop calling larger people fat. Geez, you give skinner people a bad rap.
Monday 14 December
By cortni
You must be pretty young and immature to write the things you do. It is a very naive assumption that "thin is in." Do you believe everything the media tells you? Just because you see it on television does not mean it is true. This article was a discussion about various perceptions of beauty, but it seems you are too narrow-minded to realize that. Most men like a woman that has meat on her bones and curves to her body. And maybe that is what your comment is really about; you don't have curves, so you don't understand why a person would love them. The media has perpetuated an unhealty, unrealistic image of female beauty in the United States for a very long time, and just because an article wants to celebrate the female body, in all its forms, does not mean it is a personal attack on "skinny" people. I am sorry if you are insecure about your body; you wouldn't have taken it so personally if you weren't, but beauty comes in all shapes, sizes, and is subjective to each person, so don't project your insecurities onto "curvy" women; it's not our fault that we are becoming the new standard of beauty.
Women everywhere need to quit being so catty with each other and come together to show the world that beauty is truely in the eye of the beholder and not some unattainable standard.
Monday 14 December
By Summer
Excuse me, but I am just curious as to what level of education you have completed? It is obvious that you can not comprehend the information that you have read, or on the adverse, you chose to respond ONLY to the title of this article. You should focus more on you grammatical language before publicly responding to any type of article. Also, you might want to consider therapy. It seems that you harbor an aggressive attitude towards certain types of people. Is it that you have a "fat phobia?" Or is it that you are just a narrcissistic person? Just curious.
Tuesday 08 December
By jordan
you forgot the other extream in certain parts in africa, in which the heavyer a woman is the better, to the point in which woman will take dangerous steps to gain pounds such as fattening farms in which women are forced to gorge themselves,
Reply
Tuesday 08 December
By suck it
so get your skinny flat ass started on writting that book! duh!
Reply
Friday 11 December
By Raven(;
I completely agree...daaang...so true...~s if you're complainin about it then do it
Tuesday 08 December
By Erin
S, no one said skinny is gross. As a larger woman I can say I still think skinny women are beautiful. This is a book to help people realize that that skinny is not the said beauty goal in other countries. I know you just want to rant and start a flame war, because your being super aggressive but this isn't meant to be a book on hating skinny people. Maybe you need to re-read the article and THINK? Your a very cruel and awful person, I can tell by your hyper insensitive post. I hope one day you gain a crap load of weight and realize going to the gym isn't just going to make it go away.
Reply
Tuesday 08 December
By Nikki
No, I actually AGREE with ~S!
Us skinny girls (natually skinny, I may add) get SO MUCH HEAT and so many ppl on an everyday basis telling us to eat. I brush off those comments, but I have a newsflash for those people. Some women are just naturally skinny! It's in our DNA. No matter how much we eat, (and believe me, I can be a pig, and I can also eat healthy), we just can't seem to gain weight.
It's getting so ridiculous now with people pointing fingers at us! I don't go aroudn telling fat women to stop eating, because they can do whatever they want! Hell, I even think curvier women are very sexy. But don't judge me and call me unhealthy because I'm naturally thin. I take pride in that, and I know I'm beautiful in the body I have. (And yes, you can look attractive with a slim body. There are a lot of slim beautiful women out there)
Stop with the hate, please.
Reply
Tuesday 08 December
By Nikki
And I'm sorry if I offended people. I guess I'm just having a bad day...I already had two women stare at me up and down in the elevator and whisper something to each other...
I know, it may not mean anything. But there was no need to do that in front of me...
Reply
Tuesday 08 December
By Ronit
I find it interesting that the standards of beauty worldwide are changing so drastically due to the influence of American media. We are being bombarded all over with American movies, TV shows, magazine pictures, gossip etc. and I can definitely see the change in the physical appearance of women in my small town in the Andes Mountains... they are progressively getting thinner, bleaching their hair, getting plastic surgery to have more western features, trying to create a celebrity gossip culture here (and no, we don't have any celebrities so its a really forced attempt..) etc. It's kind of sad actually.. we are losing our culture and what we considered to be beauty for a photoshopped ideal that we see in magazine covers.
Reply
Wednesday 09 December
By Marsh
Ronit,
I somewhat resent the idea that America is being blamed for the proliferation of beauty standards. I won't deny that American entertainment is slathered all over the planet, but have you ever looked at Japanese fashion catalogs? A runway show in France? The US is far from having a monopoly on international beauty standards. I would agree that it's a Western standard, but East Asian height/weight standards aren't exactly "curvy" either.
I do agree though, that the celebrity gossip culture is disgusting, sad and a detriment to any society that participates in it.
Tuesday 08 December
By erin
S,
You're being dumb. If you read the article, then you'd know it isn't hating on skinny people. It's just talking about different body images around the world. All you're doing is making yourself sound illiterate.
Reply
Thursday 10 December
By Amber
There a plenty of magazines, movies, ads, photos, contests talking about how great skinny is. If your skinny and you love it, great, if your fat and you love it great, but why can't people talk about curves being as acceptable as being skinny?
Reply
Tuesday 08 December
By ebonyavenger
there is nothing wrong with being thin if you are naturally thin and not starving yourself and obsessing in order to do it. You on the other hand sound like you're just making excuses for the fact that you have the body of a pre-pubescent teenage boy and hating on the women that actually have some femininity to their body.
Reply
Tuesday 08 December
By Kat
What constitutes curves? It seems as though curves are defined differently by different sources. The media says Kim Kardashian has curves...last I could tell a size four with a big butt does not mean "curves." I am heavier, but I run on a regular basis and I try to eat healthy. I feel like I can be ok with my body except for I have the same societal reprucussions as someone who is obese and according to my BMI I am overweight not obese. I guess my gripe is that the idea of "curves" is overgeneralized and someone who is 5'4 weighing 200 lbs is the same as someone who is 5'4 and 150 lbs...it looks completely different.
Reply
Tuesday 08 December
By calico
It's not about hating thin people. It's about cultures that embrace the fuller figured.
Besides if skinny was so great for everyone, why does the US have a significant number of teens suffering from anorexia nervosa or bulemia? I lost a friend to anorexia a year ago. She wanted so bad to "be in" she starved herself and did organ damage. Why can't we all just love how we look and not be forced to look like someone else?
Reply
Wednesday 09 December
By sluggyswife
Do not call it " Your Fatness" Some of us FAT girls do not hate on skinny girls because we are jelous. sometimes i do i will admitt it but that not the only reason why. Im tired of skinny girls calling me fat. do i call you bones? no. people need to accept others and stop being petty bitches. seriously. why is it anyones business how fat or skinny someone is. as long as they are healthy and not harming themselves there should not be a problem. the people with a "fatness" problem will get over it when you stop being a bitch and calling it "fatness"
Reply