Five-foot-nine writer Zandria covers fitness and dating topics on BlogHer.com.I've always thought that if I'm interested in a guy, he should at least be my height, if not taller. It's just ... easier, you know? People don't think twice when they see a shorter woman with a taller man, but when it's the other way around it tends to create chatter. I would say that most women I've heard from on this subject share the same preference.
Some people would ask, well, what about guys who are a little shorter than usual? Is it unfair for someone like me, being 5-foot-9, to eliminate a guy from romantic consideration if he's, say, 5-foot-6? What's my hang-up?
A Dating Double Standard?
On an online dating site, if you search for people and attempt to narrow the number of results (in addition to searching for something obvious like geographic proximity), one of the many filters you can use to eliminate people from your search results is minimum height. I haven't used this search feature for a number of months, but I remember what I originally set as the minimum height: 5-foot-10, which is an inch taller than me.
I have a hypothesis, though. A guy would probably say it's unfair for a taller woman not to give him a chance (if a height difference is the only thing holding them apart from mutual attraction), but I think there are many guys who specifically look for shorter women. This doesn't hold true all the time, for sure -- there are always exceptions to any rule -- but, well, here's the thing. I'm basing this assumption on personal experience. I've dated a few guys who weren't substantially taller than me and the subject of height has always come up, usually sooner rather than later.Sometimes it'll be a comment, like the guy will say, "I've never dated a woman as tall as you before." Or when we're standing face-to-face, they'll straighten up as tall as they can, just to make sure the top of their head is above mine. (To the other tall ladies out there, have you noticed that when someone does this and you're wearing shoes, they automatically look down to see how much height your shoes are adding?)
And, really, come on -- it's not like I'm an Amazon. What must it be like for women who are 6 feet or taller?
(And yes, certainly, sometimes there are positive comments as well. Like the tall guys who say it's nice not to have to bend down so far when they come in for a kiss.)
Rethinking Roles
I've thought about what it might be like to go out with a guy who's shorter than me. I know there would be absolutely no difference in the person -- it would all come down to how comfortable I felt about having him be the one to tip his head back when it came time for a kiss. I'm not sure how I'd feel about that. And on the flip side, I think there are a lot of guys who wouldn't know how they feel about that, either.
I don't know what made me start thinking about this recently. Maybe because I've now gone out with men who were older than I said I'd go out with, and I've gone out with people who had a different overall look/body type than my "normal" preference. I guess it just makes me wonder what other things I thought were what I wanted may not really be the case.
Ladies, have you ever dated someone who was noticeably shorter than you? Guys, have you dated someone taller? If you haven't, do you think you'd be OK with that?
Related Reading:
At The Frisky, 6-foot-1 Susannah Breslin has some advice for How to Date a Tall Chick: "When other guys see a guy with a woman who's taller than he is, they assume one of two things: A) He has a lot of money, or B) He's really good in bed. Bagging a six-footer is big-game hunting. If you land one, everyone will assume you're a baller. Now, get out there, and find yourself a tall woman. I bet she's waiting for you -- with her heels on."
Double X: Julia Child's Height Was Not a Handicap: "Tall women's struggles are more subtle. You're not aware of this unless you're tall, but there's a vortex of silence around tall female public figures, and a total dearth of tall female role models. Sure, there are lots of very successful tall women out there. But you probably don't know who they are. Because they don't talk about it."
Kaye Dacus published a novel with a plus-size heroine who also happens to be 5-foot-11. She said she wanted to address the stereotype of tall men and short women, women "who are short enough the top of their head barely reaches the hero's shoulder."
BlogHer is the leading participatory news, entertainment and information network for women online. Follow us at BlogHer.com, on Twitter (@Blogher) and on Facebook.












Comments:
Add a comment
Tuesday 20 October
By Cat
I'm a tall woman. I'm six foot one. My boyfriend is about five foot nine/ten- it's a noticeable difference. He doesn't seem to mind and neither do I. In the past I've always dated men that are about my own height. The only issues I've found is that sometimes I'll think twice about wearing high heels around my boyfriend. I don't mind being so tall, but it can be just insane. I got a new pair of pumps with a five inch heel. (They were on sale!) My boyfriend loves it, especially in private- He becomes boob-height!
Reply
Tuesday 20 October
By Krystal
My boyfriend is shorter than me, but it doesnt bother either of us. It used to bother me when I was younger cause i'm 5'10" and well thats kinda tall for a girl, but now i'm fine with it and i dont think it should matter as long as your happy with who your with nothing else in the world should matter if you love the person and they make you happy.
Reply
Tuesday 20 October
By Julie
Cat,
it's interesting you say that, here's my case for comparison:
My boyfriend is around 5'7"-8", and I'm 5'4"-5". Obviously, he is taller, but just a bit--he's definitely shorter than other guys I've dated, and with heels on, I sometimes creep up to his height. I normally love much taller guys, for that "manly" "protective" element (yes, I am a stereotypical female). My boyfriend actually strongly dislikes when I wear heels, and I often wear flats just so we mantain a respectable height ratio. Please don't get mad when I say this, as it only applies to my personal feelings: I actually have less respect for my boyfriend, and I feel he is less of a man, when I'm towering over him in my heels. It's like he's my child. But to each his own...
Reply
Tuesday 20 October
By Cat
Julie,
I understand the protective, manly appeal. I think every girl wants a bit of that. I think my boyfriend is just really comfortable with our height differences. He still insists on walking on the road side of the side walk, opens doors for me, is the big spoon, and cuddles me close during scary movies. He may be shorter than me, but I definitely see him as a man, even when I'm wearing sky-high heels have have to bend down a bit to kiss him. We're just comfortable with ourselves and each other. I wouldn't have it any other way.
Wednesday 21 October
By Stacie
I'm 6'2 and I hardly ever date guys taller than me. Why? Because they are rare. The average male is 5'10. The odds are against me. I figure that my height is a good thing. It gets rid of the insecure asshats who refuse to date a woman taller than them and leaves the guys who would love to date a lovely amazon. Sure, I don't wear heels, but that's because I learned my lesson at prom when I walked in the room measuring at 6'6. Would it be intriguing to date a man taller than me? Absolutely, but I'm not holding my breath.
Reply
Wednesday 21 October
By dannyfrom504
I'm 5'4". i've dated taller and shorter women; it honestly doesn't matter to me. I've only had one gf who appeared bothered by my height and I broke it off with her. My last gf was 5'9" and while there were issues in that relationship, our height differences weren't one of them. I used to joke that the great thing about being with her was that fact that we'd have normal sized kids.
If it's right, it's right. Disregarding a man based on his height would be like a man dismissing a woman because she were "a bit overweight" or her bewbs are too small. But like someone else posted, to each his/her own.
Reply
Wednesday 21 October
By Julie
Danny, guys do diss women because they are "a bit overweight". I remember one guy telling me he wouldn't date anyone over 120 pounds, assuming they are 5'4" (I was 124...oh well). It's completely about attraction, if both people like each, who cares? But, other people may make your relationship harder--I was dating a guy who was obese, but the nicest guy, and best boyfriend I ever had (plus, he was probably in better shape than me since he worked out and ate healthier than I did), but all my friends and family members told me to break up with him. Even though he was a great boyfriend, they just didn't think it was right--my mom referenced how my children would probably be obese. It does put strain on a relationship when everyone is so against it. Height can be the same thing for people. For me personally, it's a big deal. Like a nice car or some other status symbol may be for some women. If I had to pick (all else being equal) between a really gorgeous guy who is 5'7" (my boyfriend) or a passable looking guy who is 6'3", I'd definitely pick the taller one (if height and looks were the only distinguishing factors).
Wednesday 21 October
By Trish
3 years ago...I met a guy and he seemed nice and sweet...we met online. We talked for a while and then we met in person....and boy was I knocked out when I seen how tall he was! He was my height 5'2! So I was kinda reluctant to give him a chance being he was well ....short. All my friends conveinced me and I gave in. Ok...as the months of the relationship progressed...it turns out that he had the NAPOLEON complex BIGTIME! He was always defensive about things...and always tried to make himself so tough when it came to things. One day someone tried to pick a fight with him..and boy he ran! LOL! What a chicken s***! But to add he also cheated on me and tried to get a away with it....plus a heavy gambler to always prove himself as a winner! When it came down to the breakup up of course he berated me to no end, telling me I would only find someone to date that is in the "Loser Category"...so I back handed him with the comment and you could only find someone in the "Munchkin Club" follow the Yellowbrick Road! What a ass****! So some short people are ok....but most of the guys I encountered had the NAPOLEON COMPLEX! Stick to anything over 5'8!
Reply
Wednesday 21 October
By Julie
The stereotype is sometimes true, some of short people try to overcompensate for their height.
Wednesday 21 October
By Stangchick1983
I have always had a thing for shorter men. I am 5'5 so shorter or just a few inches taller then me; I love. Really tall men do nothing for me.
Reply
Wednesday 21 October
By Julie
Any particular thing you like about them? As in, do you know what you find so attractive?
Friday 23 October
By dannyfrom504
julie-
my point was, it's wrong to diss a girl for the reasons i mentioned. and i totally realize that a man's height can be a real put-off for some women (know all too well actually lulz), to me it's superficial non-sense. your family/friends were wrong to give you grief and i'd be willing to bet they were less put-off about his weight and more jealous that you were really happy. at any rate all that should have mattered was your own happiness and being taken cared for by your bf. my gf is 5'2" and doesn't like to wear heels that make her taller then me, but i make sure she does anyway. looks like i'm back to having pygmies for children again. hahahaha.
Reply
Thursday 22 October
By sydra
I know this is kinda the other way around, but what about when a super tall guy dates a super duper short girl. Thoughts?
Reply
Friday 23 October
By lovely
Shorties shouldn't hog the tall men. Its rude and unnecessary. J/k... But being 6'2 it still pisses me off when I see it
Friday 23 October
By Julie
I know a couple who has a 16 inch height difference. The girl is super short and very skinny (but still kinda curvy for 90 pounds), and the guy is very tall and muscular. I think he's 6'4" and she's a bit less than 5 feet. They are ADORABLE together, and I can't see anything wrong with it. Especially because the power dynamics seem to be inversely proportional to their height.
Monday 26 October
By Kate J
I'm 5'4". I do not think it is too much to ask for a man taller than myself! That isn't a very difficult requirement to meet with my height; my boyfriend is 6'4" so I get my wish!!
I have dated someone that was shorter than myself, and I'll never do that again. It was mostly because he was a ridiculous, psychotic, frighteningly religious, spiteful, double-standard-embracing douchelick, and I am SO GLAD I got back with my ex and realized that he was an infinitely better person and I was a FOOL to leave him. Furthermore, he has a humongous penis...especially in comparison. Oh, and did I mention he LOVES me? "Ex" is not always a bad word.
Also, just a passing comment: I think a lot of women who say "Size doesn't matter" are in love with a man with a below-average penis length. Nothing quite like settling ^_^
I won't go below 5'10". Never again.
Reply
Monday 26 October
By Kate J
Actually he was a few inches TALLER than me, like 5'8"; I mistyped. That's still to fkcing short though. I know what I want and I'm not going to pretend just to have someone's attention.
Monday 09 November
By ashley
met this guy just a few days ago and now i found out he likes me... i havent dated anyone fr the last year or so bc all of the guys seem to be shorter then me .. by the way im 5'11 .. he guy that i meet is about 5'9.. i really dont know what to do.. i wouldnt mind dating him.. it just that everyone is always makeinf fun of my height and feel it is gong to be even worst if we do date.. what do you all think?? should i date him or not??
Reply
Saturday 14 November
By Kaitlynn
I think you should date him. There is nothing wrong with a short guy. My current bf of 9 months is shorter than me.I'm 5'9" so i dont really find any guys that are taller than me.
Monday 16 November
By Shannon
I am currently dating a guy that is 5'6 and I am 5'7. I have to admit I dislike wearing heels that are more than 2 inches in height. He would absolutely love for me to wear 3-4 inch heels out on a date. Maybe one day. I have learned not to judge people by their height or ethnicity. By the way he also Asian. We definitely get a lot of looks. My nickname is Barbie and he is my Asian Ken! LOL