Congress is back in session this week, and that means that the debate over health-care reform will only get uglier. From here on out, we'll be hearing a steady drumbeat from right-wing pundits and their mainstream media enablers: abortion abortion abortion. Second only to lies about "death panels," abortion scare tactics are a favorite of universal-health-care opponents. But if you, like a majority of Americans, find abortion icky, then you should be an eager supporter of universal health care for two major reasons.
1. Taxpayers Won't Be Paying for Abortions
Despite what conservative activists claim, taxpayer money will not fund abortions. The Hyde Amendment specifically forbids the use of federal money to pay for elective abortion, and there's no reason to think health-care reform will change that.
Some conservatives argue that under health-care reform, insurance companies that already cover abortion will continue to do so, even though they're in a federal system. And under the proposed public option, it would be legal to cover abortion because the public option will be paid for -- like all insurance companies are -- by members.
Click here for more.
None of this means that abortion will be paid for with tax dollars. If you really don't want to pay for abortion with your insurance premiums, you can choose one of the insurance companies that don't cover it. But I'll bet that most people gnashing their teeth over this don't even know whether their own insurance company covers abortion.
Universal Health Coverage Will Lower the Abortion Rate
If you're anti-abortion, then you want fewer of them, right? Universal health coverage would most likely lower the abortion rate. Western European nations (and Canada) that conservatives claim have "socialized medicine" also have a much lower abortion rate than the U.S. America has 21.3 abortions per 1,000 people. Contrast that with England (15.6 per 1,000), Canada (16.4 per 1,000), Germany (7.6 per 1,000) and Holland (6.5 per 1,000). What do they have that we don't? Universal health care.
It makes sense if you think about it. The number one cause of abortion is unintended pregnancy. The best way to prevent unintended pregnancy is contraception. And the most reliable forms of contraception -- IUDs, sterilization and hormonal contraception -- require putting you in front of a doctor. Universal health care makes that much easier, which in turn reduces the unwanted pregnancy rate.
It isn't just contraception, of course. Many women who get pregnant by accident consider keeping the baby, but for those who don't have health insurance, that's a (dangerous) pipe dream. Universal health care could reduce the abortion rate coming and going.
Anti-Abortion but Pro-Sex?
Of course, if what you object to isn't abortion so much as sex, mostly likely the premarital kind, then I suppose these arguments mean nothing to you. And that's why the organized anti-choice movement opposes universal health care.
Most to all anti-abortion organizations object to contraception use, sex education and other methods to reduce the abortion rate, because they believe these things make it easier to have sex without consequences. Given a choice between punishing sex and reducing the number of abortions, the anti-choice movement will choose the former every time.
But you don't have to. If you genuinely have no problem with sex, but don't like abortion, then there's only one choice for you: Support universal health care. Because without it, we're stuck with a high abortion rate.
Amanda Marcotte is the author of "It's a Jungle Out There" and writes about politics daily at Pandagon.net.












Comments:
Add a comment
Monday 02 November
By Felicia 2
Mr. Knapp,
With all due respect, if Universal Heath care takes effect you will be an object tossed around by the political system. They cannot manage medicare now yet they plan to run health care in a similar manner. The elderly will get sidelined and if you think it is just like abortion to leave poor people without medical care how about the elderly? How about the kids that would be forced to be aborted because the doctor thinks that they will be deformed in some way and cost the government lots of money. The government wastes tons of money now why do you think it will be any different if they run health care?
Reply
Thursday 04 March
By jerry Mcguire
i, "LIKE THE MAJORITY OF AMERICANS"
WHO HARDLY CALL THE UNJUST TAKING
OF AN INNOCENT HUMAN life "ICKY"
AS YOU SO FALSELY AND IGNORANTLY
SEEMED TO IMPLY-
[THEY LIKE MYSELF]
MOST LIKELY "ALSO" STOPPED USING
THE TIME AND ENERGY THAT WOULD BE
WASTED FROM READING OR PAYING
ANY more ATTENTION TO AN ARTICLE THAT
WAS AUTHORED BY SOMEONE AS PITIFULLY
AND SADLY "ANTI"-LIFE" AS YOU CERTAINLY have let yourself
become.
FOR THE SPECIFIC REASON OF HELPING YOU TO REALIZE HOW THE MISTAKE OF ALLOWING ONESELF TO BECOME 'INFLUENCED' OR 'HARDENED
BY THE CUNNING AND SCHREWED "GREAT SPEECH GIVERS" THAT FIND THEIR WAY INTO SOCIETY
[I WONT MENTION ANY NAMES ;)]
CAN "BLIND" OR "DIVERT" ONESELF FROM
WHAT IS TRULY DECENT OR MORAL
or SHOULD I SAY at the risk of offending anyone
WHAT IS ALL OF OUR GOAL
WHETHER WE WANT TO ADMIT IT OR NOT
AND THAT OF COURSE IS
'WHAT IS THE MOST IMPORTANT THING
FOR ALL OF US' WHICH TRULY IS
THAT WE MUST PLEASE 'HIM' WHO
IS THE MOST IMPORTANT BEING IN 'HIS'
UNIVERSE
THAT IS PROBABLY, the only reason that i will offer any "comment"
[[well other than the fact that you could be an amazing
journalist if you didnt let the damage that goes with
our mistakes of what our "culture of death" comes with
to unintentionaly limit what our capacities truly are when
we do God's will and not ours or worse smeone else's
that is not on His side [due to the same "human" bad choices related God's "giving" us what is not to be confused with today's "FARCE" of "choice"
[thereby i dont expect your "allowing"
such "defense for what is "EVERYONE'S RITE TO LIFE"
to merit it's being published herein among all those
other "creations of Our Lord" who are somehow
"More" entitled to the "GIFT" given to you and "all" of
"our" brothers and sisters"...including the unborn
boy and girl babies that you delight in refering to by
the names that we are all given simply to "describe
"when" we are all in that "particular" "stage"
of [our] "HUMAN" "LIFE"....
**no more or less than say "senior citizens"
are equaly entitled to Life and to "LIVE"
and to NOT be Killed.
-and please spare me and yourself
the comparason of the taking of an innocent older human life
to their "dying"-or in keeping with the
retarded pro-death mentality of
today's anti life politicians-
"rite to die"...omg...
also such labels are definitely not meant to "imply" or "disqualify"
us or any other of our innocent brothers and sisters
in the womb from being exactly that which we all
indeed are.;
"EQUAL LIVING HUMAN LIFE QUALY ENTITLED
TO THE RITE TO LIFE.
Nothing personal against yourself-
however you even do yourself and your success as a
journalists a great diservice by your allowing yourself to
have become so anti-life-pro-death perhaps without even realizing
how the weakness of our being human subjects us to "fail"
or mistakenly be decieved by the greater intellects of those
promoting evil..
Reply
Thursday 04 March
By jerry Mcguire
i, "LIKE THE MAJORITY OF AMERICANS"
WHO HARDLY CALL THE UNJUST TAKING
OF AN INNOCENT HUMAN life "ICKY"
AS YOU SO FALSELY AND IGNORANTLY
SEEMED TO IMPLY-
[THEY LIKE MYSELF]
MOST LIKELY "ALSO" STOPPED USING
THE TIME AND ENERGY THAT WOULD BE
WASTED FROM READING OR PAYING
ANY more ATTENTION TO AN ARTICLE THAT
WAS AUTHORED BY SOMEONE AS PITIFULLY
AND SADLY "ANTI"-LIFE" AS YOU CERTAINLY have let yourself
become.
FOR THE SPECIFIC REASON OF HELPING YOU TO REALIZE HOW THE MISTAKE OF ALLOWING ONESELF TO BECOME 'INFLUENCED' OR 'HARDENED
BY THE CUNNING AND SCHREWED "GREAT SPEECH GIVERS" THAT FIND THEIR WAY INTO SOCIETY
[I WONT MENTION ANY NAMES ;)]
CAN "BLIND" OR "DIVERT" ONESELF FROM
WHAT IS TRULY DECENT OR MORAL
or SHOULD I SAY at the risk of offending anyone
WHAT IS ALL OF OUR GOAL
WHETHER WE WANT TO ADMIT IT OR NOT
AND THAT OF COURSE IS
'WHAT IS THE MOST IMPORTANT THING
FOR ALL OF US' WHICH TRULY IS
THAT WE MUST PLEASE 'HIM' WHO
IS THE MOST IMPORTANT BEING IN 'HIS'
UNIVERSE
THAT IS PROBABLY, the only reason that i will offer any "comment"
[[well other than the fact that you could be an amazing
journalist if you didnt let the damage that goes with
our mistakes of what our "culture of death" comes with
to unintentionaly limit what our capacities truly are when
we do God's will and not ours or worse smeone else's
that is not on His side [due to the same "human" bad choices related God's "giving" us what is not to be confused with today's "FARCE" of "choice"
[thereby i dont expect your "allowing"
such "defense for what is "EVERYONE'S RITE TO LIFE"
to merit it's being published herein among all those
other "creations of Our Lord" who are somehow
"More" entitled to the "GIFT" given to you and "all" of
"our" brothers and sisters"...including the unborn
boy and girl babies that you delight in refering to by
the names that we are all given simply to "describe
"when" we are all in that "particular" "stage"
of [our] "HUMAN" "LIFE"....
**no more or less than say "senior citizens"
are equaly entitled to Life and to "LIVE"
and to NOT be Killed.
-and please spare me and yourself
the comparason of the taking of an innocent older human life
to their "dying"-or in keeping with the
retarded pro-death mentality of
today's anti life politicians-
"rite to die"...omg...
also such labels are definitely not meant to "imply" or "disqualify"
us or any other of our innocent brothers and sisters
in the womb from being exactly that which we all
indeed are.;
"EQUAL LIVING HUMAN LIFE QUALY ENTITLED
TO THE RITE TO LIFE.
Nothing personal against yourself-
however you even do yourself and your success as a
journalists a great diservice by your allowing yourself to
have become so anti-life-pro-death perhaps without even realizing
how the weakness of our being human subjects us to "fail"
or mistakenly be decieved by the greater intellects of those
promoting evil..
Reply
Friday 05 March
By jERRY mCGUIRE
i, "LIKE THE MAJORITY OF AMERICANS"
WHO HARDLY CALL THE UNJUST TAKING
OF AN INNOCENT HUMAN life "ICKY"
AS YOU SO FALSELY AND IGNORANTLY
SEEMED TO IMPLY-
[THEY LIKE MYSELF]
MOST LIKELY "ALSO" STOPPED USING
THE TIME AND ENERGY THAT WOULD BE
WASTED FROM READING OR PAYING
ANY more ATTENTION TO AN ARTICLE THAT
WAS AUTHORED BY SOMEONE AS PITIFULLY
AND SADLY "ANTI"-LIFE" AS YOU CERTAINLY have let yourself
become.
FOR THE SPECIFIC REASON OF HELPING YOU TO REALIZE HOW THE MISTAKE OF ALLOWING ONESELF TO BECOME 'INFLUENCED' OR 'HARDENED
BY THE CUNNING AND SCHREWED "GREAT SPEECH GIVERS" THAT FIND THEIR WAY INTO SOCIETY
[I WONT MENTION ANY NAMES ;)]
CAN "BLIND" OR "DIVERT" ONESELF FROM
WHAT IS TRULY DECENT OR MORAL
or SHOULD I SAY at the risk of offending anyone
WHAT IS ALL OF OUR GOAL
WHETHER WE WANT TO ADMIT IT OR NOT
AND THAT OF COURSE IS
'WHAT IS THE MOST IMPORTANT THING
FOR ALL OF US' WHICH TRULY IS
THAT WE MUST PLEASE 'HIM' WHO
IS THE MOST IMPORTANT BEING IN 'HIS'
UNIVERSE
THAT IS PROBABLY, the only reason that i will offer any "comment"
[[well other than the fact that you could be an amazing
journalist if you didnt let the damage that goes with
our mistakes of what our "culture of death" comes with
to unintentionaly limit what our capacities truly are when
we do God's will and not ours or worse smeone else's
that is not on His side [due to the same "human" bad choices related God's "giving" us what is not to be confused with today's "FARCE" of "choice"
[thereby i dont expect your "allowing"
such "defense for what is "EVERYONE'S RITE TO LIFE"
to merit it's being published herein among all those
other "creations of Our Lord" who are somehow
"More" entitled to the "GIFT" given to you and "all" of
"our" brothers and sisters"...including the unborn
boy and girl babies that you delight in refering to by
the names that we are all given simply to "describe
"when" we are all in that "particular" "stage"
of [our] "HUMAN" "LIFE"....
**no more or less than say "senior citizens"
are equaly entitled to Life and to "LIVE"
and to NOT be Killed.
-and please spare me and yourself
the comparason of the taking of an innocent older human life
to their "dying"-or in keeping with the
retarded pro-death mentality of
today's anti life politicians-
"rite to die"...omg...
also such labels are definitely not meant to "imply" or "disqualify"
us or any other of our innocent brothers and sisters
in the womb from being exactly that which we all
indeed are.;
"EQUAL LIVING HUMAN LIFE QUALY ENTITLED
TO THE RITE TO LIFE.
Nothing personal against yourself-
however you even do yourself and your success as a
journalists a great diservice by your allowing yourself to
have become so anti-life-pro-death perhaps without even realizing
how the weakness of our being human subjects us to "fail"
or mistakenly be decieved by the greater intellects of those
promoting evil..
Judging by your incredible inacuracies,falsehoods and biased anti life-pro death mentality and obsession to degrade the honorable intentions of what every anti abortion individual knows is what is the right thing to do-
IT ISNT ANY WONDER THAT A PERSON AS SINISTER
AND SCHREWED AS HISTORY DEMONSTRATES THAT
THE FOUNDER OF PLANNED PARENTHOOD WHO WAS
AN AVOWED COMMUNIST,RACISTS AND A PERSON WHO
PROMOTED THE EXTERMINATION OF THE AFRICAN AMERICAN RACE IN AMERICA-
[WHICH AS HISTORY ALSO SUBSTANTIATES,
MARGARET SANGER DID IN FACT START THE
ORGANIZATION "INNOCENTLY" KNOWN AS PLANNED PARENTHOOD.
AND WHO IS NO MORE AMERICAN,PRO WOMAN OR EVEN A HALF BAKED
EXCUSE FOR "FUNNELING" THE MILLIONS AND MILLIONS OF TAXPAYER DOLLARS WITH THE CONVENIENT AID OF MR. OBAMA'S OBSESSION WITH "DEATH"-
IT IS NO WONDER THAT SOMEONE LIKE YOURSELF WOULD USE YOUR TRADE TO CONTRIBUTE TO AMERICA'S DESTRUCTION NOW BEING NURTURED BY OUR "CULTURE OF DEATH"...
Reply
Friday 05 March
By jERRY mCGUIRE
i, "LIKE THE MAJORITY OF AMERICANS"
WHO HARDLY CALL THE UNJUST TAKING
OF AN INNOCENT HUMAN life "ICKY"
AS YOU SO FALSELY AND IGNORANTLY
SEEMED TO IMPLY-
[THEY LIKE MYSELF]
MOST LIKELY "ALSO" STOPPED USING
THE TIME AND ENERGY THAT WOULD BE
WASTED FROM READING OR PAYING
ANY more ATTENTION TO AN ARTICLE THAT
WAS AUTHORED BY SOMEONE AS PITIFULLY
AND SADLY "ANTI"-LIFE" AS YOU CERTAINLY have let yourself
become.
FOR THE SPECIFIC REASON OF HELPING YOU TO REALIZE HOW THE MISTAKE OF ALLOWING ONESELF TO BECOME 'INFLUENCED' OR 'HARDENED
BY THE CUNNING AND SCHREWED "GREAT SPEECH GIVERS" THAT FIND THEIR WAY INTO SOCIETY
[I WONT MENTION ANY NAMES ;)]
CAN "BLIND" OR "DIVERT" ONESELF FROM
WHAT IS TRULY DECENT OR MORAL
or SHOULD I SAY at the risk of offending anyone
WHAT IS ALL OF OUR GOAL
WHETHER WE WANT TO ADMIT IT OR NOT
AND THAT OF COURSE IS
'WHAT IS THE MOST IMPORTANT THING
FOR ALL OF US' WHICH TRULY IS
THAT WE MUST PLEASE 'HIM' WHO
IS THE MOST IMPORTANT BEING IN 'HIS'
UNIVERSE
THAT IS PROBABLY, the only reason that i will offer any "comment"
[[well other than the fact that you could be an amazing
journalist if you didnt let the damage that goes with
our mistakes of what our "culture of death" comes with
to unintentionaly limit what our capacities truly are when
we do God's will and not ours or worse smeone else's
that is not on His side [due to the same "human" bad choices related God's "giving" us what is not to be confused with today's "FARCE" of "choice"
[thereby i dont expect your "allowing"
such "defense for what is "EVERYONE'S RITE TO LIFE"
to merit it's being published herein among all those
other "creations of Our Lord" who are somehow
"More" entitled to the "GIFT" given to you and "all" of
"our" brothers and sisters"...including the unborn
boy and girl babies that you delight in refering to by
the names that we are all given simply to "describe
"when" we are all in that "particular" "stage"
of [our] "HUMAN" "LIFE"....
**no more or less than say "senior citizens"
are equaly entitled to Life and to "LIVE"
and to NOT be Killed.
-and please spare me and yourself
the comparason of the taking of an innocent older human life
to their "dying"-or in keeping with the
retarded pro-death mentality of
today's anti life politicians-
"rite to die"...omg...
also such labels are definitely not meant to "imply" or "disqualify"
us or any other of our innocent brothers and sisters
in the womb from being exactly that which we all
indeed are.;
"EQUAL LIVING HUMAN LIFE QUALY ENTITLED
TO THE RITE TO LIFE.
Nothing personal against yourself-
however you even do yourself and your success as a
journalists a great diservice by your allowing yourself to
have become so anti-life-pro-death perhaps without even realizing
how the weakness of our being human subjects us to "fail"
or mistakenly be decieved by the greater intellects of those
promoting evil..
Judging by your incredible inacuracies,falsehoods and biased anti life-pro death mentality and obsession to degrade the honorable intentions of what every anti abortion individual knows is what is the right thing to do-
IT ISNT ANY WONDER THAT A PERSON AS SINISTER
AND SCHREWED AS HISTORY DEMONSTRATES THAT
THE FOUNDER OF PLANNED PARENTHOOD WHO WAS
AN AVOWED COMMUNIST,RACISTS AND A PERSON WHO
PROMOTED THE EXTERMINATION OF THE AFRICAN AMERICAN RACE IN AMERICA-
[WHICH AS HISTORY ALSO SUBSTANTIATES,
MARGARET SANGER DID IN FACT START THE
ORGANIZATION "INNOCENTLY" KNOWN AS PLANNED PARENTHOOD.
AND WHO IS NO MORE AMERICAN,PRO WOMAN OR EVEN A HALF BAKED
EXCUSE FOR "FUNNELING" THE MILLIONS AND MILLIONS OF TAXPAYER DOLLARS WITH THE CONVENIENT AID OF MR. OBAMA'S OBSESSION WITH "DEATH"-
IT IS NO WONDER THAT SOMEONE LIKE YOURSELF WOULD USE YOUR TRADE TO CONTRIBUTE TO AMERICA'S DESTRUCTION NOW BEING NURTURED BY OUR "CULTURE OF DEATH"...
Reply
Monday 19 April
By Sandy
Amanda, you should look at the abortion statistics in the UK, a country where Universal Healthcare has been in place for quite some time. They're rising and have been for over a generation, now.
Please don't tell me that 'free' healthcare is going to solve the US's horrifying abortion rate. That's just stupid wishful thinking.
Reply
Friday 01 October
By Dorishelena15
--I learned about abortion in school (last yr in 9th grade) so that makes meh in 10th grade now. well some people said abortion is right if you get raped...we had to work in our groups all of them said abortion was right because if u got raped or something ..i disagree ...i think abortion is wrong because its murder..you have a livin bein in u and u get an abortion which is killin the baby..i think abortion should be ban and you shouldnt get it because women now a days are gettin abortions from gettin raped or just havin sex and they find out they are pregent now come on ..if u get raped u should still have a adoption dont kill the child let it have a life..ur ruin its chances by havin one..for the one that just have sex and find they are pregent that is what BIRTH CONTROL && CONDOMS are .....If you have sex there are chances you could get pregent so if you wanna have sex be warned u might be a parent..think before u do anything these days
Reply