Mommyblogger extraordinaire Rita Arens explores the unique situation of transgender children -- and their parents -- for BlogHer. At BlogHer09 Conference, I sat down to lunch with friends in the basement of the Sheraton. A little later we were joined by a slim woman with short hair. She introduced herself, and we started talking about eco-stuff, as she is an eco blogger.
Then I sort of faded out of the conversation and snapped back in when she mentioned she is the parent of a transgendered child. A very young transgender child.
I had to pause and shake off my initial thought, which I admit was, But what if it's just a phase? I might have said it. I hope I didn't. I'm sure Jen Khatchatrian hears that all the time. And before you click away from this post because it's off my normal beat, pull up a chair at this lunch table and join me to listen.
Changing My Mind About Changing Gender

I'd love to tell you that I'm the world's most open-minded person -- that I came out that way. But I didn't. I get messages every day from the media, from my life experiences, from friends, neighbors and family. I grew up thinking boys were boys and girls were girls and everyone was either Lutheran or going Straight To Hell.
Click here to keep reading.
Nobody tried to brainwash me -- it was just the environment I grew up in. As I've traveled through my life, I've tried to stop and listen before making assumptions. I've tried and continue to try to let new facts filter in and shape my perceptions.
I went into the conversation thinking it was wrong to let a young child make the decision to change his or her gender. I came out of lunch thinking, I have to help this woman find friends for her daughter. Her daughter who has a penis.
And I also thought, "This has to be the toughest parenting decision a person could have to make."
What changed my mind? Listening to Jen's story. She talked of her daughter's pain and isolation, how she asked, "Am I the only one?"
How Far Would You Go to Help Your Kid?Can you imagine how you would feel if your child asked you if he or she was the only person in the world with such a primal problem?
I thought of my own daughter and how I would do anything to help her grow up as secure and happy as possible. And I realized that if I were in Jen's place, I would be there at the therapist every week, just like she is. I would be searching the world for other boys who believed they were girls. I would be traveling to transgender conferences wearing a T-shirt saying, "I'm from Chicago," just like Jen is.
We can't judge until we've walked in her shoes. Jen's certainly not crazy, and I doubt her kid is, either. We know many aspects of humanity operate on a spectrum, and gender is just another component of humanity.
"It's Like You're Trapped"
WPTZ in Omaha covered a transgendered-boy-to-girl story in May. The child said: "It's kind of like you're trapped somewhere and you can't get out," said the boy, whose name and face are not being made public to protect the family from potential harm.
"20/20" covered the story of Jazz, a 5-year-old girl who was born as a boy, in April 2007. While Jazz's parents now fully accept their son as their daughter, the transition has not been without considerable doubt and stress. Many parents grieve for the child that never was.
"I mourn the loss of the idea of my son," Renee said. "I see pictures and the video, and that child's gone. But there's a wonderful person now that's with us."
Jazz, Katie (in Omaha) and Jen's daughter are lucky to have parents who want to help them. According to a 2007 San Francisco State University Chavez Center Institute study, GLBT and questioning kids who come from an unsupportive family are nine times more likely to commit suicide than other kids.
Unique Challenges for Unique Children
Unsupportive parents aren't the only obstacle transgender kids face.
Michael Rowe wrote a while ago on the Huffington Post about KRXQ's shock jocks' vicious attacks on transgender children, who are, after all, children, first and foremost. Trusting, innocent and vulnerable, they ought to be beyond the reach of the violent, hate-mongering adult rhetoric that is taken for granted on American talk radio.
One needs no particular sympathy for transgender people to understand the prodigious boundary transgression of promoting contempt and disgust towards children -- anyone's children -- on a radio show.
How You Can Help
You may know a transgender child without realizing you do. How to help instead of hurt? TransYouth Family Allies offers these suggestions:
* Treat these children as you would any other child.
* Use the child's preferred name and pronouns.
* Avoid gender stereotyping and speak out against it in your interaction with others.
* Intervene when you witness bullying or intolerance.
* Help create gender-neutral spaces on school campuses.
* Help create comprehensive anti-bullying programs that include gender identity and expression in workplaces and schools.
* Contact your local lawmakers and request legislation to protect gender identity and expression in your state, city or township.
* Volunteer your time and talents or donate your funds to help educate others on gender identity and gender expression.
Jen is still looking for a girl-with-boy-plumbing to be friends with her daughter, so she can prove she is not the only one. Can you help her find such a child?
More Resources:
* TransYouth Family Allies
* "The Transgender Child: A Handbook for Families and Professionals"
BlogHer is the leading participatory news, entertainment and information network for women online. Follow us at BlogHer.com, on Twitter (@Blogher) and on Facebook.












Comments:
Add a comment
Wednesday 16 September
By Lori Beth
For 60 years I have lived with the feeling that I was in the wrong body. In the past two years, three independent mental health professionasl have confirmed that I do suffer from gender dysphoria. I have been married for 38 years and have two grown daughters. You can imagine the pain I am experiencing (physical, mental and emotional) trying to live in my true gender (female) without ridicule and abandonment by my family. I have suffered from so much depression I've tried to kill myself once and had many a suicidal thought. My PCP told me to get my gender identity straightened out and suggested I become a chemical woman. He saw no other way for my depression and pain to abate. I struggle everyday wondering if hormones and dressing at home will be enough. I wish I could have told my parents how I felt when I was a lot younger. But they wouldn't have understood. My mother was abusive to begin with, and my father abandoned me emotionally when I was in grade school. I hung with the girls all through school. Transgender is not a whim; it is a fact for those of us who suffer from it. I often ask "How could God have screwed up?" We are not freaks, although most people think we are. We are victims of nature. Have pity on the youngsters and their parents; don't criticize them or abandon them in their hour of need.
Reply
Wednesday 16 September
By james
Better to end up a statistical suicide as opposed to an eternity in hell. If you are saved you dont go to hell for suicide, but a feminine man will NOT enter the gates of Heaven Said God.
Reply
Monday 21 September
By Leon
I'm curious about this. Did God define what male and female were? Or is it that those of us, who think that we're actually smart enough to fully understand God's thoughts/intentions, assumed that all males will have male genitalia and all females will have female genitalia? If a man who was born with a conventional female genitalia (vagina and uterus) is forced to act feminine and live as a woman just for having a vagina doesn't that mean that when he is forced to be a feminine man all his life even though he doesn't want to be?
Transgender people always existed in all societies. They exist in the natural world as well in other species. In some societies it is perfectly acceptable to take on any gender role that you need in order to get things done. Lack of acceptance is what some societies have and some doesn't. Lack of acceptance is what is unnatural.
The body of a person can deviate from the most common state in various ways. A child can be born without limbs or a functioning visual system. It doesn't make them any less of a person. If they technology exists to give them artificial limbs or eyesight then shouldn't it be given to them instead of saying "if you were meant to be able to see, God would have created you with eyes that work"?
A fetus always starts out as having no specified genitalia. Sometime during the growth process, the specific sex hormones are released to the system to cause the development of the specific genitalia as well as the receptors for the sex specific hormones. If something goes wrong during this process, the child may end up having the brain/instincts for a specific gender while the typical body of the other gender.
In some cases the genitalia may not even develop fully because of whatever went wrong in the process. Its quite obvious when it doesn't develop fully, but its not so obvious when its fully developed for the opposite sex than the one they were supposed to have. In that case, the brain feels that it needs something and its waiting forever for the body to provide it. Its clear that to fix this you either have to change the brain or change the body. Until there's a way to change the brain, the only option available is to change the body.
A child may be going through a phase or they may actually be telling you what their brain is telling them. One good way to approach it is to see what makes the child happy and what allows the child's brain to get what it needs. The child may not be old enough to make an irreversible decision, but what makes them happy is a good indication of what may be needed in the future. It may help to keep the "changes" as irreversible as possible until its not an option anymore.
Monday 21 September
By Marlene
How in the hell do *you* know, James? Are *you* god?
Tuesday 22 September
By shaking my head
The Bible also says He who is without sin cast the first stone and Im pretty sure you're not without sin because the only perfect person to walk this Earth was Jesus so who are you to judge? And who are you to feel that you know what God is thinking? God is not only an all knowing God but he is also a forgiving, compassionate, and accepting God
Saturday 19 September
By Jasmine
If people had been more accepting of me as a child I would not have spent my teen years trying to kill myself. I have spent the rest of my life in hiding. I have no friends because everyone feels "stigma": I spend my time "pretending" to be the role that "God gave me". I would go to church (Episcopal) every week if only I was accepted by my faith. I am now 35 and too old to transition into a female. For the rest of you "Christians" ( like my own father), it is because of your intolerance that I fear for my life on a daily basis (if anyone finds out) and now have to keep spending the rest of my life alone, lonely, and sad (I have nothing to look forward to and when I die I go to hell) . I am sure Jesus is proud of what you have done today by re-affirming old testament Genesis not "Love they neighbor".
Reply
Monday 21 September
By ella wallace
Congratulations? I think this is a lovely story and ill pray all goes well !!! It is very hard too march too a different drummer !! I knew from an early age that i was not a male ..it has caused me great sadness and confusion thru life ..there is a light at end of tunnel now soo goo For it ...with all your heart and soul its true !!!
Reply
Thursday 24 September
By Adrian R.
Like Jai, I am also a female to male transgendered individual, but I identify as a gay man. Aside from one or two instances in my childhood I considered my longings to be a boy were simply an extreme form of being a tomboy. Finally, when I was 16 i stumbled across a website for transgendered individuals......and spent the next hour sobbing my heart out. I knew what I was at last! For those of you who are Christian, as I am, remember that trangendered people are not mistakes.....we are God's way of reminding the world to open their eyes. Also, I have a unique trait: I am mildly intersexed.
While circumstances prevent me from ever undergoing a full transition...I honestly don't let it get to me. I plan to make use of what I've been given, finish college, marry an open-minded man....yes, MARRY....and raise a family.
God's blessings be upon my fellow transgendered brothers & sisters: may you find suport, love and peace.
Cheers,
Adrian
Reply
Monday 05 April
By jackie holland
Hi, My son is 6 and has wanted to be a girl since the age of 4. We too are looking for some friends who can relate to us. I think its great you have come on here and asked if there is anyone else as I have come on the net looking for the same thing! JH
Reply
Thursday 08 April
By ericka
i am 18 years old and i am currently dating a transgender he hasnt started any of the transformations yet but is ready just got to get the money for it i am trying to figure out why transforming to a male is more exspencive than going from male to woman i no people might thing we are young but we can make it work
Reply
Friday 12 November
By Annonimous
I am a transgenderd boy and i dont know what to do. Can someone help me?
Reply