Mommyblogger extraordinaire Rita Arens explores the unique situation of transgender children -- and their parents -- for BlogHer. At BlogHer09 Conference, I sat down to lunch with friends in the basement of the Sheraton. A little later we were joined by a slim woman with short hair. She introduced herself, and we started talking about eco-stuff, as she is an eco blogger.
Then I sort of faded out of the conversation and snapped back in when she mentioned she is the parent of a transgendered child. A very young transgender child.
I had to pause and shake off my initial thought, which I admit was, But what if it's just a phase? I might have said it. I hope I didn't. I'm sure Jen Khatchatrian hears that all the time. And before you click away from this post because it's off my normal beat, pull up a chair at this lunch table and join me to listen.
Changing My Mind About Changing Gender

I'd love to tell you that I'm the world's most open-minded person -- that I came out that way. But I didn't. I get messages every day from the media, from my life experiences, from friends, neighbors and family. I grew up thinking boys were boys and girls were girls and everyone was either Lutheran or going Straight To Hell.
Click here to keep reading.
Nobody tried to brainwash me -- it was just the environment I grew up in. As I've traveled through my life, I've tried to stop and listen before making assumptions. I've tried and continue to try to let new facts filter in and shape my perceptions.
I went into the conversation thinking it was wrong to let a young child make the decision to change his or her gender. I came out of lunch thinking, I have to help this woman find friends for her daughter. Her daughter who has a penis.
And I also thought, "This has to be the toughest parenting decision a person could have to make."
What changed my mind? Listening to Jen's story. She talked of her daughter's pain and isolation, how she asked, "Am I the only one?"
How Far Would You Go to Help Your Kid?Can you imagine how you would feel if your child asked you if he or she was the only person in the world with such a primal problem?
I thought of my own daughter and how I would do anything to help her grow up as secure and happy as possible. And I realized that if I were in Jen's place, I would be there at the therapist every week, just like she is. I would be searching the world for other boys who believed they were girls. I would be traveling to transgender conferences wearing a T-shirt saying, "I'm from Chicago," just like Jen is.
We can't judge until we've walked in her shoes. Jen's certainly not crazy, and I doubt her kid is, either. We know many aspects of humanity operate on a spectrum, and gender is just another component of humanity.
"It's Like You're Trapped"
WPTZ in Omaha covered a transgendered-boy-to-girl story in May. The child said: "It's kind of like you're trapped somewhere and you can't get out," said the boy, whose name and face are not being made public to protect the family from potential harm.
"20/20" covered the story of Jazz, a 5-year-old girl who was born as a boy, in April 2007. While Jazz's parents now fully accept their son as their daughter, the transition has not been without considerable doubt and stress. Many parents grieve for the child that never was.
"I mourn the loss of the idea of my son," Renee said. "I see pictures and the video, and that child's gone. But there's a wonderful person now that's with us."
Jazz, Katie (in Omaha) and Jen's daughter are lucky to have parents who want to help them. According to a 2007 San Francisco State University Chavez Center Institute study, GLBT and questioning kids who come from an unsupportive family are nine times more likely to commit suicide than other kids.
Unique Challenges for Unique Children
Unsupportive parents aren't the only obstacle transgender kids face.
Michael Rowe wrote a while ago on the Huffington Post about KRXQ's shock jocks' vicious attacks on transgender children, who are, after all, children, first and foremost. Trusting, innocent and vulnerable, they ought to be beyond the reach of the violent, hate-mongering adult rhetoric that is taken for granted on American talk radio.
One needs no particular sympathy for transgender people to understand the prodigious boundary transgression of promoting contempt and disgust towards children -- anyone's children -- on a radio show.
How You Can Help
You may know a transgender child without realizing you do. How to help instead of hurt? TransYouth Family Allies offers these suggestions:
* Treat these children as you would any other child.
* Use the child's preferred name and pronouns.
* Avoid gender stereotyping and speak out against it in your interaction with others.
* Intervene when you witness bullying or intolerance.
* Help create gender-neutral spaces on school campuses.
* Help create comprehensive anti-bullying programs that include gender identity and expression in workplaces and schools.
* Contact your local lawmakers and request legislation to protect gender identity and expression in your state, city or township.
* Volunteer your time and talents or donate your funds to help educate others on gender identity and gender expression.
Jen is still looking for a girl-with-boy-plumbing to be friends with her daughter, so she can prove she is not the only one. Can you help her find such a child?
More Resources:
* TransYouth Family Allies
* "The Transgender Child: A Handbook for Families and Professionals"
BlogHer is the leading participatory news, entertainment and information network for women online. Follow us at BlogHer.com, on Twitter (@Blogher) and on Facebook.












Comments:
Add a comment
Saturday 05 September
By Kelly
How 'bout her mom tries to find her friends who accept her the way she is? I mean, I'm white, female, and straight, but that doesn't mean I'm ONLY friends with other white, straight females.
Reply
Saturday 05 September
By Payton
That's not the point. The point is to show her daughter that she's not the only girl with boy parts, not to isolate her into being friends with ONLY transgendered children.
Sunday 06 September
By Ustand4what
Sick.Every kid thinks the "other" has it better in one way or another at some point.That doesn't mean that when they literally mean it.Those thoughts aren't even in their heads until someone puts it there either by accident or on purpose.They get them started thinking in that direction and tell them it's o.k. and acceptable and they think,"well maybe.O.K. easy way out to deal with things."
The ones that allow this should be charged with abuse towards a child.
For lack of a better example just off the cuff.... A rowdy female kitten that likes to act like a Tomcat,won't ever be one.And shouldn't.God created male and female and called it "good".
Reply
Monday 07 September
By wench
Do you really think that your genitals determine your gender? Or that children don't know which gender they feel like? Kids know. It would be wrong to let them have gender reassignment surgery, but if a kid wants to grow up a boy or a girl, they ought to get to pick. After all, we're equal, with equal rights and responsibilities in this society, so gender is really just a matter of image these days.
Thursday 10 September
By Sarah
Just because the child doesn't feel like shit fits in doesn't mean it's the mothers fault. The mother of this child is trying to show her she's not the only one and if any one is making her think she's a freak it's other children or any one else who is not accepting. It's not always the parents fault. Kids tease other kids and that hurts more than someone older or younger than you teasing you. Trust me, I'm not a transgender person but I had a hard time in school as a young child. Despite my mother telling me I was special and that there was nothing wrong with me, I still managed to be made fun of for something and I took it hard.
Friday 11 September
By Sarah
I mean "She" not "shit."
Tuesday 15 September
By adyson
You don't understand it is their choice and God didn't make peoples personalitys as to being transgendered it's not right to say that it is abuse the child wants this for their life and not only because they dream to be the other gender also to fill the hole in their hearts so you should not say that but it is your opinion I'm not going to say one thing or another!
Tuesday 15 September
By Donovan
there is scientific proof showing that on occasion the brains chemical structure can be opposite the body's so yes "god" if you believe in him made us boys and girls but that doesn't mean everyone is perfect i have glasses i didn't choose to have glasses i need them because without them i cannot see this girl and i will call her a girl in her mind knows the way she has been made is wrong we look from the outside she feels from the inside one was incorrect who are we to judge
Wednesday 16 September
By IBCHEROKEE
I AGREE. GOD MADE US MALE AND FEMALE AND SAID IT WAS GOOD.IF YOU TELL A CHILD THAT HE IS STUPID LONG ENOUGH HE WILL START TO BELIEVE IT, THEREFOR YOU CAN CAUSE THEM TO BELIEVE THAT THEY ARE NOT WHAT GOD MADE THEM
Monday 21 September
By Marlene
Ustand4what & IBCHEROKEE -- When you rant and are rude to others by screaming that your Bronze Age book is valid in the 21st century, read the passage about eunuchs.
Furthermore, oh ignorant one, there are examples of intersexuality in humans (ambiguous genitalia, extra and missing sex chromosomes). How do you explain *that*, sweetheart?
Also Cherokee (if you really *are* a member of the tribe!) Go look up how your ancestors revered and venerated two-spirit people!
Sunday 06 September
By SarasNavel
Kelly, she will do just that but she needs to build confidence in who she really is verses who she thought she had to be. Part of that process is to meet others like herself. I'm sure she has and will have diverse friends; sometimes however, having someone that understands your differences first-hand just can't be beat. Luckily this kid has a very understanding and brave mom that should be proud of herself for putting her daughter's core needs above more trivial concerns. So many other kids aren't so lucky...Go, Jen!
Reply
Sunday 06 September
By Sara
Lucky girl indeed to have such a Mom. Without that support and love this girl could easily end up just another statistic on the suicide rolls of transexual kids. Those of us who transition to our target sex and live full, productive lives understand the needs of trans kids more than any others.
Jen is to be commended for her unconditional love of her daughter. And I know the woman who runs TYFA (Trans Youth Family Allies). She is amazing and dedicated to helping trans kids and their families. Kim Pearson is tireless. She has saved lives, literally. And she and a few dedicated volunteers cover the country to help families in need. If you have a moment, visit her site and donate a few dollars. You can make a difference for people like Jen and her daughter.
Sara ...
Reply
Tuesday 08 September
By Julie
I find this topic interesting, because I do see sexuality and gender orientation as a spectrum. During most of my childhood, I had wished I was a boy. I was raised a lot by my father, who wanted a son and would pretend I was a boy (to this day he refers to me as his "son", even though it's obvious I'm a girl and always have been). But, clearly I am a women and I can't say I mind being one. But to be honest, if I was born male (in the body of a man), I wouldn't mind either. Obviously I can't say for sure, since I've never experienced life as a man, but I must say, either way, I would just accept myself (and wouldn't try to live as a female with a penis). There are some very masculine women and some feminine men, and I don't fully understand why a boy who "thinks he's a girl", can't just accept that life is not fair, and live his life as a feminine man.
Before I get any hate comments, please note that I wrote "I can't understand why" not "it shouldn't be this way". People can do what they want, and I'll never stand in their way, just pointing out the idea of a man who absolutely can't stand having a penis, seems a bit extreme to me.
Reply
Tuesday 15 September
By Donovan
not hate just saying as i see it there is just as much logic saying the body is wrong as saying the mind is wrong except the body cant speak up so you just have to trust the mind and also its not so much not being able to stand having a penis in the same way i cant stand mustard on my hot dog its more the fact that you don't feel like it belongs there
Thursday 10 September
By Frank
Right! Because a child has enough knowledge and experience to make such a life decision... If I'd ever encountered such a child (tran), I certainly would not rebuke the child, or "send the child to hell;" however I cannot agree with a parent letting their child make such a decision. Children grow to learn right from wrong, and I truly believe that it is wrong for any man or woman to try to be the opposite sex. I may have just earned a few F#$% you's, but think of this before you tell me I am not open-minded: You'll contradict yourself the moment you rebuke me for my opinion that differs from yours.
Reply
Saturday 12 September
By thomas wayne gregory
i have to come out and say it. I AM TRANSGENDER. i have been this way my whole life. from the time i knew what a girl and a boys was i knew i was really a girl in a boys body. I have not been lucky enough to have parents that understand me. So i have had to hide the fact that im transgender. and i have been depressed by this my whole life. of course when i was 6 my mother left my dad. and i lived with her and my sister. at school i never hung around the boys. i was always playing with the girls. Then one year came when i 8. mom could not find a good Halloween costume for me. So i said how about i dress up as a girl. And i did. I got to wear a pretty pink dress, panties, tights, mary janes, a wig, nail polish. well you get what i mean. but any way i got to go to school that day as a girl and go trick-or-treating that night. it was the happiest day of my life. Then after i was old enough to left alone at the house i would try on some make-up or my sisters clothes. but i have been on a mission to find other transgender kids and teens. i want to help make this world a better place by trying to teach people about being transgender and make it all right for boys to wear girls clothes. i have so much to talk about it not even funny. i could type all night about this but to save you some time i will not. but if you know any one who is transgender please show them this message i would love to talk to them.
Reply
Saturday 12 September
By Jai
I'm also Transgender. I knew from the age of 4 I was meant to be a boy. I'm am a female to male transsexual. I have accepting parents and I am 100% grateful and love my family for being so accepting. Growing up at school I'd write in my excersise books when I was 6 that when I grew up I wanted to be a boy. I used to wish on my birthdays that I would become a boy. When I hit puberty, I became suicidal and I self injured and it took me until I was 13 to be able to research what was happening. I didn't begin transitioning until May 2007 due to some personal issues but believe me it is the best thing I have done. I have been on hormone refferal treatment (HRT) since December 2007 and can say I haven't had a suicidal thought or self harmed in nearly a year. I have an amazing network of friends that support me and understand me and I am in a steady and serious relationship with my girlfriend. If I could change my life so I was born a boy, I wouldn't. I'm proud to be Transgender and my aims are to help Transgender youths. If you'd like to contact me thomas please email at mrcslsd [at] hotmail.co.uk (I can provide you with some links and support sites if you wish)
Tuesday 15 September
By adyson
Right! i think you should express your feelings and you areso brave for coming out and saying that I stand up for Transgenders it is your guys' choice to do what you want for your body i am very proud you had the confidence to post that on the internet!
Tuesday 15 September
By RICKI
I WAS BORN MALE I THOUGHT.I LIKED BEING WITH GIRLS AND DRESSING UPAS ONE..ONLY TO FIND OUT .I AM A FEMALE MALE I STARTED MY PERIOD BUT IT DID NOT HAVE A CLEAR PATH OUT UNTIL THEY OPPERATED. I WAS RAISED AS A MALE PEOPLE KNOW ME AS A MALE OUT EVER I HAVE A UTEROUS AND BREAST AND OVI-TESTIES SO I CAN FEEL FOR ANYBODY WHO FEELS THEY ARE THE OPPOSITE
Tuesday 15 September
By Nicole
First of all bullying is wrong PERIOD no matter what the child is.I think the reason why Jen is trying to find kids with the same thing as her daughter-turning son due to there would be children her own age who would understand what he is going through and to try to avoid the awakardness about the kids at school.Maybe Jen is homeschooling her child.If my children were going through what Jen child and other children go through I would support my child and agree to make the change at atleast 18 or up.Thought,etc, takes time.A parent is a parent.A child only wants everlasting love.Love your children no matter what.Gay,bi,transgrender,etc.Always love your child.
Reply