It was a dark and stormy night, and people across the country were desperately trying to write the worst opening sentence for a novel to win the Bulwer-Lytton Fiction Contest. Here's what the winner, David McKenzie, 55, came up with:"Folks say that if you listen real close at the height of the full moon, when the wind is blowin' off Nantucket Sound from the nor' east and the dogs are howlin' for no earthly reason, you can hear the awful screams of the crew of the "Ellie May," a sturdy whaler Captained by John McTavish; for it was on just such a night when the rum was flowin' and, Davey Jones be damned, big John brought his men on deck for the first of several screaming contests."
Read more about the Bulwer-Lytton wretched-writing contest after the jump.
The contest, which began at San Jose State University in 1982, challenges contestants to write the worst possible opening line. The end results, as bad-writing contests tend to be, are hilarious.
Who inspired this literary throwdown? Edward George Earl Bulwer-Lytton, the novelist and author of the recollection "It was a dark and stormy night" that inspired Snoopy to begin many of his works with the same phrase. The Nineteenth-century writer Bulwer-Lytton also coined chestnuts such as "the almighty dollar" and "the pen is mightier than the sword."
In addition to lame bragging rights, the contest winner also receives, in the words of the Web site, "a pittance."
Perhaps the runner-up deserves a kick in the pants for conceiving a run-on like this: "The wind dry-shaved the cracked earth like a dull razor -- the double edge kind from the plastic bag that you shouldn't use more than twice, but you do; but Trevor Earp had to face it as he started the second morning of his hopeless search for Drover, the Irish Wolfhound he had found as a pup near death from a fight with a prairie dog and nursed back to health, stolen by a traveling circus so that the monkey would have something to ride."
More awesome stuff from around the Web:
Five Lessons Books Could Learn From Movies
Should You Google-Stalk Your Date?
The Wit and Wisdom of Church Signs
Tacky Weddings: A Photo Odyssey

















Comments:
Add a comment
Friday 03 July
By chy
thats good
Reply
Friday 03 July
By chy
beautiful
Reply
Friday 03 July
By cal
FYI: as horrible as that runner-up sentence is, it's NOT a run-on. It's a finely constructed, grammatically correct sentence. I hate it when people use "run-on" incorrectly. Okay, okay -- you found me out -- I'm an English teacher! Great writing, though!! Fun stuff.
Reply
Friday 03 July
By brian bennett
Great writing and real fun stuff but, apparently you and I are the only ones who think so.
Friday 03 July
By Cindy
Those were funny, they ought to be novels!
Friday 03 July
By anne
Even though these winners could use some grammatical reconstruction, they are quite colorful. I love the metaphor, "The wind dry-shaved the cracked earth like a dull razor." The winners of this contest obviously know enough about the English language just how to push the reader almost to the brink. If you really want to see some terrible writing, I would love to share what I am reading right now as I grade some essays from my eleventh grade students. I am sometimes paralyzed with incredulity and wonder who has passed these kids on when they cannot construct a properly constructed sentence.
Monday 06 July
By Alethea
I myself am NOT an English teacher, but I am an avid reader who can distinguish grammatical errors. This is certainly a run on sentence because in at least TWO places I can place a period, or a semi-comma. CAn you identify those places? Obviously not. The sentence should have read, " Yet Trevor Earp had to face it"..."Drover, the Irish Wolfhound, he had nursed back to health"... The word "that" is usually a filler word. I learned this at a community college.
Friday 03 July
By Silvergirl
The whole idea of a contest for such a thing is just soooo typical of the times in which we live where the whole world of what's good and right is upside down. Why do we aspire to such tripe is my question. We do we concern ourselves with trying to out do the stupid? It's so pointless. It's like, well... what do I do now to upset the balance of right and wrong. Pointless waste of time.
Reply
Monday 06 July
By Glenn Edgar
To Slavegirl:
I just read your comment, and I'm soooo, well, like, upset at how superficially your thoughts on the contest were. It pointlessly, "upsets the balance of right and wrong"? Pointlessly even. That is so "out there" that it leaves me speechless. You should have entered your comment in the contest! LOL Seriously, I think this contest is a great idea, which benefits both contestants and the general public, who get to look at the entries. First of all, it's fun! Nothing is wrong with some good harmless fun. More important, of course, are the benefits. It requires imagination, and surprisingly, some deep thinking into what constitutes *good* writing. Because in order to do a good job of being bad, you have to know what "good" is. LOL [Sadly, I'm going to have to Google "run on sentence", because according to some of the comments above, I don't think I can.]
Friday 03 July
By Pam
Wretchedly funny!
Reply
Friday 03 July
By jettjon
Both of you are correct... and isn't it telling that Michael Jackson gets tens of thousands of comments, but a writing contest gets three? And this reporter/writer is probably more of the current crop who never bothered to pay attention in school and is more concerened with "making" the news than reporting it. Run on, indeed!
Reply
Friday 03 July
By Rae
Oddly enough, when I was reading the runner-up sentence, I thought to myself: "Wow, he managed to string all of that together, and there isn't a grammatical error in sight!"
However, I'm personally more a fan of the Lyttle-Lytton contest. Short and sweet, and funny!
Reply
Friday 03 July
By CG
I am a paralegal. Trust me, MOST attorneys could win this contest hands down without even trying. Just read the first sentence/paragraph of any of their pleadings! I always thought they taught run-on sentences the first year of law school.
Reply
Friday 03 July
By hg
it just seems bad taste --it's more of a horror flick type and style of writing---winston churchhill never grouped words like that either----the english language of england in terms of old english vs modern english has distorted into many forms for personal use--- i will agree it's bad written or spoken english-----but this form may be horrible but it makes great horror flicks keeping you coming back for more
Reply
Friday 03 July
By Pat
I'm so happy to learn they are still holding this contest. I have 3 of the books with past entries and I always get a laugh out of them. I haven't seen any new books in several years. I hope they will publish more.
Reply
Friday 03 July
By Jan
You have to realize that most people who comment on here cant spell, can barely read and have been spending the last 10 minutes trying to google the word "dictionary"....lol.
Reply
Friday 03 July
By girallie
The runner-up sentence is not a run-on. The semi colon actually separates sentences. I'm not an english teacher, but agree with cal.
Reply
Friday 03 July
By Cathy Olson
Read enough books on how to get published these days and those opening sentences seem to fit the bill.
Reply
Friday 03 July
By buzz
Most extraordinary. All the comments to this story have been rational, coherent and intelligent. I guess this type of material doesn't attract the usual psychos and dysfunctional twits and hate mongers.
Reply
Friday 03 July
By Aenvoy
I am always afraid I am going to write something I truly believe is my best and end up winning this award.
Reply