Researchers in Israel have found that women who encounter workplace sexual harassment do not usually report the incidents and tend to leave their companies instead. As your resident Human Resources expert, I'm not shocked or outraged by this news. In fact, I fully support this course of action.
There is no reason, ever, to tolerate a hostile work environment. It's insidious, it's damaging and it's unacceptable. I encourage you to stand up to anyone who harasses you and devalues your work. But if your employer hires or keeps on staff someone who thinks it's okay to treat you like a second-class citizen, that means your company is already broken.
Reporting the harassment and enlightening the "perp" is worthwhile; however, the most
effective way to make the harassment stop is to formally reject your company, focus on your career and get the heck out of there. Implement a strategy of shock and awe.Click here to read why reporting harassment isn't worth it.
Trying to change the system from within has failed American women for decades. Don't be a sucker -- say "I quit" instead.
The Most Annoying Co-Workers
Insistent Instant Messenger: No matter how much time or miscommunication could be spared by talking face-to-face, this person insists on talking virtually, via IM or email. If they're a superior and you're not online, they send you an email to ask where you are (meanwhile you're at your desk, ten feet away).
Cycle Sister: This is a person you're not particularly fond of, but for whatever cosmically twisted reason, your daily routine is synched up -- you walk into work at the same time, and from there, you see your Cycle Sister in the bathroom, on your smoke break, at the vending machine, and on the way out. Even if you do like this person alright, the sheer coincidence makes things creepy and awkward.
Mr. Flibble, Flickr
The Get-a-Lifer: This person asks you out to post-work drinks on a regular basis, despite the fact that you always decline. And the one time you went to a party at their house, it ended up being the two of you playing Taboo. The Get-a-Lifer is often the same person who plans meetings at 6 p.m. on Fridays, not realizing that everyone else goes out with their friends on the weekend.
bealluc, Flickr
Listserv Leech: If someone has taken this person's lunch out of the fridge, the entire staff will be notified via the staff listserv, which everyone else uses exclusively for professional communication. Alternately, this person may use the listserv to let everyone know about the lack of toilet paper in the bathroom, a party they're throwing, or to ask who took that package off their desk.
Angry Typist: The Angry Typist pounds on her keyboard with the vigor of someone hitting their ex-boyfriend. The violent clacking leads to many misunderstandings, as this person is often unaware of their problem and is not actually pissed.
.faramarz, Flickr
The Toilet Mouth: You're on the pot midstream (or worse) when the Toilet Mouth strikes up a conversation. This person also likes to chatter at the sink for before and after they go, giving no one in the bathroom privacy to do their business.
Megan *, Flickr
Monday Manic: The coffee hasn't hit your bloodstream yet, and the Monday Manic is flittering about, imbued with an unnatural amount of energy and optimism. They're telling stories about how freaking great their weekend was and so stoked about the work they get to do that day.
Old News Hound: OMG, did you hear that Lindsay Lohan is dating a girl!? The Old News Hound is always the last to know about everything, but the first to belt out at a stale headline at full-volume to their surrounding coworkers.
Rash Revealer:This person has no shame getting on the phone with their doctor, their spouse, their aunt, or their mom to discuss a rash, a yeast infection, and any other personal bodily defect or medical issue.
maydaFUNKbewithu!, Flickr
The Chit-Chat Blaster: If this person catches you in the break room or on your way out of the bathroom, you're done for a half an hour later they're still yammering away about the paint samples they're considering for the livingroom, the deli they ate at for lunch, the meeting the boss called earlier, the diet they're on. The Chit-Chat Blaster also doesn't notice you inching away, and generally lack the ability to pick up social cues.
Some might say it's anti-feminist to say that a woman's two best choices are to put up with it or leave. I think it's anti-feminist to judge another woman's choice (unless you are the Octo-mom and then I'm going to judge you so hard).
HR Is Not Your Pal
If you choose to stick around and report the incident, there is no turning back. Your HR representative is tasked with moving quickly to protect the organization's image, and the system for investigating the claim of harassment is callous.
The goal of a harassment investigation is to establish blame and shift liability away from your employer. The burden of proof falls on your shoulders. Rather than asking how you want the situation to be resolved, Human Resources is primarily concerned with determining if you are lying or telling the truth. Even though you are a victim and your HR rep may sympathize, your feelings will only be addressed to the extent that it protects the company.
If you are successful at proving the harassment, which is very unlikely, you may be asked to continue to work with the offending employee – no matter how awkward this feels for you – because he has the right to a "second chance" according to most corporate disciplinary policies.
Another, even more insulting solution is that your harasser might be paid to resign -- HR execs see it all the time. The goal is to pacify the victim and secure a promise that the offender will not sue the company for firing.
Be Your Own Union Rep
I believe the best way to remedy harassment effectively in the workforce is to quit. Companies are only motivated to change their behaviors when faced with financial implications, so I suggest that you turn in your resignation and then inform your employer about what happened.
This doesn't sound like a great solution, but I know firsthand that the cost of replacing you -- and your awesome institutional knowledge – is enough to draw thoughtful and sincere attention to the problem.
Telling a woman not to report harassment seems counterintuitive and anti-feminist; however, I see this action as the most courageous action a victim can take. Dare to demand a work environment where gender equality and cultural sensitivity are important, and accept nothing less -- even if that' means finding a new work environment.
Laurie Ruettimann is a writer, speaker and HR exec with Fortune 500 experience. She blogs at Punk Rock Human Resources.
The Most Annoying Co-Workers
Insistent Instant Messenger: No matter how much time or miscommunication could be spared by talking face-to-face, this person insists on talking virtually, via IM or email. If they're a superior and you're not online, they send you an email to ask where you are (meanwhile you're at your desk, ten feet away).
Cycle Sister: This is a person you're not particularly fond of, but for whatever cosmically twisted reason, your daily routine is synched up -- you walk into work at the same time, and from there, you see your Cycle Sister in the bathroom, on your smoke break, at the vending machine, and on the way out. Even if you do like this person alright, the sheer coincidence makes things creepy and awkward.
Mr. Flibble, Flickr
The Get-a-Lifer: This person asks you out to post-work drinks on a regular basis, despite the fact that you always decline. And the one time you went to a party at their house, it ended up being the two of you playing Taboo. The Get-a-Lifer is often the same person who plans meetings at 6 p.m. on Fridays, not realizing that everyone else goes out with their friends on the weekend.
bealluc, Flickr
Listserv Leech: If someone has taken this person's lunch out of the fridge, the entire staff will be notified via the staff listserv, which everyone else uses exclusively for professional communication. Alternately, this person may use the listserv to let everyone know about the lack of toilet paper in the bathroom, a party they're throwing, or to ask who took that package off their desk.
Angry Typist: The Angry Typist pounds on her keyboard with the vigor of someone hitting their ex-boyfriend. The violent clacking leads to many misunderstandings, as this person is often unaware of their problem and is not actually pissed.
.faramarz, Flickr
The Toilet Mouth: You're on the pot midstream (or worse) when the Toilet Mouth strikes up a conversation. This person also likes to chatter at the sink for before and after they go, giving no one in the bathroom privacy to do their business.
Megan *, Flickr
Monday Manic: The coffee hasn't hit your bloodstream yet, and the Monday Manic is flittering about, imbued with an unnatural amount of energy and optimism. They're telling stories about how freaking great their weekend was and so stoked about the work they get to do that day.
Old News Hound: OMG, did you hear that Lindsay Lohan is dating a girl!? The Old News Hound is always the last to know about everything, but the first to belt out at a stale headline at full-volume to their surrounding coworkers.
Rash Revealer:This person has no shame getting on the phone with their doctor, their spouse, their aunt, or their mom to discuss a rash, a yeast infection, and any other personal bodily defect or medical issue.
maydaFUNKbewithu!, Flickr
The Chit-Chat Blaster: If this person catches you in the break room or on your way out of the bathroom, you're done for a half an hour later they're still yammering away about the paint samples they're considering for the livingroom, the deli they ate at for lunch, the meeting the boss called earlier, the diet they're on. The Chit-Chat Blaster also doesn't notice you inching away, and generally lack the ability to pick up social cues.












Comments:
Add a comment
Saturday 28 February
By K
I'm a male and I have been on the recieving end on sexual harassment by other men. I was not singled out, this was done to other men as well. Most took it in stride, joked along with them or just ignored it. I had had enough of hearing another man telling me to s*** their d***! and I stood up for myself. I told them and my bosses the it would stop or I would make things misserable for the company and the offenders. What did it get me? I got shunned by all the workes at the plant not just the ones who haressed me. I got pasted over for promotions thst I was in line for. No one would work with me and the bosses stopped talking to me. Got me no where. I quit! This was a good job with great pay and benifits. It is a no win situation for the offended.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By keeptryingscum
Excellent selfless piece of advice from the Israelis. I think that ALL Israeli women "need to quit" :)
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By D
This article is ridiculous! We do not live in the middle east where children are married off at the age of 8 in arranged marriages! Sexual harrassment will continue if we don't collectively and continuously stand up to these actions.
How about taking Aikido or another form of self-defense? Be very aware of your surroundings and if the perp comes up behind you to touch you, a very swiftly planted elbow in the stomach "accidently" because, "oops, you surprised me!" can help. I do recommend that you get real training in it. The training helps you on many different levels.
Also, I agree with the very LOUDLY stated things like, "I do not like it when you touch my breast, so don't EVER do it again!" If the haraasment continues, or worsens, then the monitoring devices added on to it could help. Most perps will back down when they are caught in the act. In some circumstances, letting the spouse know can help. Remaining silent just reinforces the idea that this behavior is acceptable.
Our society has degraded in the last 10 years and heading back to the days where this harrassment was considered to be normal male behavior. We need to dress in business-like ways, behave in business-like manners and stand up to all inapproriate verbal and sexual abuse.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By unemployed
I used to work for the St ate of Missouri. You'd think that the state would actually be better than the private sector? It is taxpayer money.
But, here's the deal. HR is there to back up the organization. Not the employee.
Their lawyer said to go to mediation. So my lawyer agreed. Well, mediation did nothing. They did not want to compromise or do anything.
So our option was to file under EEOC both state and Federal. Now, the Feds will sue, but realize that only about 1% of the complaints end up having the Feds suing. There are a lot out there they just do nothing about. Same with the state. The odds are stacked against you.
The mediatior said, well they're not compromising and dropped it. This was the Law School at the University of Missouri. Another state institution.
So our option was to sue. We filed a lawsuit and did have a good case, but realize this, it takes money to sue. And you have to pay the hundreds of dollars an hour up front, plus a retainer.
And to find out, IF you do win, the State of Missouri keeps you from any state employment for FIVE years, and you NEVER are able to work for the agency you sued. Plus you have to get a jury in Missouri, the we-hate-taxes-government-is-evil jury of your peers, to give you a settlement. Fat chance.
We quit before we went to trial. Even though I had a good case. But, at least the harassment stopped. Oh yeah, best comment, 'We're the State of Missouri, we don't have to follow ADA.' I finally quit.
Good luck though, odds are stacked against you. Even if this is the 21st century.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By Frank
With the easy availability of small tape recorders it seems to me that woman who are dealing with sexual harrassment would simply tuck one of these where they can turn it on surreptitiously and catch the offender in action. Men who sexually harrass women in the workplace should be fired immediately.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By l
It is obvious who's side the author is on. Instead of facing reality and cleaning out inappropriate employees, the victim should leave with no compensation. Awesome, why don't we all just lay down and die and let our boss grope us on the way out the door.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By Koosh
Laurie's advice is counterproductive and dead wrong. Her reasoning is anecdotal. Why not describe some companies that do a good job protecting all employees (not just women are victims, Laurie) from harassment. As long as people occupy the workplace, there will be harassment but many companies do an excellent job getting the word out that there will be ZERO tolerance for harassment and keeping their word. They also conduct investigations that are prompt and courteous and result in an appropriate disposition. I really wonder if Laurie has any relevant business experience or if she just came up with her idiotic recommendation to get some cheap publicity.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By Val
Queen Robin - you passed up a golden opportunity to embarass the guy who made you look at his penis. I would have gone a little closer for a better look and then laughed hysterically at it's size or position or maybe there was a mole on it or something. "My 5 year old nephew has a few inches on you buddy!" Either way I would have definitely mocked the 'dick' and walked around with my head high. I would have also told any employee who hadn't had the privelege to not be insulted - it wasn't worth the look!
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By Harrassed
Interesting article. I have experienced harrassement many times in the workplace and NEVER have encouraged it and I'll tell you that HR department do protect the company first. Your life is usually hell if you report and end of staying. In many cases, companies protect their morons although not always. If you're planning on leaving, report it to HR, document, document, document and don't contribute to the problem. Collect any info you can on the idiot (dates and times) be as specific as possible. 6 months is the standard that you can get a company to pay you if you've legitimately been wronged. Using a lawyer is helpful but if you negotiate it on your own, 6 month pay is typically what you can get so negotiate for a year and the lawyers will negotiate down. Court costs will be more. Be professional and firm and stay relevant. The company may play some games with you and give you special treatment which often is just singling you out to make you feel bad. Lawyers will give you a free consultation typically. They will tell you to document.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By PriderockT
Spoken like a true male chaouvenist, or a wannabe. The best way to get back at these types of people is to air their behavior, and ruin their reputation. Annymisously of course, and on the internet. Also, send an annymous memo to the top bosses, especially the perps top boss. If the perp is the top boss, then resort to the first two steps already mentioned.Victems, stand up for your rights, and stop letting others victemize you. You're a person of worth and value. If the leech is incapible of realizing that, then that leech has to go. Not you.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By Kate
What disgusting advice! I was forced to leave one job due to sexual harrassment and it took me YEARS to find another another decent job afterwards. And six months after I left the job I'd been harrassed in, the guy was fired for (guess what) sexual harrassment. Never again. I have a right to work, damn it, and in this economy I am not ABOUT to go throwing away my job. My sister was harassed at work (Red Cross), complained, and the issue was resolved within a few weeks with the guy's termination (granted, he was an extreme perv who eventually started following her home). What ever happened to changing the system from within? Employees are expendable, jobs are NOT.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By Val
Thanks Wes, unfortunately I learned very young when I worked in a car dealership (the only female on the selling floor) how to deal with this sort of thing. The first time I really had to put it into play was when I was on a date with a guy my mother wanted me to go out with because she was friends with his mother. He wanted to leave one bar where all my friends were and go to another - well he pulled into a motel parking lot and wanted to get a room. When I tried to get out of the car he used the electric locks and I couldn't get out. So - I told him that on second thought, he SHOULD go book a room and if he wasn't the absolute best lover I ever had, I was going to go back to the bar we had left and tell all my friends. He put the car in drive and took me home. When I got out of the car he begged me not to tell my mother because he didn't want it to get back to his mother. What a baby.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By Bobcheesedoodle
Another option that no one seems to be considering is going along with the harassment. Many women have advanced themselves by carrying-on with their co-workers. Let's face it, part of human nature is women using their womenly ways to get ahead. Are we talking about some perfect world or the real world?
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By Vonnie
Unfortunately, many women(or men) do not live in a city where there is a choice
of good jobs. In my city, there are only two places of employment that are available to a great number of people. It's not always feasible to say, "I quit!"
The job market is almost non-existent in my city, unless you know someone who can pull some strings to get you hired. Every city is not like New York or
Chicago.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By Stuck to my guns in Alabama
I did NOT work five years at my company, building business it would take years to replace, just to quit. After several demands to my boss for his behavior to stop, I finally told my company higher ups what was going on, and they moved the offender out of my office. He pretty much self destructed on his own shortly thereafter. I got a confidential settlement from the company - that they offered, apparently afraid I might file an EEOC report - and was allowed to work reporting directly to them, not to my old boss. In the paperwork, they did NOT cover my old boss legally, in case I wanted to seperately sue him in addition to the settlement they gave me. It turns out that he was embezzling funds from them as well - we all found out later.
This type of guy plays fast and loose with all the rules and companies who are smart find they are better without these men (or women as the case might be). I chose not to sue my old boss seperately since I knew that A) He was filing for bankruptcy and B) he had three kids, C) I did not want to ruin my own rep is our small community.
I did think about quitting many times and even saw a therapist during the saga. But I decided that no way was I giving up what I had worked so hard for in terms of my business and my client base, so instead I started gathering evidence and documentation. Nobody does that to me and gets away with it.
There were no negative repercussions for me. In fact, I made four times as much money after the incident when I was able to report directly to someone over my bosses head. That's not including the settlement. Women don't necessarily have to sue, but they don't have to turn tail and run either.
I should also note that this was serious sexual abuse and harrassment. The expectation of sex in return for commissions due to me, etc. I think sometimes women are way too quick to take offense at off color remarks or jokes when such things are not really an impediment to job performance. But when someone is physically touching you sexually, extorting sex, or tying your compensation to sexual favors as happened in my case, THAT is sexual harrassment, if not abuse, and I don't think that a woman's only option in that case is (or should be) to quit and run to another company. It is certainly a woman's CHOICE to do that, but we need to back her up all the way if she chooses to report it and demand her rights instead.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By harrassed
It's also amazing in my experience how men feel that it's ok to harrass their employees when they're in a power position. It becomes the victims problem. I recently went through a situation last year with a certain erp training company in the east coast. The pig that initiated the harrassment, I later found out did this to a number of woman at the same company. Based on my understanding, I'm the only one that stepped up. I find it funny how men find a way to say that you brought it on. I'll tell you, it all starts when they start complaining about their wives and how mistreated they are. That's the first signal..the victim act. Beware ladies!! Document everything dates and time. Remember, only some states will allow you to record conversation without the other person knowing. I think Minnesota lets you record conversations. Remember, you can always tell their wives.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By mimi
When I have been approached with "sexual suggections," I respond by stating if it happens again, I will be happy to share the comment with all co workers and with their wife or girlfriend. That is usually the end of it........try it.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By Ken
You ladies, especially you feminists, are so unstable emmotionally that you're like a volcano that could erupt at any second. When you are in your playful moods, or around someone you secretly admire,you enjoy and even initiate the same behavior that you then turn around and throw a hissy fit about at your next convienient TIME. Bottom line is. Women were not designed to work hand in hand with men. It undermines the family unit, the efficiencies of companies and the livleyhoods of the people who God intended to be the workers of the society- men. I know all you man haters cant stand it, but the fact is that our society started to deteriorate when women started working full time jobs. Its just a fact that cant be argued with. So, all you man haters put the facts in your tight little pipes and puff away! And all you men who let the man haters run your homes and wear your pants should be forced to wear their little skirts around. Best way to live a happy life is stay the hell away from women. Their minds have all been warped by liberal media from their births and they are all oportunistic, tempermental, selfish C-u-N-t-S.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By sarah
I did this once as well, though I was not being sexually harassed. The boss simply hated me and was always asking me to be in several places at once, and blaming me for the mistakes of others. I quit, informed HR of the precise reasoning (I'd complained about her before), and several others did as well. She ended up fired after five people claimed her attitude as the reason they left.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By bnstone1
This is some of the worse advice I have ever heard! As former HR Rep for a refinery, harassment complaints (both sexual and personal) were the ones that were dealt with most seriously. Our workforce understood that harassment would get you a ticket out the gate sooner than any other Employee issue. And while not everyone want's to sue or complain the person being harassed does have a duty to draw attention to the problem and ask for it to stop. At that point, the company and harrasser are now on notice of the offense and should be both legally and morally bound to resolve. If not your local HR, a corporate contact, ombudsman, Supervisor in another area and ultimately the EEOC can all be involved. Yes, if all this fails you may need to look elsewhere but remember,like a rape case, it's not about the actions of the victim it's about the illegal activity of the perpetrator.
Reply