As I mentioned before, my personal trainer administered a body fat percentage test. I was going to keep the results shrouded under the veil of shame and discretion, but I have no dignity, and besides, revealing my number will help me prove a point.For background, you should know that my BMI (Body Mass Index) is in the normal range. Sure, it's on the high end of normal, separated from the overweight range by a few measly decimal points, but the important part is that it is separated.
Now, I know that BMI doesn't take frame size into account, and isn't perfectly accurate for shorter women like myself. Truthfully, I would like to lose almost 20 pounds. But my jaw literally dropped when I discovered that my body fat percentage, a whopping 34, falls into the "OBESE" category. OBESE, people. O-B-E-S-E.
I wear a size 10, for God's sake. So what this test underscored for me is that none of the numbers we use to measure and define ourselves, whether BMI, weight, size or body fat percentage, tell the whole story on their own.
Click here to read more about jump-roping and to see the surprising shape of a size 10 today.
For instance:

Each of the above women is a size 10. The number, by itself, is about as useful as I would be on a football team. I am not obese, but neither do I truly warrant placement in the "ideal weight" category. I find that a far more effective way to gauge the state of your body is by how it feels -- more specifically how it feels when you are, say, jumping rope.
I don't like to brag, but when I was young, I was something of a jump-rope prodigy. This was long ago, and back then, the favorite activities of the girls on my block were playing jacks (LOOK IT UP, KIDS) and holding vicious double-dutch competitions.
In elementary school phys. ed., we had a whole jump-rope unit, and once a traveling troupe of jumpers -- sort of the Harlem Globetrotters of jump rope -- came to perform for us at an assembly.
I had many career ambitions back in the day, but the only one that involved actual physical activity (unless you count "spy," which I would assume entails quite a bit of running), was "professional jump roper."
After my last personal training session, I found myself in one of the gym's fitness rooms, and I spied a bunch of jump ropes hanging on the wall. It had been years since I'd used one, contenting myself with Jillian Michaels' ropeless jumping exercises. Barely containing my glee, I snatched one up and whirled it around as I sprang into the air.
I landed with a thud. And another one. And while I kept going, everything about jumping rope felt different than I remembered, and not in a good way. I felt heavy and awkward; the floor seemed to shudder with every footfall. Gravity had never seemed quite so ... powerful. I was panting. For some reason, the image of the tutu-wearing hippos from "Fantasia" kept popping unpleasantly into my head.
So this is my goal, and how I will measure my progress. Numbers are ambiguous and misleading, but a jump rope doesn't lie. When I can jump rope and feel some amount of the springy, joyful ease I used to feel bouncing along on the sidewalk outside my house, I'll know my body has changed for the better.
(However, just to be clear, I am pretty sure my double-dutch days are over).
Alexa Stevenson tries out various exercise techniques and documents them every other week on Lemondrop.












Comments:
Add a comment
Friday 23 January
By Provocative Girl
I think that a BMI is a number that is way more important than the size of your clothes or the number that appears on the scale. It's measuring your fat to muscle ratio, and you always want to have more muscle than fat. But a size 10 isn't exactly the smallest size in the world. You mention that you aren't very tall and when you gain 5 lbs when you're only 5'3" then it won't look like you if you gained 5 lbs and you're 5'7". A size 10 for someone who is short rarely fall into the BMI range of normal. How you go from normal to obese, completely skipping over overweight is kinda shocking. I think one of the biggest issues today is people not noticing how much they really weigh. Over 2/3 of the country is over weight but I think everyone is just getting used to everyone else looking a little larger than they did 10 years ago. Kind of a "reverse anorexia" rather than a stick thin girl looking into the mirror and seeing someone who is chubby, a "reverse anorexic" will look into the mirror and see someone who is thin/healthy no matter what size they are. My mom says she has reverse anorexia all the time. So, you've got to listen to the numbers because even if you dont want to admit it the numbers don't lie ....
www.provocativeremarks.com
Reply
Friday 23 January
By Kate Baxter-Kauf
My elementary school had a jump-roping TEAM, which I was proudly on and could even do some basic tricks. I have NO idea if I could do any of them now, but you've made me think that I should try. I have no idea where, though, since Minnesota winters are not awesome for jump-roping outside, and I think I would feel ridiculous doing so at the Bally's.
And if you're obese, I shudder to see what the commenter above would say about me. Ridiculous.
Reply
Friday 23 January
By Jessica
I don't see how a size 10 can fall into the category of obese. I can't claim I understand all about BMI but there is no way someone who is size 10 and 5'3'' can be obese. Maybe it's on the overweight side, but not by much.
Jumping rope is hard. Just think about all the other things that children can do that become much harder as adults. Doing the monkey bars, pulling their bodies up, climbing ropes. I wish I was as strong as children are.
Reply
Friday 23 January
By cliff
Hi.
Mid 30s body fat for US women is normal. It is unhealthy, but normal, because most women (and men) in the US are fat. We have become used to everyone being fat/unhealthy, mostly because of our horrible diets, with our lack of exercise adding to the problem, but it's mostly our diet.
I changed my diet years ago, and it was different from most Americans. Then, my son (age 10) got diagnosed with Type I Diabetes. So we changed our diet again, making it more healthy. He recently got diagnosed with Celiac's Disease (no gluten/wheat), so we are changing our diet towards the more healthy end again.
However, compared with how my brother's family eats, our diet is STILL not very healthy. My brother's family actually eats a VERY healthy diet, and it is so far different from a normal American diet, that 90% of America would say it is strange/weird, and would not recognize what they eat, and in fact refuse to eat their food.
Americans eat total crap every day, and we get fatter and fatter, and think it's normal and OK. It IS "normal", but it's not OK.
You don't have to be skinny to be healthy, but you can't be fat and be healthy. That's a new thing, lately. If you're fat it's "normal", so you are healthy and OK. Wrong, wrong, wrong.
If you want to be the healthiest you can be, you (meaning ALL Americans) need to change your diet, and change it drastically. I would say that 80% of the crap in a typical grocery store is bad for you, and should not be eaten.
My wife is about 5' 10" - 145 lbs, and wears a size 6 tall. I am about 6' 4/5" - 185 lbs. and wear a 33'x36' jeans. We both struggle to try and stay healthy, because it is difficult to eat healthy food in today's America.
The sooner we (Americans) wake up and realize that the diet we eat is complete and total crap, the better off we will be. The restaurant and processed food that was see advertised, we buy, and we eat, is horrible for us. We are wasting billions of dollars on health care caused by our decision to make horrible dietary choices.
If you want to be healthy, good luck to you. It is VERY difficult to eat/act healthy in America. I hope that will change in the future.
God Bless!
cliff
GRB
Reply
Friday 23 January
By cliff
Hi.
Kate & Jessica: Your comments on the story are very normal and understandable. You think it is ridiculous that a short, size 10 women is obese, and you don't understand it.
Almost all Americans would agree with you.
That IS the problem. We are so used to us, and everyone we see being fat, and eating almost all horrible food choices, it seems normal, natural, and everyday to us. It IS normal to be fat and eat crappy "food" here in the US.
But, it is NOT healthy. We are fat, and we eat horrible food. If you actually had a healthy diet, then your friends and neighbors would be shocked if they knew, because it is so different from what they are eating.
Until we see being fat as unhealthy, and our diets as horrible, we will continue to waste billions of dollars on health care treatments that are needed to combat the affects of our unhealthy eating habits.
Good luck to all of you trying to change your lifestyle!
cliff
GRB
Reply
Saturday 24 January
By Amy T.
I am 5'3" also, and I have been working since September to get a healthy BMI. I started in a size 14 (tight) and am now in a size 10 (loose). I am 1 pound away from being "normal" by BMI standards. I am not sure how good the formula I use is, because it only takes into consideration height and weight. It does not take into account muscle mass or lack thereof and frame size. Like someone else mentioned, I am currently in the category "overweight", which is between "normal" and "obese".
I do not see myself as "fat" anymore at all, but I most certainly was 40lbs ago. Good luck to you!
Reply
Thursday 29 January
By Jennifer
Good comments from Cliff, as harsh as they may sound. It's so true, as I wander through the grocery store and think about all of the processed stuff that's not the best thing for me to eat. Years ago I remember a (healthy, ripped) female swim teammate saying, "don't eat anything that comes in a can or in a box." Using that as a general rule, I end up doing a lot more shopping in the fresh produce aisle (though canned garbanzo beans are still on my list), and therefore trick myself into staying away from lots of salt and fat that sneaks into packaged foods.
Another comment that hasn't been made (and, unfortunately this is going to sound harsh too): what Cliff says about us getting used to an unhealthy lifestyle, thinking it is normal, this is so true. Another indicator of this is the women's clothing industry and its vanity sizing. We may wear a size 10 or 12 and think that's great. But women's sizing numbers aren't a consistent measurement. We would be better served to look at a more absolute measurement, like inches around our waist and rear. I remember when I graduated from high school (in the late seventies), I wore a size 12. I weigh more now than I did then, yet I wear a size six now. That shows that the size six of today is the size 12 of 30 years ago. So women: don't be fooled by your dress size, it's another way that we Americans talk ourselves into thinking we're thin when we're really getting larger with each generation. Sad but true... and it's up to us to look past the processed food industry, and past women's vanity sizing brainwashing, if we really want to do what is right for our health.
We can do it though! The fact that we're all discussing it makes us more aware of what's going on, and we can make more informed decisions.
Reply
Thursday 29 January
By eemilya787
I just want to respond to Provocative Girl to say that the numbers do in fact lie, relying on BMI is a bad idea. BMI only takes into account height and weight, therefore it will categorize a very muscular person as overweight or obese. % body fat is a much better indicator of weight health. Of course, even that has it's problems due to measurement, mostly that if you rely on a bathroom scale to measure body fat it is not accurate. Bathroom scales only measure the body fat in the lower half of your body, therefore if you're a pear shaped woman it may overestimate your body fat. This is why the body fat scales at nutritionists' offices also have hand grips which send electrical current through your upper half. Luckily the bathroom scale is useful for telling you if there has been a change in your %body fat, which is all you should care about if you're trying to lose fat.
Reply