British officials are hitting below the belt in their recent efforts to decrease prostitution. Instead of trying to stem the supply of sex for sale by arresting suspected solicitors like we do in the States, last week they announced their plan to punish the men who purchase sex, with possible rape charges, fines and imprisonment.
Home Secretary Jacqui Smith is the Oz behind the curtain of the new laws, which aim to protect prostitutes who have been trafficked or exploited by pimps. And if a man claims he "didn't know" the woman he cavorted with was trafficked, or even if the woman told him she wasn't, he can still get in trouble.
Click here to read about other approaches to stemming prostitution -- including publicly shaming customers.
Rising Trend in Arrests
Smith, who brushes off the notion that some women choose to sell their bodies, is no original. She's simply following the lead of other countries that have attempted to simmer down the sex trade with a stiffer system.
Lithuania and Finland both have similar laws, and Norway is on its way to banning the buying of booty but not the sale. And Sweden all-out criminalized the purchasing of sex almost 10 years ago. There's proof that punishing the punter is working in that country: There are only around 500 prostitutes, down from 2,500 when the laws went into effect.
While a slap on the wrist has been the norm for high-profile johns like ex-New York governor Eliot Spitzer, our government is getting serious about pointing the finger at the other players in prostitution, including two international efforts.
Shaming Instead of Sentencing
Some cities are using their own unique methods to hold johns accountable. Chicago has taken the lead in targeting those who buy sex. Starting in 2005, the city's police began posting the names, photos and addresses of men arrested for engaging or soliciting prostitutes on its Web site and started a "john school" where they learned about the law and the life of a prostitute. In 2006, officials created a task force that targets pimps, traffickers and johns.
The Akron, Ohio, police department runs an "Operation John Be Gone" Web site that features those convicted of prostitution charges, and Charlotte, N.C., sometimes airs Shame TV, showing the names and faces of convicted johns. In the 1990s, Kansas City, Mo., and Denver, Colo., posted the images of people arrested for prostitution charges on a community-access TV channel. A few years ago in Oakland, Calif., officials started posting johns' faces on billboards that read "Don't John in Oakland."
At least two prostitution research and advocacy groups think focusing on the demand side of prostitution by picking on the purchasers is the way to go. But other experts say there will always be a problem as long as there are women seeking non-mainstream, under the table work.
Tell us: Should the U.S. focus on the supply or demand side of prostitution?












Comments:
Add a comment
Thursday 04 December
By hank
Thats right put the mans name out there and ruin his entire family not just him..... good lord what a bunch of idiots.... problem is the government is not getting its fair share of tax reveue..... if a woman wants to sell it and a man wants to buy it... why is if the governmetns business?? taxes my friends taxes~~~
Reply
Friday 05 December
By daria
no, it isnt always taxes my friend. some women are exploited and forced to have sex with other men and they dont even profit from it themselves. yes, target the man and if his family is embarassed...oh well,
Monday 02 March
By Jac
It is not anyone's business what goes on between two consenting adults. The only acceptable time for government intervention is if one is forcing themselves on someone else or hurting them in someway.
The way those people would have it just hurts innocent people that (well one at least) pay taxes and deserve better law enforcement.
KEEP THE PIGS OUT OF THE BEDROOM !!!!
Monday 08 December
By Anna
I say it needs to be legalized but heavily regulated. The women who work this profession need to be able to get legitimate rights, legal equality and protection, and health care. We need to get the johns, pimps, and traffickers off the streets and try to put an end to puritanical facades. The more something is criminalized, the farther it goes underground. The more this happens, the more people get hurt by it.
Reply
Saturday 06 December
By Leslie
Laws Laws what would they do if not for all these laws maybe life and keep their noses out of peoples lives.
Reply
Monday 08 December
By JO DE SANTIS WINTERGOLDSTEIN
PROSTITUTES "CHOOSE" THEIR PROFESSION. BECAUSE IT PAYS WELL
bottom line is there a profit in it?
THEY CHOOSE TO GO TO HELL LIKE ALL LIARS AND GOSSIPS the apathetic AND "CONTROL FREAKS"!
Reply
Tuesday 09 December
By CleverRich
Dumb, dumb, dumb. If a woman can sleep with a man for a chicken dinner, why can't just take the dough instead? I know this is in the UK, but we the people of the United States should do something about the illegality of prostitution. I think it's a non-issue and the gov. needs to get its nose out of a woman's personal, sexual business. I may not care for prostitution, but I should have no say in whether or not two consenting adults want to engage in sexual activity-regardless of whether cash exchanged hands. Prostitution doesn't encourage rape-it most likely minimizes it. If a guy is willing to shell out dough, he has no need to rape. Finally, some guys aren't 'clever' enough to succeed in the dating circles. What are they supposed to do for pleasure? Suffer? Come on people, we need to wake up. Trying to stop prostitution is like trying to stop the ebb and flow of the tide-it ain't happenin'!
®
Reply
Monday 22 December
By Stan
Right on
Tuesday 09 December
By Katie
Actually, to all those who think Prostitution is a choice for most women, you're quite wrong. Girls don't exactly grow up thinking, "I wanna be a prostitute! Thats so much better than a Doctor or Veteranarian!" Unfortunate circumstances lead these women to be sold into what is effectivley slavery. The "Pimp" recieving most if not all of the money.
And for the idiots who believe Prostitution doesn't promote rape, well, i really don't know what to say to you. You're obviously too far gone to even consider logic. Rape is not a purely sexual act. Its about control, demeaning, hurting the victim.
A "John" has control by paying money. The woman becomes an object, not a human being. Just as slaves were bought and sold because they were considered sub-human, so are prostitutes. If someone has that view of women (ie: the "john") its not exactly a leap to rape. These sick freaks get their rocks off by hurting, deameaning and controling women (and men).
Don't let this continue because of someone's family being embarassed. I'd much rather have a family member of mine exposed than continue hurting people.
Reply
Wednesday 31 December
By ralphgmiami
Prostitution is illegal in the United States except for hotels and casino in Las Vegas and in Reno, Nevada. Prostitutes in Florida don't run rampant because in strip club there are friction dances. In friction dances, a man pays a dancer to rub up against his privates. Yes she wears shorts and is topless. The man is wearing pants. However, I have heard there are private champagne rooms where the woman can get naked and also the man. I don't know what goes on there as I have heard this by rumor only. If that is true, he can possibly penetrate her to comit fornication and illicit sex. Sure she is getting paid. My guess is that I prostitute can make money in one of these strip clubs also. Only the dancers or workers themselves know who is really having sex for money or just giving regular friction dances.
Reply
Saturday 28 February
By Alex Cleveland
Don't like something make a law against it. The great American way.
We never ever stop wars, let see war on drugs doesn't work, war on sex
has never worked. So why did we give up on war on alcohol???
Think about it , if a man is not married wants sex, rape is not for me.
Beating women up for it is not for me. Don't always have a girl friend around
whats a guy to do. Wait wait i know just suffer.
I am a criminal so you may just as well go ahead and put me in prison
for the way i think. I would pay for sex in a heart beat. You do it anyway you
just call it something else. Hey i just woke up in communist America.
Reply
Wednesday 18 March
By Bobby
I visit prostitutes because, # 1. They never have a headache. 2. They don't have gas. 3. They never say, "Oh, not tonight". They really never say, no.! Now, isn't that wonderful ? I think so, and most of the women I know need the money for their very existence. Far be it from me to deny someone a little stimulus payment.
God Bless all the prostitutes. I LOVE EM' ! ! !
Reverend Bob
Reply
Friday 17 April
By perry
yes, punish the johns
Reply
Friday 17 April
By perry
many prostitutes live terrible lives...
some don't, but most do....
do you really want to patronize that?
a real prostitute wouldn't embarrase herself on a street corner....
she would take good care of herself, keep it clean and keep it private...
most women on the street arent thinking straight, when i see a prostitute i see a woman who was probably abused as a kid... i cannot patronize that
Reply