Present predicament: You ask your gentleman caller for some hints about what he wants under the tree, and he grunts something to the effect of "Oh, nothing." Agggh!

We say: Figure out a price point you're comfortable with based on your situation (both financial and degree of romantic seriousness), and then get him something that shows you know his personality. And when in doubt, go for something fun and playful -- after all, he is a guy.

Scroll through our gift guide below for some of the best presents you can give to your guy, no matter what he's into.

Click here for more cool gift ideas.

Gift Guide for the New Boyfriend

    For the preppy guy: Nautica White Sail Cologne for Men $32.50, Kohl's.

    For the classic boyfriend: Citizen Silver-Tone Watch Set $180, Kohl's.

    For the crime-solving boyfriend: An Interactive Sherlock Holmes Mystery $18, Amazon.

    For the biker: Men's Wood Grain Belt with Buckle $65, Fred Flare.

    For your constantly lost fiancee: Garmin Nuvi 255 GPS $174.25 - $299.99, AOL Shopping.

    For the hipster boyfriend who's sick of his Converse: Camper sneakers $152, Edge of Urge.

    For the gamer: Nintendo Wii Gum $3.50, Fractal Spin.

    For the writer: 5-Year Journal $24.95, Rare Device.

    For the earthy boyfriend: Men's Morrocco Necklace $68, ShopSCAD.

    For the movie buff: Vintage movie posters Prices range from $7.99 and up, E Movie Poster.