Income, sales and property are proud to welcome a new little guy to the tax family: the plastic bag! Seattle, Los Angeles, Dallas and New York City lead the list of American cities considering the plastic-bag tax, which has already been implemented all over Europe. The concept: Charge a fee at the register for every plastic bag a shopper uses, promoting reusable shopping bags and more environmentally sound bagging alternatives.
Seattle was all set to be the first American city to implement the tax (a 20-cent-per-bag charge intended to start January 1), but grocery stores and the plastic-bag industry collected enough signatures to force the matter to wait for a citywide vote next August. New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg recently called for a six-cent-per-bag fee, with one cent of it going to grocers for their compliance.
Who Will Speak for the Plastic Bags?
While these plans may sound like simple eco-conscious brilliance, there is another side to the matter. At a Palo Alto, Ca., city council meeting, groups including the American Chemistry Council and SaveThePlasticBag.com expressed concern that the tax would cut into grocers' revenues, force a shift to equally harmful paper bags and undercut recent advances in plastic-bag recycling. (There's also concern from the general public that the tax takes environmental awareness a little too far, but we're not convinced that's really possible.)
Story continues below
Guilt-Free Grocery Shopping
1AEON Bear Tote Bag
Especially good for the more treacherous grocery stores. ($20, Supermarket)
Supermarket
Drawflowers Blue Damask Shopping Bag
Made of vintage French wallpaper from the '70s. ($39, Etsy)
Etsy
Envirosax Flora Pouch
The original reusable shopping bag. ($37.95/5, Envirosax)
Envirosax
M. Carter Waves Tote
Just as fun as the designer's trademark t-shirts. ($20, M. Carter)
M. Carter
Albinoberlin Catchall Shoulder Bag
With tons of inner pockets, this one can double as a purse. (69 eu., DaWanda)
DaWanda
Old Bag Crafts Carrier Bags
Comes with a little drawstring pouch for easy storage -- perfect to stash in your purse for whenever you need it. ($15/2, Etsy)
Etsy
Wren Organic Coffee Sling Bag
Made of recycled fair trade Jute coffee sacks and lined with organic hemp, these bags are super sturdy, guilt-free and totally one-of-a-kind. ($58, Etsy)
Etsy
Showpony Embellished Bag
Dress up your grocery shopping with these fun almost-fancy totes. ($30, Etsy)
Etsy
Bum Bags Floral Skull Tote
Comes in your choice of color. (8 eu., DaWanda)
DaWanda
Reiter8 Number 8 Sail Tote
Made of recycled sailboat sails. ($75, Etsy)
Supermarket
While no U.S. city has yet to implement the tax, some stores have. The Ikea chain started charging five cents per plastic bag in 2007, and saw a huge decrease in usage. Other grocery stores, including Whole Foods Market, offer a discount of a few cents to customers who shop with reusable bags.
Tell us: What's your opinion on the plastic-bag tax? Would you be happy or upset to see one implemented?
Also on Lemondrop: More eco-friendly ingenuity! Check out these dresses made of everything but boring old fabric.
Really Stupid Hats
Oh deer, there's a deer on my head.
Getty Images
Couture welding gear.
Getty Images
Flower arrangement from a funeral home.
Getty Images
Fashionista pirate.
Getty Images
Hatbox hat.
Getty Images
Lego my hat.
Getty Images
Modelcorn horn.
Getty Images
Rat's nest head gear.
Getty Images
Sad clown model.
Getty Images
Channeling Space Invaders.
Getty Images














Comments:
Add a comment
Wednesday 19 November
By Ame
I am all about the plastic bag tax. They are wasteful and besides, I use my tote for other things than geocerys and shopping. When I stay at my boyfriends house I use it to carry my clothes and whatnots in...
And besides, if they pass the tax on the plastic bag, you are going to pay more in the long run than if you buy a few reuseable totes...
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By Joanna
Its not a tax, but Sav a Lot has been charging for plastic bags for years. 3 cents for the little flimsy ones and 10 cents for the big sturdier ones. If you don't bring your own and you don't want to buy them they have stacks of boxes for people to carry home their groceries in - boxes that the store would have had to pay to throw away.
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By DoctorBob
I went shopping at Walmart recently and took along my own canvas bag. Not only would the checkout troll NOT allow me to use it in place of Walmart's plastic bags; she insisted that I put my canvas bag inside a Walmart bag "to show the guy at the door that I had paid for my merchandise." So much for cutting down on plastic in the landfill.
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By ira
I like the plastic bags. I use them when I scoop my cat box.
Reply
Thursday 20 November
By Vicki
I also use them for my cat box, I also use them for my garbage they are the perfect size for 2 people. Isn't that called recycling?
Wednesday 19 November
By krwstar
I'm all for methods to reduce use of plastic bags. Reduction for bringing your own bag is a great idea. There are too many given out for the sake of 'convenience'. The reusables hold so much more than the plastic ones. I tell the cashiers that I don't want a bag and leave the store many times with a few items in my hand when I forget my own bag. I've even bought bags and given them to out others. It's an easy habit to get used to for more than one reason.
And I have a cat, too; even so, can't possibly use all the plastic bags I get from shopping.
Let's all try it, refuse a bag some time and see how good it feels.
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By timbo
nutcase u r timbo says......
Thursday 20 November
By jmuhj
I reuse every plastic bag I get and I need them. Paper bags just don't cut it and the cloth bags are completely ridiculous for reuse to bag rubbish. How about cutting out styrofoam and waxed paper junk food containers -- and while we're at it, the muck that comes in it -- instead?
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By gbense
Hip, hip, hooray. I already use my own canvas bags, rather than suffer through those horrible plastic ones. I first started using Re-usable bags about 10 years ago, when N.Y. City Grocer D'Agostino started promoting them, in their markets. I've never regretted it, and I'm always encouraging friends and family to drop the plastic. My favorite Grocer today, ShopRite, now offers a 5 cents per canvas bag off your grocery bill, for every re-usable canvas bag you bring with you. That's cool. Now I'm getting paid, for being environmentally conscious!
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By timbo
i like plastic bags, i put them over my head and twist.........i need air...lol
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By L Sanderson
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration tested waters in many parts of every ocean. They found that no matter how deep they tested, no waters were free of degraded plastic. This means every living thing in the oceans, including anything we eat, cannot keep from ingesting plastic. Going too far? I support this tax.
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By Cyndi
I save my plastic bags and use them for packing mtls for shipping and other household things (sm trash can liner). My only concern is that we shop big once a month. There are a lot of bags. I use my tote for a quick trip during the weeks. But the totes don't seem practical for our large family shopping. We usually have two carts now, I think I would need a third to carry all the totes. lol I would pay a tax once a month.
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By natasha
i think its great to promote recycling by encuraging consumers to drop the plastic though i must admit, i hate to give away any more of my hard earned cash when i happen to make an impromptu dash to the market and end up being charged for plastic. also, the article stated that ikea charges for plastic bags. here in maryland, ikea doesn't even carry plastic anymore. if u don't purchase one of their totes, ur stuck carrying loads of nifty gadgets out the door by hand.
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By Bill
dumb dumb dumb whats next. time for a enviroment tazx on stinky perfumes, high calorie foods, toilet paper, writing paper, newspapers, sports and concert tickets, new clothes, old clothes, politicians who do a lousy job, big business that overcharges, little businesses that overcharge, and the list goes on and on. oh and most of all on attorneys who come up with all these dumb laws.
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By Shelley
In a time when money is tight, I am VERY opposed to any of my money going to something like a "plastic bag tax". I am apalled that so many people are agreeing to another tax on the middle class. I use a combination of plastic and reusable. I reuse my plastic bags for everything from dirty clothes when I go out of town, to bathroom garbage liners, to lunch bags, to carry things to and from work, to school projects for my kids. Thank you but I already give enough of my money to people who do not deserve and do not manage it well. Anyone who agrees with this tax is nothing more than bunch of "koolaid" drinkers...following an idea because it sounds politically correct. I think I will keep my money for me and mine thank you very much.
Reply
Thursday 20 November
By theused
WTF this is the most moronic thing ever, they invented the plastic bag because it was easier/cheaper/ and better now they want to tax people for something they started, I don't think so
If they start doing this to me, guess what I'll take your shopping cart home instead of the plastic bag, does that sound better?
What happens if you by chance one day forget to bring the canvas bags to the grocery store?
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By Sports Fan
Why bother taxing, just don't make them available ala Costco. No big whoop.
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By CallMeLater
How pathetic is this ?? With all the disposable (non-recyclable) things that are thrown away everyday... plastic bags tops the list... How about foods that are sold as "one serving"... alot of plastics thrown out there.. all the cans and glass that end up in the dump and it is plastic bags that causes the worries. Pathetic. How many of you whiners actually recycle anything ??
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By Bill
I can just see it now ... people lined up to return their plastic bags; to exchange them for a different size; to replace the ones that tore, as they all do. A tax on plastic bags ... a charge for plastic bags? Totally ridiculous! The bag costs a small fraction of one cent to manufacture and everything in the store is already marked up to cover the cost of things like plastic bags. So, in effect, we will be charged twice for the same thing. I don't like it and I'll let them know.
Reply
Wednesday 19 November
By Julaine
I believe the concern is the environment, I use both reusable and plastic and I do use the plastics for trash liners, cleaning out the cat box etc. but the fact remains that they do not biodegrade in land fills or in our water ways. I'm not sure taxing is the ticket, perhaps just not having them anymore as stated previously some stores just don't offer them.
Reply